2 ms·
> I'm a little surprised at the contrast between the contents of the paper and how people have described it on HN. I haven't read the paper beyond the abstract
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> I'm a little surprised at the contrast between the contents of the paper and how people have described it on HN.
I haven't read the paper beyond the abstract yet, so can't comment on it's contents, but can you specify what you mean by "how people have described it on HN"?
To be frank, I don't like this style of argument, because I literally don't know what you're referring to. I'm quite familiar with the hubbub that happened when Gebru left Google, but feelings around what happened there shouldn't be misconstrued as feedback on this paper specifically.
In other words, if you think that people are arguing that this paper is "outside the realm of valid academic discourse", I think you should call out what you're referring to, because I haven't seen that as a widely held opinion. It feels like a straw man, or at the very least you are discounting some very specific critiques other commenters have made by just broadly referring to "HN sentiment".
- hardwaregeek 4y agoApologies, I assumed it would be clear from the other comments. When I posted this the top comment was a very visibly negative take on the paper. Similarly, Google must have considered this paper to be sufficiently outside the realm of valid academic discourse because their actions around the release of this paper lead to the termination of a couple authors and a PR snafu.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThanks for explaining. FWIW, I don't think your last sentence is a fair assessment of what happened at all. Pointing out major deficiencies in a paper is not the same thing as saying it's "sufficiently outside the realm of valid academic discourse", and, having closely followed the news when this all went down, it's clear that it's what happened in the aftermath of this paper that led to the terminations - it's not like Google said "this paper is so bad, you're fired".
- hardwaregeek 4y agoI can’t speak to the aftermath but even interfering in the publication of the paper is pretty dramatic. If Google had let it go through and not said anything, or at worst published a milquetoast response saying they disagree but respect the discourse, I don’t think the paper would have had half the attention. If your scientists publish a paper that is not even wrong, do you ask them to retract it? Shouldn’t the response from the larger academic community be enough?