3 ms·
> It doesn't provide any actual reasons for why BNPL is a bubble nor why such a supposed bubble is about to burst. I'll provide one: it only made any significa
by ceejayoz 4y ago
> It doesn't provide any actual reasons for why BNPL is a bubble nor why such a supposed bubble is about to burst.
I'll provide one: it only made any significant sense in the near-zero interest rate levels we had last year. "Split it into four payments for $0 fee" is attractive. Much less so when there's a fee; Amazon's BNPL via Affirm is now up to 10-30% APR from the previous 0%.
At those rates, people just put it on a credit card.
- sbuccini 4y agoYour claims are not true for several reasons: - Whenever you see a BNPL offer for 0% it means the merchant is paying the interest on behalf of the consumer. The merchants are in charge of making that decision, not Affirm. Affirm earns interest on every loan. Many merchants choose to assume that cost because it greatly increases conversion rates. Replies to my comment only confirm this fact (“I only ever used BNPL cause I got 0%!”) - "attractiveness" is in the eye of the beholder. You may be unwilling to pay a fee, many other people are. Plenty of people roll over their CC balances each month and pay even higher APRs. - Interest rates have little effect on BNPL financing; many can either lend out of their bank account due to their size, or they sell the loans immediately upon origination and thus pass the risk of changing interest rate environments onto another party.
- emptysongglass 4y agoI don't think you make a convincing argument. Anecdotally, I've only ever used Affirm when they offer me 0% interest. Paying 26% or more for a soundbar over six months is not attractive.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Whenever you see a BNPL offer for 0% it means the merchant is paying the interest on behalf of the consumer. Yes. We consumers appreciate that. > You may be unwilling to pay a fee, many other people are. Sure. I think a lot fewer people will be willing to pay $X than $0. > Interest rates have little effect on BNPL financing 0% APRs are only really feasible in a low-interest environment. There's a reason that Fed rate hikes are immediately followed up by APRs.
- _fat_santa 4y agoI disagree and I think interest rates have a huge impact on these places. Just look at Affirm that used to offer 0% and is now offering 10% at minimum. As far as "attractiveness", I really see two groups here. You have one that legit cannot afford the full price and are taking out this loan as a traditional loan, within that group "attractiveness" is in the eye of the beholder. However the other group is people that can very much afford the product but see the magic "0%" rate, for this group the only "attractive" rate is 0, any higher and they will not use the service.
- lozenge 4y agoMerchants pay the interest because they see larger basket amounts and therefore more revenue. If the cost to them increases then it can reach a point where it's no longer attractive.
- jerf 4y ago"You may be unwilling to pay a fee, many other people are. Plenty of people roll over their CC balances each month and pay even higher APRs." I get the sense you're not thinking in the margin. This isn't a question of whether "some people" will pay the fee, it's about the fact that as soon as the fee is greater than zero, "some people" won't, and the rate of that will go up as the fee goes up. This isn't a binary thing where suddenly the rate goes from 0% to 100%. 1% or 2% doesn't mean much to me and my household budget, but for these businesses such percentage differences are generally the difference between profit or loss.
- jacobsimon 4y ago> Whenever you see a BNPL offer for 0% it means the merchant is paying the interest on behalf of the consumer. I don’t think this is true - the merchant pays a transaction fee (around 3-5%) with companies like Affirm or Klarna, which is not much different than typical credit card fees. The merchant is not paying an interest rate or liable to pay more if the customer fails to pay on time.
- clintonb 4y agoYou’re on the right track, but have the wrong specifics. A merchant accepting card payments might pay “sticker rate” for processing, 3%, at the outset; but, they eventually get IC+ pricing as their volume increases. This might be closer to 1-2%. If they pay 5% to a BNPL, that extra 2-4% is meant to cover the interest of the “loan” if the customer doesn’t pay back on schedule.
- jacobsimon 4y agoSure but the merchant isn’t literally paying interest - yes they get charged a fee which helps subsidize an interest-free loan, but that fee is not interest nor is the merchant party to any loans that the consumer enters. The merchant gets paid more or less immediately minus a fee - similar to how a credit card transaction works.
- sbuccini 4y agoI am 1000% correct. Go look at Affirm’s Q1 2023 earnings supplement, slide 14. Average MDR is actually closer to 5-7%, 0% is closer to 12.5%
- _fat_santa 4y agoI see BNPL companies as having two types of customers: those that can't afford the full price and want to pay over time, those that read the terms closely and realized the deal is too good not to take. I took out a number of BNPL loans last year and it was never because I couldn't pay the full price but rather if I was getting the money at 0%, "free money". But I was never the target customer of these places, I was just taking advantage of very good terms. Now that Affirm (and I assume most other places) are charging a floor rate of 10%, that second group of customers are no longer customers. I'm not sure how significant this group is but I'm sure it's not an insignificant number. Since these places make most of their money on transaction fees rather than rate premiums and fees on the back end, this could really put a dent in their business.
- _huayra_ 4y agoMaybe I just haven't had the opportunity to buy any big ticket items with BNPL, but the few times I tried it (trying to do the "free money" thing, getting a bit more interest in my HYSA by amortizing the total payment out over time), it just created kind of a financial tracking nightmare. I'd get flurries of emails about how my "pay in 4" payment was about to process....for $13. Trying to keep track of all that for a few pennies became too difficult (matching up which purchase each micropayment was from), although those pennies add up for larger purchases indeed! But for a floor rate of 10%, BNPL is just a less terrible credit card, not a good deal :(
- UncleMeat 4y agoThis is my take too. A $10,000 purchase on 0% interest for a year earns you ~$400 in interesting from a money market fund or whatever. I'm in a high tax bracket so $160 of that goes to the government. So even for a large purchase I net $240 in a year. Hooray. Decrease the total cost of things purchased in this manner or increase the number of different things to track (or both) and suddenly I'm paying quite a bit more in additional mental energy than I benefit in cash. The only place where this makes sense (IMO) is when you buy a new car and can get 0% and no payments for more than a year
- 4y ago
- pharmakom 4y agoMarket for lemons? How many BNPL customers don’t qualify for a good credit card?
- gnicholas 4y agoI never used one of these, partly because it seemed like it would create significant friction if I needed to return the item. What is the return/refund process like with these services? I assume they get the refund from the merchant and then disburse your part of it to you? Does it go smoothly, or do you have to chase things down?