4 ms·
The esp32-6 is a great example of why these types of clients are never good Wi-Fi citizens - it supports about half the Wi-Fi 6 enhancements a normal client wou
by zamadatix 4y ago
The esp32-6 is a great example of why these types of clients are never good Wi-Fi citizens - it supports about half the Wi-Fi 6 enhancements a normal client would, does it with a single antenna, and only does it in 2.4 GHz. Better than previous microcontrollers doing 802.11n for sure but it still includes Bluetooth anyways and Bluetooth has more powersaving/congestion avoidance features unless you need lots of data (which this is not good at doing even with Wi-Fi). Even with things like RUs Wi-Fi is still only as good as the worst clients in the airspace let it be.
802.11ah (Wi-Fi HaLow) was intended to serve these types of devices in a separate spectrum with a very different set of features (and 802.11ax later brought some of these features over for normal clients to take advantage of but ignored many specific to IoT only use cases) but it never caught on vs LoRa and Bluetooth.
- rektide 4y agoDo you have any links talking about what wifi-6 capabilities are missing? I was under the impression capabilities like OFDMA were mandatory on uplink & downlink for "WiFi 6". Ditto for Target Wake Time. In general, while wifi might not always be the best pick, I also see it working very well in many challenging environments, and I think the expectation that low end devices are necessarily bad for the network isnt going to hold forever. The legacy 802.11b devices have left a lot of emotional scars & pain, and wifi 4 & 5 had many limitations that made low-end devices a network tax, but it seems like we really finally are on the way to better. I was aware of 802.11ah somewhat, but admit I had forgotten just how many tweaks/optizations went into it. Time division/grouping I'd forgotten about. TWT seems like a good help here. It also seems to lack the key thing that should hopefully be decreasing congrestion, which is ppwer control, which should hopefully greatly reduce congestion in most scenarios, by making devices not always be shoutintg at each other. Admittedly it seems like a large number of esp32 users do struggle woth throughput, which sucks. A quick scan around the net & Im seeing very few users get above 12Mbps. Many see huge gains from improving bad board design, which seems to compound the issue. WiFi 6 has great potential, but as usual, there's many paths abound to screw up a good thing.