6 ms·
My perspective is that “protecting this planet’s life” is just more human narcissism (this isn’t a jab at you, it’s a very common mindset). Short of total ster
by Waterluvian 4y ago
My perspective is that “protecting this planet’s life” is just more human narcissism (this isn’t a jab at you, it’s a very common mindset).
Short of total sterilization, mass extinction events seem to be really good at creating space for new forms of life to develop. In a way, preventing them in the name of the non-human life here is just picking the incumbent over whatever comes next. How would we feel if aliens stopped the mass extinction events that led to our existence? I’m not sure there’s solid argument for why one is more deserving of existence than the other.
I think why this slightly rubs me the wrong way is it feels like an excuse to make us feel good. Non-human life seems by and large indifferent to its long-term fate on this planet. Let’s not pretend we do anything significant for non-human life that isn’t to our direct benefit.
Just my perspective. Not trying to say “no, you’re wrong!” Just, “I disagree.” I’m going to guess there’s an entire named branch of philosophy that explores this.
- 77pt77 4y agoMost of what humans call human reasoning is actually motivated reasoning. Excuses if you will.
- dymk 4y agoHumans are really good at causing mass extinctions - just look at how we've literally decimated the planet's biodiversity since the dawn of man! That's a lot of new space for new lifeforms to specialize in.
- Waterluvian 4y agoBut to our narcissistic displeasure, the biosphere acts on a very different time scale. But points to us for a world record pace speedrun on the downturn side of it. It’ll eventually bloom again once we’re done here.
- rapind 4y agoThe biggest brain fart of humanity is our tendency towards monoculture (for scale). Nature is very obviously showing us how to sustain an ecosystem and yet in our incredible hubris we’re like “nah, we got this”. We just want to swim upstream for the hell of it.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI think one of our greatest flaws (and possibly main reason we are here today) is that we’re so self-centered. Why do we monoculture if it will kill us long-term? Because it benefits us short-term. (And hey, maybe that gives us runway to solve the long-term problem).
- XorNot 4y agoNature doesn't try and do anything. Nature is constantly trying to murder everything around it. The most lethal diseases to man are natural, and often common skin bacteria which everyone carries. There's a viral form of cancer which is wiping out the Tasmanian Devil right now, just because. Nature and evolution has no plan and no morality, it has survivors and a balanced ecosystem is a cold war stalemate.
- rapind 4y agoNature is teaching us how to survive by trying to constantly murder us and everything else if you prefer. So we can gain knowledge by seeing what works for other surviving species around us.
- ASalazarMX 4y ago> How would we feel if aliens stopped the mass extinction events that led to our existence? I would wager than as soon as a technological civilization is born, it's morally reprehensible to let it go extinct, since it no longer is at the full whims of evolution. It's complex issue, so many people would wage otherwise, and only a jury might reach a conclusion. The case is moot when said civilization can avert extinction by their own hand, though. I don't know about two technological civilizations in conflict, like sapiens and neanderthals. Would it be morally acceptable to let them go at each other, even if the fittest extinguishes the other?
- Waterluvian 4y ago> I would wager than as soon as a technological civilization is born, it's morally reprehensible to let it go extinct, since it no longer is at the full whims of evolution. I see the logic here. But why, though? And technology is everywhere in non-human nature. While I think our technology and civilization is unlike anything else here, it’s still on the spectrum of nature’s exercise of community and technology. Are we really that special? I think this heads towards the whole “Prime Directive” line of reasoning. P.S. Eloi > Morlocks, of course. ;)
- avgcorrection 4y ago> I see the logic here. There’s no logic there. Just a faith in “potential”. It is arguable one way or the other whether civilizational humans have caused more happiness or more suffering for Earth (all of us lifeforms combined). So the only way to call such a thing “morally reprehensible” is if you assume that Civilization will eventually evolve into some awesome, fantastic, space-faring, all-needs-met, stewards of the near solar system fantasticness.
- interestica 4y agoI'm not sure there's a well defined line for that "birth" -- especially if looked at by a well-advanced civilization. Maybe "technological civilizations" have a tendency to destroy themselves pretty quickly and it becomes wasted energy to intervene too early. So perhaps an external viewer might look at more of a fuzzy demarkation of a few thousand years. Are we there yet?
- TylerLives 4y agoGiven how long it takes for complex life forms to develop, and how other planets known to us don't seem to have any life at all, I think it's reasonable to prefer the existing life to the future potential life, even from a non-anthropocentric perspective.
- chki 4y agoBut why? Why are algae better than rocks and ants better than algae if you take humans out of the equation?
- hgsgm 4y agoComplexity is interesting.
- chki 4y agoWhy is complexity interesting if there are no humans to observe it?
- PKop 4y agoCloser to us, and we are great.
- TylerLives 4y agoI think simpler life forms have no chance of surviving long term. Though now that I think about it, you could say caring about that is anthropocentric too. I don't think it's possible to truly be objective because it would require us to escape our own perspectives, but there should at least be some objective measures for this question. Without that, the question is meaningless. Number of species, average lifetime and average happiness seem sufficiently objective to me.
- the_af 4y agoSimpler lifeforms have been one of the most persistent and successful lifeforms on Earth, with a way longer existence than mammals. In fact, some theories postulate they are capable of interplanetary colonization, something we still cannot do!
- closewith 4y agoTotal sterilisation is a guaranteed outcome on a long enough time line.
- dctoedt 4y ago> I’m not sure there’s solid argument for why one is more deserving of existence than the other. Maybe we're helping to build a universe, and we can do more in that regard than single-celled organisms, cockroaches, etc.? https://www.questioningchristian.org/2006/06/metanarratives_.html https://www.questioningchristian.org/2006/06/metanarratives_... (self-cite)
- Waterluvian 4y agoI love this line of thinking. It gets me excited about Sci-fi. But I think we may already have the technology to seed life elsewhere. We won’t do it though because it’s unsatisfying to our narcissism. Imagine trying to sell the world on a trillion dollar project where we shoot loads of bio-goo out into the cosmos in thousands of directions, knowing it’ll take eons to maybe have an effect that’ll then take billions of years to produce a result we will never appreciate. I think if we do any sort of proliferation of life, it’ll be of us, by us, for us.
- hgsgm 4y ago> Imagine trying to sell the world on a trillion dollar project where we shoot loads of bio-goo out into the cosmos in thousands of directions, It's funny to imagine that this might be not how life on Earth started.
- polishdude20 4y agoIf the universe causes an asteroid to hit earth and make all life extinct or let's new life flourish, us saving the earth from said asteroid is also an outgrowth of the universe. We are not separate from nature and protecting the earth is only natural for a multicellular intelligent species like ourselves.
- Waterluvian 4y agoFor sure! And if a meteor is heading our way, I’ll be on the top of that hill with my Louisville Slugger. I just think we shouldn’t pretend that we’re being altruistic.
- the_af 4y agoI think the argument is not that mankind preventing a mass extinction event is unnatural, but rather that mass extinction events seem both natural and necessary for the rise of new life forms, and as such are "neutral" rather than bad events (except from the perspective of mankind, which would be rendered extinct). So it can be argued that you are not necessarily making a "favor" to Earth's ecosystem.
- wonderwonder 4y agoPersonally, who cares? I think I and probably most of humanity if given a choice between the survival of the human species and the birth of some philosophical new species that may never even exist, we choose humanity every time. Going even further if given the choice of humanity over any other existing species we choose humanity. I see no issue with this choice either, we are a part of nature and Darwinism built us to want to survive and spread.
- m4rtink 4y agoThis is really a non issue to start with - once space settlement really gets going, we will spawn many more spacies, as the various groups go farther apart and evolve/modify themselves and all the life they took with them. It could even result in funny situations where one of them encounters a clearly alien beings with totally different physiology, culture, appearance and language - only ot find they are just another branch of life originating from Earth. :-)
- hparadiz 4y ago> mass extinction events seem to be really good at creating space for new forms of life to develop To what end? Life on this planet has about a 1 billion year run way left since the sun will start to expand and eventually strip away Earth's atmosphere and finally swallow the planet whole. It's taken 3.7 billion years to get to this point and most of the "interesting" evolution has occurred in only the last 500 million years. So it is true that the next 500 million should be even more diverse. However unless another intelligent life form develops the point is moot. No matter how smart a dolphin, or raven, or chimp, or octopus is... if it can't escape this rock then it's not much different from a bacteria colony that dies out when it's food source is exhausted. Evolution is random. For all we know an even more intelligent form of life will develop than us humans but on the other hand it's possible that for the next billion years we are the only fluke in the evolutionary timeline and nothing else will develop. Finally there's a third option that is within the grasp of humanity which is to say we can branch off Earth's tree of life and take it into space while leaving Earth to develop as it will.
- Waterluvian 4y agoA billion years seems to be a LOT of time for many mass extinction events. I think your argument leans on “interesting” a lot, which has its basis in our narcissism. Again, it only feels important that the life be “interesting” if we’re here to care. Just to restate: I’m not saying we don’t act selfishly. I sure would. Let’s just not pretend we’re being altruistic.
- hparadiz 4y agoThe vast majority of evolutionary complexity has evolved in the past 500 million years. That's what I meant by "interesting". Things like flowering plants. It has absolutely nothing to do with our branch of the tree of life. So I'm not sure where your accusation of narcissism is coming from. For all I know a flowering plant will develop a brain and become sentient in the next 200 million years.
- lovemenot 4y ago
- hackinthebochs 4y ago>I'm not sure there’s solid argument for why one is more deserving of existence than the other. I think an existence bias is defensible. Take it as an axiom that suffering is bad and flourishing is good. I think its clear that the suffering of something that exists is worse than the lack of flourishing of something that doesn't exist but could. Value is something that conscious creatures do, and so value depends on existence. The states of something that can prefer its own states should be valued over the states of something that can't. Existing fish matter more than rocks and potential fish. So the organisms that exist, at least the sentient ones, should take preference.
- lcw 4y agoThere are a bunch of weak arguments here. > How would we feel if aliens stopped the mass extinction events that led to our existence? This statement is just appealing to emotion and is commonly used in arguments against abortion or attempts to thought police. There is nothing provable or disprovable in your argument and this question is used to just try and bait people into an emotional response. > Non-human life seems by and large indifferent to its long-term fate on this planet. I would argue that self preservation is an innate characteristics of every plant and animal on this earth. Isn't a desire to live the basis for self preservation? Isn't it natural for a plant or animal to stop something from killing them if it impedes in their ability to survive? At a basic level plants compete for sunlight at the expense of other plants. If there was an cognitive leap in a plant or animal wouldn't it be natural for anything to protect their greater habitat? If that's narcissistic than I guess it's the most natural narcissism I can think of.
- the_af 4y ago> This statement is just appealing to emotion and is commonly used in arguments against abortion or attempts to thought police Your statement itself seems like a fallacy to me. It makes sense to me that the comment you're replying to is emotional, because it's not meant to be a "proof" but an opinion, and it's valid to have emotional opinions; moreover, it was a reply to a comment which was in itself an emotional appeal! Self-preservation is not innately good (or bad). Mass extinction events seem to have been good at giving rise to species that are now self-preserving; maybe a new mass extinction would give rise to even "better" species. As a human, I'd rather we didn't go extinct. I'd rather mankind prospered and even spread out to more planets. But I'm ok with anthropocentric appeals to emotion :)
- themitigating 4y agoI think he's right. The person isn't offering an opinion they are asking "how would you feel". They want the other person to form an opinion biased by an emotion
- lcw 4y agoI see what your saying in regard to me trying to appeal to emotion by using a topic like abortion. However, my intent in the example was/is that emotions are high in these topics and are used to give some opinions more attention than they deserve. In this case I feel like the main point of the parent commenter was not a well formed opinion and as such the commenter was trying to appeal to emotion. I'm not trying to say they can't say something like what they said here. This is a perfect place to have a discussion. > Self-preservation is not innately good (or bad) I agree with you. The parent comment that I was responding to does not agree with this statement. That's clear when they say "what rubs me the wrong way", and referring to work done in the name of human preservation as narcissism.