4 ms·
> They don’t rely on individualized suspicion, which is what’s required under the Fourth Amendment [to the U.S. Constitution] That's definitely a "citation nee
by tzs 4y ago
> They don’t rely on individualized suspicion, which is what’s required under the Fourth Amendment [to the U.S. Constitution]
That's definitely a "citation needed" statement.
In Skinner v. Railway Labor Executives’ Ass’n, 489 U.S. 602 (1989) the Court upheld mandatory drug testing for railway employees involved in accidents or safety violations despite no probable cause or individualized suspicion.
In Michigan Dep’t of State Police v. Sitz, 496 U.S. 444 (1990) the Court upheld sobriety check points in which all cars are briefly stopped for questioning and observation. There's no individualized suspicion there. See also the cases involving border patrol checkpoints. A checkpoint 50 miles from the border doesn't involve any individualized suspicion.
Individualized suspicion is required I believe to target an individual, but hasn't targeting a place where a crime has been committed to get more information to try to figure what individuals might be involved been standard, uncontroversial, police procedure in the United States for hundreds of years?
E.g., if a clearly murdered body is found in a maid's closet at a hotel when the maids go to start their shift in the morning police are going to get a warrant to get the list of all staff and guests that were known to be in the hotel between the time the closet was last known to be dead body free and the time the body was discovered.
That seems at least somewhat similar to a geofence warrant and has been pretty normal since basically forever.
- richardhod 4y agoBeing 'normal' != is constitutional
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ModernMech 4y agoKind of, it's weird. There's "the Constitution" the document, which has some words in it. Then there's "the Constitution" the spirit, which is what the American public feels abut the document, irrespective of the words therein. The two are never quite the same, and the latter is often the deciding factor when it comes to writing laws. The former factor, carefully parsing the words in the context of laws, has been where the courts come in. But these days is seems the court's view on the Constitution is colored as much by their feelings about the words as the words taken literally themselves. For example, for decades one court can say that a right to privacy is implied by the Constitution, and then suddenly a new court can completely flip that. Despite the words in the Constitution remaining the same in the intervening period, the feelings of the court about the document changed, and so what is considered "Constitutional" under the law changed as well. In that sense, what is normal can in fact be Constitutional, as long as people with the right power say so, even if the document doesn't say as such in literal words.