8 ms·
This author is mostly writing an update of 1950s science fiction about a robot takeover. Things to worry about in the near term: - Really effective targeted a
by Animats 4y ago
This author is mostly writing an update of 1950s science fiction about a robot takeover.
Things to worry about in the near term:
- Really effective targeted advertising. Most computers already have a camera watching you. That's now coming to TV sets. Amazon and Google are always listening. So far, all this info is only used to select ads. Soon, it should be possible to generate customized marketing content for each consumer, and use immediate feedback on how the customer reacts to adjust the sales pitch. Alexa is already part of the way there.
- Machines should think, people should work. That's what working in an Amazon warehouse is like today. The machines tell the humans what to do. They have to; only the computers have an overview of the process. (Yeah, Marshall Brain's "Manna", which everyone here has probably read.)
- Big Brother is watching you. It is possible now to watch most of the people most of the time. Track who's out of view and for how long, to know what's being missed. China leads in this, but the UK is not far behind. The US isn't centralized enough to integrate all the available data yet. We're coming up on Oppression 2.0. Latest advance - Iran is using surveillance cameras and face recognition to catch women not wearing hijabs.
- Machines beating humans at business. In some areas, AI systems may generate better returns than humans. That already happens in parts of finance. After all, it's an optimization problem. The free market may force companies to use AI more in management.
- Reduced need for education. Right now, about half of college graduates do jobs that don't require a college education. For many people, going to college is not cost-effective. That will increase.
This is all next 5 to 10 years stuff.
- dustbitying 4y ago> Reduced need for education. Right now, about half of college graduates do jobs that don't require a college education. For many people, going to college is not cost-effective. That will increase. you seem to implicitly assume that a college education is an unnecessary expense for most and that therefore, it shouldn't be really given away so readily. this suggests to me that you assume that the real purpose of college is job preparation. your reasoning makes sense from the perspective of a higher level institution (or corporation, or possibly a government) seeking to be as efficient as possible regardless of the impact on typical human individual's well-being. college is not a 'factory' (or any sort of industry) that 'manufactures' workers for companies.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThese days, if you want to just "learn for learning's sake", or for self improvement, there are tons of free and cheap ways to get a good education. The only reason people are willing to pay tens of thousands of dollars for college is that it is a credentialed degree that people think will open up career doors. We shouldn't beat around the bush on this fact.
- auctoritas 4y agoNot only that, truly advancing into the depths of a subject, becoming a scholar and serious intellectual in the process, is a path reserved for but a few. The moment you force the masses into higher education as the default path that earlier justification of University as the forge of scholars becomes anachronistic and new justifications must be created.
- korroziya 4y ago>These days, if you want to just "learn for learning's sake", or for self improvement, there are tons of free and cheap ways to get a good education I agree, but you won't have a sheet of paper proving it. It's like that infamous scene from Good Will Hunting. Question is whether you want an easy way to PROVE you're educated. Which is what a license, certificate or diploma grants you.
- fooqux 4y agoThe person you replied to already covers that in the following sentences. Why else would you need to prove your education except for work?
- haswell 4y agoIn a hypothetical post-work era where people no longer build their reputation via career, it’s not hard to imagine group dynamics emerging such that education level is no longer a means to an end, but an end unto itself. Essentially a new way to establish hierarchies.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI think this is a great post, but it also makes me so sad because it highlights a lot of the general pessimism I've felt about the direction of tech over the past decade or so (after so much optimism in the 90s and 00s). I mean, I feel like your description of "Really effective targeted advertising" is spot on, but it also makes me think "Why don't they just dump as all in the nutrient baths Matrix-style and just hook our eyeballs up to a continuous loop of ads?" In seriousness, I feel like the only hope here is that the general population gets more and more aware about the negative impacts on all this hyper-targeted advertising. Certainly we've been making strides there with things like GDPR and documentaries like the Social Dilemma, but with so much money on the line it will be hard to fight back.
- eternalban 4y ago> - Machines should think, people should work > - Reduced need for education. This subset is the radioactive bits of AI impact. We can always address the rest, but that requires thinking and an education.
- packetlost 4y ago> - Really effective targeted advertising. Most computers already have a camera watching you. That's now coming to TV sets. Amazon and Google are always listening. So far, all this info is only used to select ads. Soon, it should be possible to generate customized marketing content for each consumer, and use immediate feedback on how the customer reacts to adjust the sales pitch. Alexa is already part of the way there. Not only this, but the realtime trade-to-trade performance of companies is also easily available. If I was building an AI, I would let it make realtime decisions on where to put money as the "actuator" of society and advertising/consumer spending metrics as the sampling mechanism.
- college_physics 4y agowe are already in an AI catastrophe. "AI" has become lately a new thing due to a combination of some catchy technical advances and an associated runaway speculative bubble. In reality this is just the latest act in a long-running process of data collection, quantification and data driven decision support that is gradually seeping through to permeate every facet of life. With the proliferation of digital computers (we are now swimming in a soup of etched silicon) these processes are exploding. Whereas in the past there was some breathing room for society to catch up, evaluate and control this technology [0], today the rapidity has converted it into a wild west: tech entrepreneurs and their financiers declare their self-serving moral standards as the new norm, the broader public is dazed, confused and misinformed and public institutions, nominally at the service of the citizenry are only as good as their weakest, most capturable link Name one development over the past decade that indicates we [1] are actually capable to control what is happening and the above dark picture is mere scaremongering. [0] think e.g., about regulatory constraints around insurance or financial data and models [1] as in citizens anywhere in the world
- Joeri 4y agoI’m expecting even worse: heavily weaponized political influencing by AI bots. Brexit was won in 2016 by microtargeting ads on facebook based on individual profiles, and since then this has become a common strategy. Think of what a game changer it will be to have convincing AI bots engaging one on one with people online to give them exactly the arguments needed to make them vote the right way. The candidate with the best AI team is all but guaranteed to win. This is not a matter of “if”, it is a matter of “when”.
- yamtaddle 4y agoWe're gonna have to choose between a free, semi-anonymous, international communication network, and democracy. Probably very soon. I've long suspected China had the right idea here, and am, in this case, not happy to be proven right.
- _nalply 4y agoCare to explain more? Especially what do you think China's idea is? And also how that idea relates to, in your words but abbreviated, «choosing between a network and democracy». Thank you.
- UncleOxidant 4y ago> Machines beating humans at business. In some areas, AI systems may generate better returns than humans. This was part of what was going on in the recent novel "Mountain in the Sea". An AI-controlled fishing corporation figured out that replacing robots with enslaved humans on it's AI controlled fishing fleet was more cost effective (the ocean air was hell on the robots apparently, they kept breaking). Each fishing boat was controlled by an AI which had the objective of maximizing profits. As a result the oceans were being depleted of fish at a rapid rate.
- AussieWog93 4y ago>- Machines should think, people should work. That's what working in an Amazon warehouse is like today. The machines tell the humans what to do. They have to; only the computers have an overview of the process. (Yeah, Marshall Brain's "Manna", which everyone here has probably read.) I actually run some Manna-esque systems in my own small business (most notably a system for stock picking and shipping) and this isn't something to worry about in the near-term. It greatly, greatly reduces the amount of frustration and stress people experience in mundane jobs, greatly reduces cognitive complexity and just generally makes the work more satisfying. Maybe there's a risk of humans losing their jobs to machines, a la chapter 2 of Manna, but to be frank it's no different to the threat of outsourcing which has existed for 50+ years.
- Eleison23 4y ago[dead]
- alpineidyll3 4y agoWorrying is only worthwhile if there is something you can do about it. I don't think there is anything most people can do to avoid the wave of human replacement that near term AI is going to cause. The best most people could manage would be to develop better philosophies and perspectives to cope with their irrelevance.