3 ms·
Wouldn't it be more politic, for bipartisan support, not to lead with a subtitle that sounds like partisan PR puff? > New Standards Demonstrate President Biden
by neilv 4y ago
Wouldn't it be more politic, for bipartisan support, not to lead with a subtitle that sounds like partisan PR puff?
> New Standards Demonstrate President Biden’s Leadership to Reduce Air Pollution that Threatens Communities
To me (who is strongly supportive of environmental protection), this language sounded like it risks creating additional partisan opposition to this effort and other EPA efforts, which seems counterproductive. Or is 100% opposition already a given?
Or is there additional complexity that requires promoting/rewarding a politician/party, even if that hurts other subgoals?
- dylan604 4y agoIsn't the EPA under the leadership of the current administration? So by extension, would the EPA policies be the execution of the administrations play calling? If the EPA were non-governmental, then sure, I might agree.
- neilv 4y agoThere are the interests of the public, represented by government institutions and individual public servants. Those interests are separate from PR for politicians/parties, and sometimes incompatible, like perhaps in this case.
- Dalewyn 4y agoIt's kind of under the White House but not quite. Structurally, the EPA is an agency of the Executive Branch (aka the White House, POTUS, etc.). Organizationally the EPA answers only to Congress (aka the Legislative Branch) and the Supreme Court (aka the Judiciary Branch).[1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_agencies_of_the_United_States_government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_agencies_of_the_Un...
- dylan604 4y agoSo, like all of the branches of govt are in control. Huh?
- Dalewyn 4y agoEPA answers to Congress because they make the laws stating who and what EPA is. EPA answers to SCOTUS because the courts decide how laws are understood and executed. EPA gives the finger to the White House because they are an independent agency despite being part of the Executive Branch.
- nemo44x 4y agoNo you’re 100% wrong unfortunately. Congress is the part of government that creates laws. Over time congress has delegated more and more of its power to government agencies. This is of course anti-democratic. These agencies are the real power structures in the country. No matter who is elected by the people, agencies get to enact policies that are in effect laws being created by people that are not elected. However, these institutions maintain the power of the ruling class by virtue of being indirectly responding to “the science” elite universities arbitrarily choose to fund by virtue of wealthy donors and is normalized in prestigious journals so good natured folk like yourself not only accept it but justify it. This is how “current things” take hold. You can’t really blame democrats or republicans for this as they both use it to enter an h power outside of democratic methods. Democrats have better utilized them to be sure but they’re 2 sides of the same coin minus some outliers here and there.
- rsj_hn 4y agoThat's not how the current administrative state operates. The white house can nominate the head of the EPA (and a layer of bureaucrats beneath them) and the Senate must approve the nominations. These are political appointees. The white house cannot say "fire person X" who works for the EPA but was not nominated, because there is (supposed to be) a wall between the political appointees, who must be confirmed by the Senate, and the professional appointees, who are supposed to be protected by a web of laws and whistleblower protections. So while many people think that the President is the "head" of the administration and can just order it to do whatever he wants, that's not how it's supposed to work. The set of things the EPA is supposed to be doing is set by legislation and the manner in which it does things is also subject to oversight. That doesn't actually stop the politicization of these agencies -- e.g. the CDC studying racism as a public health crisis or gun crime as a disease, or having the IRS investigate conservative groups, etc. The boundary of this tug of war in which the President tries to order an agency to do X and his opponents sue him saying "you can't do this" is exactly the issue of lawfare and the constitutionality of various executive orders. Many such attempts at directing Federal agencies fail or are ruled unconstitutional, but the overall effects of appointing ideologues to leadership positions is felt in things like the newspeak so common now in public announcements.
- wara23arish 4y agoThis is first thing that jumped at me. I recently got emails regarding my student loans that had very similar language. Instead of just delivering a message with information, it was borderline propaganda
- nemo44x 4y agoImagine if a fundamentalist Christian ran this agency and put out a press release justifying their goals (which may be good!) by referencing how Christ died for our sins and that a few bible passages clearly show why we are making the moral decision. It would be crazy. Not that a fundamentalist Christian would ever even be close to this level of power. Social Justice is modern Gnosticism and the language used here is how it’s expressed. Even if the admin doesn’t believe in it they will use this language of the elite if they ever want to advance their career much like an atheist in Saudi Arabia would give praise to Allah even though he doesn’t believe. It’s what you do to express that you’re not only right but that your are righteous.