4 ms·
Having a standard of "X" is clean and "X plus Epsilon" is unacceptable is just bad science and inefficient economics. A much more sensible method is to assign
by WalterBright 4y ago
Having a standard of "X" is clean and "X plus Epsilon" is unacceptable is just bad science and inefficient economics.
A much more sensible method is to assign a cost for a particle, and then tax the emitters of those particles that cost.
- Gigachad 4y agoThese kinds of ideal free market solutions sound good in theory but basically never get used in reality. While all particles emitted are equally bad, they aren’t all as easy to cut out so we always end up with more specific laws which force the most capable of improving to move first.
- WalterBright 4y agoThem never being implemented says nothing about whether they will work or not. However, we do know that the ideal way to distribute scarce resources is by supply&demand. There's no reason whatsoever why this would not work to allocate pollution to where it is necessary. In math we call the EPA rules "step functions", in engineering we call them "bang bang valves." They're simply very bad approximations to reality.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Them never being implemented says nothing about whether they will work or not. Real communism was also never implemented, lets try again? > ideal way to distribute scarce resources is by supply&demand Again, this is strictly false - Ideal process is perfectly informed central planning. Competition is a wastefull process, thats literally what it means- someone looses and goes under. Policing the market against fraud, insider trading, self dealing, etc. is a wastefull process too. The fact that those ideals are unachievable should indicate to you that your entire line of argument is faulty.
- UncleEntity 4y ago> Competition is a wastefull process, thats literally what it means- someone looses and goes under. Competition, since we’re talking about ideals, is the opposite of wastefulness — it allocates resources where they are most vitality needed. The wasteful uses get priced out of the market and everyone, as a whole, benefits. If you make the (non-idealized) argument that all existing processes are useful because of the fact that they exist and competition causing them to fail is wasteful then…I don’t have an answer for that because that’s just absurd. Of course, we don’t live in some ideal world so wasteful processes get protected and subsidized, useful processes get penalized and everyone thinks the all knowing AI central planner won’t just nuke all the irrational human “market actors” as an optimization step in the ideal resource allocation strategy.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoReal economists study how competition creates waste. An common example of waste induced by competition is advertising expenditures. Competition doesn't allocate resources, price discovery does that. The whole advantage of markets over central planning is they work in non-ideal situations, where planning is not practical. You got the whole thing backwards.
- WalterBright 4y agoHow would you learn about new products that will improve your life without advertising? There isn't price discovery without advertising. The advantage of markets is central planning has proven to be incapable of dealing with the complexities of markets. Making things worse in central planning is the problem of putting an inept person in charge. In a market system, the inept business goes out of business.
- UncleEntity 4y ago> Competition doesn't allocate resources, price discovery does that. And price discovery is the result of people competing for scarce resources. *scarce in the sense that it isn’t free for everyone like air, there’s no price discovery before you turn on the air compressor in your garage to fill up your car tire.
- cwingrav 4y agoAgree on the economic approach and with a preference for cap and trade. Create a certain amount of emission billets and auction them off. Then restrict the amount each bullet allows over time. It has economics, planning and reductions all in one.
- WalterBright 4y agoEven cap&trade is unnecessary complexity. Just tax it. Keep increasing the tax until the pollution levels drop. Use the tax revenue to offset the taxes on productive behavior.
- londons_explore 4y agoI would like to see an auto-adjusting tax... Eg. "The tax per gram of PM2.5 is $1. Each year, if average PM2.5 levels across America are above 5 ug/m^3, the tax will increase 10%. Otherwise, it will decrease 10%." Then lawmakers once need to put in place the tax and set the target, and they never need to intervene again.
- WalterBright 4y agoThat's a far more practical solution that the usual EPA regulations.
- XorNot 4y agoIf someone is flooding the area around them with high PM2.5 thus that everyone nearby has respiratory problems, but the overall rate of PM2.5 across all of the US is very low (because generally, it actually is) then your proposed scheme would ensure that areas (generally cities) are going to be completely unlivable, but there'd be no reason to change because overall the tax would remain low. In fact they'd have no reason to improve anything provided that their projection for the cost of improvement looked marginally more expensive then just paying projected future cost of the tax.
- meowkit 4y agoCap & Trade (as I understand it) would be the government playing referrer, and polluters/cleaners building a market place to exchange credits. Taxing would involve playing referrer, collecting taxes for this specific issue, and then allocating that tax to either public or private parties to work on productive behavior. Taxing sounds more problematic given how dysfunctional most governments are, especially when it comes to non-regulatory procedures. More failure points in the market generation. A variable tax to disincentivize pollution combined with cap and trade would make the most sense to me.
- caslon 4y agoIf the true cost of bad air quality is a lower lifespan, what dollar amount makes it okay to contribute to the problem?
- Dave_Rosenthal 4y agoAlthough it may seem somehow unsavory, there is a long history of placing value on the probabilistic saving of human life (e.g. in highway engineering). We have limited resources in the world to save lives and doing the math is better than the alternative.
- fwungy 4y agoThe value of a human life in engineering calculations is about $8M. Seems barbaric, but if you don't do it you have no way to stop adding safety measures to anything and thus cannot do anything.
- onecommentman 4y agoFor the US, that’s roughly correct. For one State in India, $640K. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life#India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life#India Although, given the expected lives saved from using modern agricultural equipment and practices instead of slash-and-burn for planting crops in the districts surrounding Delhi, I’m guessing the India number is a gross overestimate. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/future-development/2020/11/25/delhi-the-worlds-most-air-polluted-capital-fights-back/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/future-development/2020/11/25...
- seiferteric 4y agonot necessarily, if the products/services produced that cause the pollution also positively impact lifespan, you have to take that into account to decide if it is a net benefit or not.
- WalterBright 4y agoAll endeavors have a risk of death to them, including getting out of bed in the morning. How many dollars are you willing to pay to get an extra hour of life?
- schiffern 4y agoApples and oranges. The EPA primary standard (which is they propose to change) is based only on health and not economics. From the Regulatory Impact Analysis[1]: (yes it's long, but the quote preempts a lot of the predictable replies here) >The Clean Air Act (CAA) requires the EPA, for each criteria pollutant, to set standards that protect public health with “an adequate margin of safety” and public welfare from “any known or anticipated adverse effects.” As interpreted by the Agency and the courts, the CAA requires the EPA to base the decisions for primary standards on health considerations only; economic factors cannot be considered. The prohibition against considering cost in the setting of the primary air quality standards does not mean that costs, benefits, or other economic consequences are unimportant. The Agency believes that consideration of costs and benefits is an essential decision-making tool for the efficient implementation of these standards. The impacts of costs, benefits, and efficiency are considered by the States when they make decisions regarding what timelines, strategies, and policies are appropriate for their circumstances. TL;DR: Primary standards are meant to determine healthy levels, including for vulnerable people like children and the elderly. They are not intended to determine what levels are economically efficient. That's handled during implementation, not when setting the primary standards. [1] https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2023-01/naaqs-pm_ria_proposed_2022-12.pdf#page24 https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2023-01/naaqs-pm_...
- onecommentman 4y agoDo wonder whether they are using a threshold model instead of simple linear model for dose-response for particulates nowadays. Makes a huge difference when determining health effects at low doses, and back in the day it wasn’t clear which model was the clear winner. Assume a threshold model and most of your health effects disappear. Probably buried in this light-hearted report (2000 pages). https://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/isa/recordisplay.cfm?deid=347534 https://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/isa/recordisplay.cfm?deid=347534
- hedora 4y agoLocation matters a lot for PM 2.5. The health impact of a bonfire in the woods is very different than one in a city center.