6 ms·
Instead this cost is spread out among all the companies in the form of employment laws. No, it's spread out among all the companies that are willing to hire wo
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Instead this cost is spread out among all the companies in the form of employment laws.
No, it's spread out among all the companies that are willing to hire women. The companies that discriminate against women have a competitive advantage over those that don't.
(Note that under normal circumstances, discrimination is a competitive disadvantage. If I hated Indians, for example, I'd never have found my current team.)
- kenjackson 15y agoThis assumes that there are a sufficient supply of men who can perform better than women.
- reinhardt 15y agoNo, this assumes that there are not many women (or men for that matter) whose hyper-productivity can make up for a 2-3 year leave of absence.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNot quite, because not every woman will vanish from work for 2-3 years. Such laws make an employer indifferent between a man of quality Q and a woman of quality Q + P(taking leave) x (cost of leave). Whether or not hyper-productivity is required depends strongly on P(taking leave) and the cost of leave.
- myko 15y agoOne other thing to note is that a lot of businesses are now granting paternity leave equal or near so to maternity leave.
- henrikschroder 15y agoOnly in countries where there aren't any laws to even this out. Where I live, there's plenty of laws that stop companies from discriminating against women, thereby removing the competitive advantage, which in turn forces the companies to do the right thing.
- mekoka 15y agoExcept that the process of proving discrimination is neither cheap nor an easy feat. How do they do it where you live?
- henrikschroder 15y agoYou file a complaint with the discrimination ombudsman, they investigate and if they find that you are right they try to reach a settlement between you and your employer. If that fails, either party can take it to the courts. Yes, there's a cost to these laws and these processes, but I think (and the politicians of my country obviously agrees) that it's cheaper and easier to do it this way, than to add a corporate tax and redistribute that money to groups that suffer from workplace discrimination. It seems to work here, but that doesn't mean it would work as well elsewhere. There are so many factors that make up a society.
- forza 15y agoI would have taught it's the opposite. If women are discriminated against because of having children, I guess the companies that doesn't discriminate against women (or even actively helps them) would get all the good ones?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThis is true only for irrational discrimination. If you simply hate women, but women are equally productive to men, then you will lose out on getting good women. I.e., you might choose a man of quality Q-d over a woman of quality Q simply because you dislike women. But in this case, the discrimination is rational. Due to maternity leave, a woman of equal skill creates significant cash flow risks - if she takes leave, you either go for 3 years with her job not getting done, or else you hire a replacement and risk being stuck with unnecessary employees in 3 years.
- forza 15y ago"you hire a replacement and risk being stuck with unnecessary employees in 3 years" That is not how it works in Sweden (nor anywhere else that I know of). The replacement is hired as a temporary position until the original employee returns.
- myko 15y agoIt is only a competitive advantage for those unwilling to hire women if the cost of hiring women is greater than the benefit of the perspective those women who were not hired could bring to the team. However I do not believe that this is the case.
- scarmig 15y agoTwo issues: 1) You overstate the likelihood of the market driving out discrimination. Racist and sexist discrimination has existed for centuries without the market ever reaching the equilibrium state of no discrimination that would result if people were rational market participants (1). 2) Inevitably people bring up Scandinavia in these discussions, and for good reason. Scandinavian countries have both very generous family benefits (including paternal leave!) and high representation of women throughout the workforce. This isn't dispositive, but it does suggest the situation is much more complicated than the original post would suggest. All in all, I prefer to live in a world where everyone pays their fair share instead of trying to eke out a couple extra cents of profit by not providing parental benefits to mothers and families. (1)This is actually an even subtler issue, because it's possible for markets to exist where racism and sexism offer a competitive advantage, due to consumer preferences.
- Iv 15y agoScandinavians have sane laws about parental leaves : both parents get the same amount. Therefore if you hire someone in the 25-30 age range, there is a high risk of having to do without this employee, regardless of his/her gender. IIRC, the rule is 12 months to be split between the two parents, no part being smaller than 2 months.
- dagw 15y agoThe 'down' side is that now us guys also get discriminated against. I've been more or less asked straight out about my family situation at a job interview, and I could tell from the expressions on their faces that they didn't like my answer, and I didn't get the job. Of course it's impossible to say why, as there where a couple of other good reasons why they might have rejected me.
- fragsworth 15y ago"No, it's spread out among all the companies that are willing to hire women." I don't think it's a black-and-white issue of giving or not giving a job. These types of government restrictions cause a change in the supply and demand for the protected individuals. This results in a change in their average salaries (i.e. more restrictions reduce salaries). Women are still worth hiring, just at a lower salary, to account for the added risk. So in the end, the cost ends up being fronted by the women anyway.
- Klinky 15y agoA whites only restaurant in a racist town doesn't seem very disadvantageous, in fact that would probably be the selling point. I would imagine that those who don't discriminate would continue to not discriminate while those who do discriminate would continue to do so. Removing the law doesn't make women less likely to get pregnant. I am not sure your concept that we should remove the laws so that everyone can discriminate against women equally is really advantageous or very upstanding. Nor do I think the idea that people are going to discriminate despite the laws & it's too hard to prove that they're discriminating is a valid reason to remove the laws either.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoA whites only restaurant in a racist town doesn't seem very disadvantageous, in fact that would probably be the selling point. True, but we are not postulating an employer who's customers prefer not to be served by a pregnant woman. We are merely postulating an employer who wants his employees to show up for work. I would imagine that those who don't discriminate would continue to not discriminate while those who do discriminate would continue to do so. In that case, why bother with any laws on the topic at all? After all, those who do discriminate would continue to do so. Removing the law doesn't make women less likely to get pregnant. No, but it does mitigate the harm that her pregnancy causes for her employer. If she chooses to vanish from the workforce as a result of becoming pregnant, her employer can permanently replace her and is not obligated to take her back 3 years later after her skills have stagnated. This in turn gives the employer a greater incentive to hire her, since she poses less of a risk to the business.
- Klinky 15y agoTrue, but we are not postulating an employer who's customers prefer not to be served by a pregnant woman. I believe you stated under "normal circumstances" discrimination is disadvantageous. I am not sure exactly what you would consider "normal circumstances", but I was merely giving an example where discrimination would be an advantage. We are merely postulating an employer who wants his employees to show up for work. Which can lead to discrimination because a woman may be turned down for a job because of something she has no control over, her ability to become pregnant, regardless of if she actually has plans to become pregnant or not, or is even fertile. In that case, why bother with any laws on the topic at all? After all, those who do discriminate would continue to do so. People still murder others even though it's illegal. Why have laws against murder? They obviously don't work. No, but it does mitigate the harm that her pregnancy causes for her employer. Isn't the biggest harm losing an employee & having to hire someone new? That happens regardless of leave laws. True it might be less hassle now that they can fire a now expectant mother, but they probably would save themselves even that hassle by not hiring a woman in the first place.