4 ms·
I had a mixed experience with FIRST, but it probably had more to do with my individual team than the program itself. I spent my freshman year on my high school'
by fecklessyouth 15y ago
I had a mixed experience with FIRST, but it probably had more to do with my individual team than the program itself. I spent my freshman year on my high school's team, which was one of the top in the country. It was very professionalized and well-funded.
It was also easy to get overlooked. I got into the website niche and ended up spending the entire build season mostly working on Photoshop. I knew next to nothing about our actual robot. Unsurprisingly, I was bored at competitions.
I had originally joined because I thought I wanted to be an engineer, but I got sidetracked by web design. I realized this after my freshman year, but was kicked off the team, since we had to conduct interviews every year. The advisors saw that I didn't enjoy the competitions and figured my spot would be better used by someone else. So I never actually learned anything about engineering in a year of FIRST. No one ever pulled me into it and I lost my first and only chance to do it myself.
I often look back at that event as a pivotal one, since the absence of FIRST led to my interest in the arts, politics, etc. Had I spent the whole fours years working on the actual robot, I might have go onto engineering schools, or programming, or all sorts of things completely removed from the liberal arts environment I'm in now.
But that's all speculation. I still wish I would have learned more programming while I was in it.
- jeremymcanally 15y agoI found your experience to be fairly common especially on the "professional" teams. Most teams are basically just ways for sponsors to live vicariously through the kids. The actual mechanisms are rarely built and programmed by students, especially on teams with tons of sponsor money and engineer coaches. I'm glad FIRST seems to have finally noticed this and started the stock car equivalent of FIRST, which lets smaller teams actually be competitive instead of getting bulldozed by the team with the fancy logo and space age CNC'd robot with the all titanium transmission.