6 ms·
How Police Exploited the Capitol Riot’s Digital Records
- throwaway4good 4y agoThis just looks like standard police work? What am I missing here?
- 0xbadcafebee 4y ago"Be careful, they have spooky powers" seems to be the message. As well as "there are digital fingerprints everywhere", as they also talk about ProPublica doing their own investigation.
- pxmpxm 4y agoNeed to keep the story in the news cycle through 2024
- pseudolus 4y agoIt's deeply regrettable that both sides of the political spectrum are so caught up in their particular narratives that they can't see potential erosion of civil rights that these law enforcement techniques bring about. On parts of the left, segments are grateful for these technologies because they allow for the arrest of individuals who they perceive as having attempted to overthrow democracy. Segments of the right are blinded and can't focus on the means and methods undertaken by law enforcement because they can't overcome their rage at what they perceive as an overblown and partisan response to the events of the riot.
- xwolfi 4y agoWhat of the population living day after day in a dangerous world ? Do they prefer civil right preservation or police oversight ? I get the politicians in D.C. might have trouble to see what's in front of them, but Im unsure the population is so against it.
- Geezus-42 4y agoI for one would prefer civil rights. The most dangerous people I have ever met were cops. I can protect myself from the individual non-state backed fascist.
- amanaplanacanal 4y ago> I can protect myself from the individual non-state backed fascist. Perhaps you can. History has shown that most people cannot.
- nemo44x 4y agoI agree. I think most people have a “if you’re not breaking the law then you have nothing to worry about” view on this. Naively trusting that whoever has authority can be trusted indefinitely. But it’s an easier point to make than an abstract view of personal liberties and protections from abusive power. Some kid (I suspect) wrote a naughty racist word on sone piece of playground equipment (easily cleaned off) and the reaction by people on an unofficial town FB group were amazing. One person called for cameras everywhere and the imprisonment of parents if their kid was recorded writing a racist or w/e word. Hell the whole defund the police thing started turning into an alternative where there are cameras everywhere. I’m pretty sure that will be the future.
- Forge36 4y agoHow many people need to be involved and how large the area before geofencing is used as an investigation tool? I'd set the current bar lower than the capital riots. Though how low is reasonable I don't know. I'm definitely opposed to finding a single individual, and an entire city. But I don't know how I'd feel about a single small building (say for a mass shooter event)
- ModernMech 4y ago[flagged]
- commandlinefan 4y ago> the Republican party Nobody even remotely affiliated with the Republican Party was involved in any actual insurrection attempt on 1/6.
- cycrutchfield 4y ago“No True Republican” fallacy?
- ModernMech 4y agoYou should really read the bipartisan 1/6 committee report. At the very least what you say isn't true because there wouldn't have been a mob in DC on 1/6 if Trump hadn't asked them to be there. How many people travelled from around the country to be in DC on 1/6/2017? Or 2009? Everyone gets there for the 20th for the inauguration, whereas historically the 6th has been ignored. But in 2021 everyone was there on that day, at the express invitation of Trump. Don't take my word for it - you just have to look at the court proceedings for the 1/6 prosecutions, where defendant after defendant pleads that they are not at fault because they were just taking directions from the President. But what you say is further untrue because there were plenty of Republicans involved beyond that. The White House was responsible for helping organize the Stop the Steal rally, at which multiple high-ranking Republican party members spoke. Beyond that, multiple congresspeople and senators objected to certifications, not because they had any basis for their objections, but in order to delay the proceeding and give Trump time to rile the mob. State GOP lawmakers forged Certificates of the Vote electing Trump that Pence was intended to substitute for the authentic ones. GOP Senators were involved in the process to transmit these certificates to Pence in time. Giuliani was busy calling lawmakers during the insurrection imploring them to delay the vote further as the mob bore down on them. Trump sat back and refused to deploy any National Guard troops, to the point Pence had to usurp control and do it himself after waiting 3 hours. Again, read the 1/6 report. It's all in there.
- acdha 4y ago
- xwolfi 4y agoIt's a question whether standard police work should be reformed since despite all classical attempts at hiding, they were found. It questions: are the trade offs worth it? I suppose the corrolary being: what if this protest was more legitimate but the police was corrupt? I live in China myself so I find it interesting to ask this question before it's fully done and lost, even if I feel I know the answer: yes, it is worth it, and you'll never shock people with stories of criminals being founds thanks to general surveillance as much as they're shocked by unsolved horrendous crimes, so the abuses will be tolerated (or hidden thanks to the new structure of standard police work) as price to pay, when a critical mass of crimes that could have been solved will be reached. And I am sad to tell you, that trading freedom for safety is paradise, and when I left the scary city I lived in before to Hong Kong where I live now, I felt such a surprised relief at the total absence of small crimes (all citizens prints are stored on a central database for instance, all 7M of us can be found in an instant). I'm never going back, they can read my emails and track my phone.
- krapp 4y ago> It's a question whether standard police work should be reformed since despite all classical attempts at hiding, they were found. They discussed their plans openly on social media then streamed evidence of it after the fact. Ignoring the question of whether the ability to hide from law enforcement is a necessary component of liberty even when one has committed a crime, these guys weren't even trying very hard to cover their tracks.
- drunkpotato 4y agoFor the core field operatives, it seemed many had unrealistic expectations of their chance of success, and were pumped on a success-or-death mentality. In retrospect it’s easy to see why that would lead to lax operational security. Now that they neither succeeded nor died in the attempt, the evidence is easy to find.
- pseudolus 4y agoPer the story the use of geofencing is of great concern as essentially it amounts to a grant of authority to the State to undertake a search simply based on geography and not reasonable suspicion of wrongdoing. This is a significant departure from past standards for undertaking a search. See article excerpt below. 'The EFF sees the tremendous scope and power of geofence warrants as a bug, not a feature. “We believe that geofence warrants are unconstitutional because they don’t start with a suspect,” says Lynch. “They don’t rely on individualized suspicion, which is what’s required under the Fourth Amendment [to the U.S. Constitution]. In the January 6th context, it’s likely that there were many journalists whose data was provided to the police.”'
- throwaway4good 4y agoBut "geofencing"; ie. in the form of the police asking for a list of phones which have been connected to a particular telecommunications tower has been around for decades. This is hardly news anymore.
- pseudolus 4y agoIt's hardly news to people who frequent sites such as HN or follow press releases issued by the EFF or the ACLU but I expect that the general population is surprised at how expansive the data harvesting efforts of law enforcement are. Additionally, the publicity surrounding the scale and scope of the operation is atypical.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- snarf21 4y agoThe police want all data, then they'll find the crimes. This goes against our country's presumption of innocence. Look at the recent case of the facial recognition and the Rockettes. A lady was trying to go to a holiday show as a private individual but was digitally black listed and kicked out as soon as she entered because she is employed by a law firm engaged in a lawsuit against MSG (who owns RCMH). I understand this is a private venue and not police but the principle is the same. She wasn't caught hacking anything or breaking in to anything she just wanted to see the dancers. The big problem with geo fence warrants is that they lead to a 1984 style big brother surveillance state. For example: should the police constantly get everyone's cell phone tower ping data and automatically issue speeding tickets for every 5 minute window someone was speeding?
- krapp 4y agoIt doesn't go against presumption of innocence because the police don't determine legal innocence or guilt. If we get to the point where that becomes the case, where for instance anyone caught up in a geofence warrant is automatically convicted of a crime in absentia and without any other evidence, then that's obviously a problem.
- fn-mote 4y agoThis is technically correct and totally naive. > If we get to the point where that becomes the case [...] Then it will be far too late to do anything about it. You're obviously going to be convicted of speeding if your geolocation data shows you going 80mph for an hour on the expressway, right? Do you really want to wait until this case shows up in court to try to prevent this kind of dystopia from emerging? See the current top post about individualized suspicion.
- mcculley 4y ago> You're obviously going to be convicted of speeding if your geolocation data shows you going 80mph for an hour on the expressway, right? Do you really want to wait until this case shows up in court to try to prevent this kind of dystopia from emerging? You might want to conjure up a different example. I am having trouble considering enforcement of speed limits to be dystopian.
- rlglwx 4y agoThe irony is that without the digital realm the capital riots wouldn’t have ever happened.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- poszlem 4y agoIt appears reasonable at first glance, but upon further reflection it seems unlikely that the internet was the only factor influencing the riots. If the internet wasn't available, it's likely that some other means of communication would have been used to spread the news that sparked the unrest. There have been MANY instances of people trying to take over a government building before the age of the internet.
- acdha 4y agoThis is true but I’m not sure you’d have had the critical mass of people primed to respond to those messages. Fox News heavily pushed lies about the election but the people who responded were part of a world which grew a lot in the later 2000s as blogs, Facebook, etc. opened up new audiences for ideas which would have been too extreme even for cable news.
- perihelions 4y agoThe (IMHO) really interesting discussions start about 30 paragraphs down: - "The EFF sees the tremendous scope and power of geofence warrants as a bug, not a feature. “We believe that geofence warrants are unconstitutional because they don’t start with a suspect,” says Lynch. “They don’t rely on individualized suspicion, which is what’s required under the Fourth Amendment [to the U.S. Constitution]."
- specialist 4y agoIf surveillance capitalism continues, we'll need to rehash past legal compromises like probable cause, presumed innocence, and refusing to testify against oneself. With panopticon and big data, investigators can rule out everyone with an alibi, sifting thru mountains of data to reveal who must have committed a crime. I'm not arguing right or wrong, morally. Just what is.
- largepeepee 4y agoLooks like the US state power is now making an obvious push to follow the CCPs footsteps after quietly eroding people's rights for years. Hopefully the people will push back on it, can't say I have much hope since the political system is purposely broken. Feels like we are already living in a world where both superpowers nations are in agreement that surveillance capitalism and disinformation is the best way to control their local population.
- gonzo41 4y agoThis argument doesn't make sense. That's like saying you cant review a security camera overlooking a carpark to see who was illegally using your carpark.
- cushychicken 4y agoI’m torn between the argument about individualized suspicion, which I find really compelling, and the fact that extreme circumstances demand some extreme measures. Leading with the capitol attack doesn’t highlight to me why wide scope of these powers is a problem. Tell me more about the civil rights campaigns that are being disrupted with these technologies and powers. It’s not helpful to highlight how it was used to arrest violent separatists. Tell me how it’s being used to punch down! Without an example like that, I’m inclined to say this is a time where the federal government’s reliance on norms is working. As in, they have the power to do these kinds of things, but they choose to apply that power pretty selectively.
- Forge36 4y agoHow does a geofence differ from a warrant to search a property? While crimes are known to have occurred, the exact people may not be known. The biggest difference I see "time". Mostly that it can be done retroactively. Would a geofence be allowed while the event is occurring?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewclunn 4y agoLesson learned. Want to commit a crime? Don't bring your phone.
- nemo44x 4y agoOr even better bring your enemy’s phone.
- gonzo41 4y agoThere'd be metadata of you moving with it. So you'd have touch points in other places through other systems. IF you have a phone, and you're tracked by it, then even if the identity of the sim points elsewhere there's the possibility you leave traces of yourself on CCTV as you're handling the device. Also you're enemy would be busy in this day and age, quickly getting a new phone and trying to contact people with it, thus creating a competing alibi. Just don't riot.
- hnburnsy 4y agoThen there will be questions about why you weren't carrying your phone.
- krapp 4y agoAt least don't take selfies of yourself committing the crime and stream it to the 'gram.
- sega_sai 4y agoI think geofencing should only be allowed to establish/check connection to a very specific crime. I.e. in this specific case of capitol riot, it was a clear one. What I don't think should be allowed is a geofence & open-ended fishing for more crimes. Obviously I am not lawyer, but I would think it could be codified somehow.
- fundad 4y ago> “Hardly looked like extremists” So gross, sorry couldn’t continue after that.
- baryphonic 4y ago> So gross, sorry couldn’t continue after that. What was so offensive about it? I interpreted it as "does not fit the overweight, bearded, too-old-for-military-service mountain-man militia stereotype."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]