3 ms·
I've always hated Music.app's and iTunes's concept of a "Library". I already have a library for my media--it's organized, hierarchal, consistently named, and fu
by ryandrake 4y ago
I've always hated Music.app's and iTunes's concept of a "Library". I already have a library for my media--it's organized, hierarchal, consistently named, and fully-integrated with my computer's operating system. It's called "the filesystem". I don't need the app to re-invent the concept of a filesystem on top of my existing filesystem. This isn't really limited to Apple applications, either. For a lot of applications, whenever you want to do anything more advance than "playing" a file, you have to first "add it to your Library", where the application grafts its own idea of a filesystem onto your already perfectly-good filesystem. Yuck!
- asutekku 4y agoa majority of the people don't have your idea of library so it makes sense to have some kind of unified system that automatically sorts the library.
- projektfu 4y agoI agree with this. When I started using iTunes in 2002 it was a revoultion for me, before that I just had music files scattered around wherever the ADHD put them. iTunes would organize them, find out more metadata like names of artists and genres, and give me a tags-based database for viewing them. And, it stored them in a pretty rational way in the filesystem, so you could find the individual files pretty easily. It became as simple as inserting a CD and in a couple minutes it was ready to go. It was even able to insert a pause between some tracks and play 2 tracks attacca if they were supposed to be played together. And, the "Genius" feature put together really decent mixes, where it would play a few songs from the same artist and move on, and seem to move through the genres pretty nicely. I appreciate all the work they're doing now curating lists and writing bios of the artists in Apple Music, but I feel like they threw away useful stuff they had before.