3 ms·
i don't get why some studies have so few partipants. How hard is it to recruit people for something like this? We're not talking rare diseases.
by paulpauper 4y ago
i don't get why some studies have so few partipants. How hard is it to recruit people for something like this? We're not talking rare diseases.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- subharmonicon 4y agoFrom what I have read in the past this is just how the funding tends to work. You write a grant proposal for a study with 20 people, get funding, get results, use that to get funding for another study with 200, then 2000, etc. Frequently they don’t manage to make it past the first couple levels because the results aren’t interesting.
- 3pt14159 4y agoAny study less than 200 people is essentially false advertising unless the population size is incredibly small (e.g., rare diseases) or the intervention has a crazy high prior (e.g., does getting shot in the chest lead to blood loss leading to passing out) so I consider these grants completely counter productive. There is a real benefit in having fewer pieces of junk to sort out and so many of these medical research studies are just noise that well meaning members of the public cite and adopt into practice because they don't know any better. It's the modern day version of leeches, essentially.
- subharmonicon 4y agoRather than “well meaning members of the public”, I think the larger problem is with health and science reporting which frequently reports findings of very small studies as if they are definitive fact, with very prominent and provocative headlines.
- 3pt14159 4y ago> health and science reporting Is part of "well meaning members of the public" just as "YouTube commentary" is and "random celebrity that Googles something and repeats it on Twitter." And quite frankly, so are scientists themselves. I have met far, FAR too many scientists that do not know the very first thing about statistics and yet feel competent to reference other people's research. This is why I say it's a big pile of leeches for more than half this stuff. Sure the incentives are misaligned, sure its reporting, sure this and that. But what we really need here are people to say "no you idiot leeches don't do dittly squat to fix this problem."
- belltaco 4y agoAll that screening and testing costs a lot of money.
- daviddavis 4y agoNutritional studies are notoriously difficult to conduct. You either have to isolate subjects and monitor everything they eat and when. Or you have to rely on self reported data and people do an atrocious job of tracking food, estimating portion size, etc. This study did the former: > The duration of the study is 7 days including 3 days with controlled diet and 4 days (including 5 nights) in a metabolic chamber at the Institute of Nutritional Medicine at the University of Hohenheim. I imagine it was prohibitively expensive to have more participants.
- bee_rider 4y agoTry plinking around on a sample size calculator a bit, the results might be surprising. For example: https://www.surveymonkey.com/mp/sample-size-calculator/ https://www.surveymonkey.com/mp/sample-size-calculator/ If you are ok with a 25% margin of error and a 95% confidence level, 16 people is good enough. You have to make sure there isn’t some skew in your population, but if your method of sampling the population produces a skew, adding people won’t really help there.