5 ms·
Why older fathers pass on more genetic mutations to their offspring
- duttonw 4y agoInteresting read. Would be more interesting to note if the mutations in the offspring were better or worse off.
- loandbehold 4y agoMutations are almost always bad for offsprings. Good mutations are rare.
- runsWphotons 4y agoreally? they seem more likely to be neutral than anything? also sometimes must be good for example children of older fathers are taller
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Tozen 4y agoThe X-Men (famous mutant characters) are for comic books. How it usually goes in nature, mutations are bad. Once in a rare blue moon, they are good. Often in some odd, unexpected, or plus versus minus type of way. And actually, hybridization between near species or more robust mixing between more genetically unrelated pairs tends to be better for more useful adaptations.
- smegger001 4y ago>And actually, hybridization between near species or more robust mixing between more genetically unrelated pairs tends to be better for more useful adaptations. Unfortunately we already killed off, or out bred all other members of genus homo. Though to be fair our ancestors do seem to have got on with them so maybe we just absorbed them more than drove them to extinction?
- Rury 4y agoA lot of research has been done on this, and the vast majority of mutations are neutral, and have no affect on an organism. That is not good, nor bad. Somewhere between 75 to 90 percent of our own DNA, is nonfunctional, and never used. But in any case, increasing the mutation rate, does increase the chance of bad mutations of happening, since it increases any kind of mutations from happening.
- klipt 4y agoRadiation causes mutations. Exposing yourself to excessive radiation is much more likely to cause cancer than superpowers. (In addition to a bunch of neutral mutations that do neither.)
- bcrosby95 4y agoI always assumed it's because older fathers tend to have more money, meaning their kids get more nutrition.
- runsWphotons 4y agoi dont think this explains it at all. afaik the pattern is true in developed countries where nutrition is not an issue. ill look at it again though.
- tempestn 4y agoMore likely older fathers are higher status, which correlates with their own height, and therefore that of their children.
- viraptor 4y agoThis is going off topic, bit it made me think whether this will change/lessen in a generation or two of remote work. I'm surprised about the height of people I work with when we meet once a year.
- aliqot 4y agoWe can't reproduce remotely yet, but remaining hopeful.
- rpgmaker 4y agomore likely because women who are taller tend to be more selective about their partner (they want them to be taller than them).. which means they end up having babies at a later age.
- tempestn 4y agoMost mutations are indeed neutral. Of those that aren't though, I believe more have negative effects than positive ones. (But the positive ones are more likely to persist, at least historically, due to natural selection.)
- CobaltFire 4y agoWe've wondered if this might have been a factor for our son. Wife and I were 35 when we had him, and he's severely autistic and has Leukemia. Research says that incidences of both rise as the age of parents does, but it's not something heavily studied at this time. His oncologist said at least partially because they already deal with parents blaming themselves enough.
- runsWphotons 4y agoeh this research is in fruit flies
- lurquer 4y agoIndeed. Moreover, there is no reason to think the differences between a young and ‘elderly’ fruitfly have any similarity to humans, as our lifespans are absurdly different…
- colordrops 4y ago35 is not that old.
- milleramp 4y ago35 is considered a geriatric pregnancy. https://www.goodrx.com/health-topic/parenthood-pregnancy/geriatric-pregnancy https://www.goodrx.com/health-topic/parenthood-pregnancy/ger...
- petemir 4y agoLiterally the first words in TFA: ‘A “geriatric pregnancy” is an outdated term’
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoThat's a result of the euphemism treadmill, not of physical reality changing. Some call it advanced maternal age now and it's exactly the same thing, if you go see a fertility specialist you can be sure he will change his recommendations greatly depending on whether you are younger or older than 35.
- zug_zug 4y agoHopefully someday we can provide a sperm sample, and get back "Here's your entirely corrected gene-set with no mutations" or maybe even "and here's undoing 100 mutations you got" for insemination
- echelon 4y agoScreening is possible, but what you've described - fixing all DNA errors - is not at all an easy problem. DNA can have an abundance of errors, epigenetic signals, etc. It has spatial packing and organization problems to overcome. Attempting the repairs themselves will each be bespoke mini problems that could introduce further disease states if the fix fails. My thinking is that by the time we have this technology as described, the world will have moved beyond humans. We're in a race. Will we advance 10x in molecular capabilities before we advance to AGI and beyond? I think not. Speaking as someone who was adopted, I also can't relate to the necessity of having a child borne of your own genes. There are lots of ways to increase value in this world, and solving this problem completely is an incredibly niche application of the limited time and talent we have. The necessary tech advances themselves are way more valuable than the problem described here.
- jasonfarnon 4y agois there an objective standard for "error"s?
- Daub 4y agoGood question. Errors are one part of what drives evolution. 'useful accidents'.
- thatoneguy 4y agoThat's pretty much how it works now, at least with IVF, pre-implantation genetic testing and known mutations/deletions.
- tempestn 4y ago
- stbl219z8y 4y agoA little deceptive title considering they talk about fruit flys and then say they don’t know if this applies to humans.
- birdymcbird 4y agoAdmittedly wouldn’t have clicked otherwise. 100% click bait title.
- KiranRao0 4y agoThis is why I love HN. These comments allow me to not click.
- rcme 4y agoNot directly related to fruit flies, but older fathers are more likely to have autistic children.
- Daub 4y agoAnd downs syndrome.
- loandbehold 4y agoDown syndrome correlates to mother's age more; autism correlates more to father's age.
- abcc8 4y agoYes, the extra chromosome 21 comes from the mother in approximately 90% of cases.
- AndrewDucker 4y agoPlausibly because men with some autistic attributes find it harder to form long-term relationships until they've got more experience than those without.
- deathclassic 4y agoCould something like epitalon reverse this effect?
- Qem 4y agoIn a more positive note: "Breaking news: Older fathers drive evolution!"
- jheriko 4y agois it that they are older? isn't this just a fallout from "mutations are random over time"?
- thro1 4y agobut.. childern of older fathers live longer.. (?)