3 ms·
> Many of them believe that radical action, even violence, may be necessary to save it. Too bad. I believe that change brought about through violence will only
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
> Many of them believe that radical action, even violence, may be necessary to save it.
Too bad. I believe that change brought about through violence will only lead to a violent regime.
- guerrilla 4y agoSo you agree that every country that exists today is a violent regime except the handful that gained their independence peacefully because the rest were all formed through violence?
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI'm not a historian, perhaps you can enlighten me. France is one that came to mind. Violent regime? Of course not. But they did have to tread through a reign of terror after their Révolution française. Perhaps you eventually get to a peaceful regime. But it's hard to imagine power sweeping into control on a wave of violence suddenly shuttering that same violence.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThis has been true at least for the US since the revolutionary war and in France since theirs.
- seanw444 4y agoCounterpoint: 1776.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoThe exception that proves the rule? That was the one that came to mind that, to my history-lacking-knowledge became peaceful right after the shooting stopped. I don't disagree.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoAn extremely rare event due to a leader actually stepping down when everyone around him was telling him to stay. Historians point to this behavior by George Washington as essentially one-of-a-kind in human history.
- starkd 4y agoOf course, people talking about violent means is a far cry from what those same people will actually do. Everyone has their own breaking point, but until it reaches a critical mass in enough people its not going anywhere. Where that point is is anyone's guess, but I would guess its when people feel their personal/family's liberties are under direct assault.
- agloeregrets 4y agoHow does one end a violent regime? What do you do when the regime can just shoot anyone that disagrees?
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI suspect they end themselves. The rest of us just need to lay low. I'm reminded of the scene in "Seven Samurai" when the villagers bring the seven samurai armor and weapons from dead samurai and Toshiro Mifune's character explodes at the peasants — always pretending to be afraid, humble, powerless, but all the while hoarding weapons, food....
- altgeek 4y agoAgree. North Korea is a shining example of this. They just make sure that they compensate their police and army forces slightly better than the serfs and keep their upper tiers in a state of suspended terror.
- vorpalhex 4y agoIt depends on whether the people can shoot back. On one hand you have a brave but tragic resistance like Iran right now where dozens of young people have protested and been brutally cut down or publically executed. On the other hand you have numerous times in history where a government has learned the phrase "Governments are supposed to fear their people". Usually fire is involved. Both will eventually achieve their aims, but the first example is usually slower and more costly to do so. Many conflicts start as the first type and become the second.
- notch656c 4y agoGovernment is just "legitimate" violence.