8 ms·
“However, ever since the chatbot has come into action, it has been negatively impacting students' learning.” This sentence is out of nowhere, did ChatGPT write
by mensetmanusman 4y ago
“However, ever since the chatbot has come into action, it has been negatively impacting students' learning.”
This sentence is out of nowhere, did ChatGPT write this article? How could someone think something so new is suddenly negatively impacting students across the board.
- Heidaradar 4y agolol, I agree that it came out of nowhere, but it has been affecting student's learning IMO - not sure if it's been for better or worse.
- nszceta 4y agoAlmost certainly negatively. Why learn or put in effort into written text prompts when examiners can be easily fooled with machine generated prose? Those that lack discipline, self-control, and have no desire to learn will eliminate themselves.
- Xeoncross 4y agoSadly. I've learned there is a lot of correlation to lack of discipline/self-control and success in life. Most of the wealthy and successful people I know also happen to go to the gym, monitor their diet, and seem to be able to control their temper in a bad situation. It seems to spill into all areas of your life.
- nullsense 4y agoIt's called trait conscientiousness.
- nullsense 4y agoMy son is 7 years and he routinely asks me "why learn anything when you can just ask Google?". I can only imagine the impact this will have on that attitude over time.
- draugadrotten 4y agoDo you challenge him with simple questions like "How do you know the answer you get from Google is true?"
- nullsense 4y agoYep. I attempt to educate him on epistemology as much as I can. He's a relatively skeptical kid, but he's also stubborn as hell and he gives somewhat of a recursive answer of "you just Google that too". I try to impress upon him too that some things take hundreds of hours of explanation before you know enough for it to be functionally useful to you, so you can't always just Google everything. You have to learn things and build your foundations up. Alas he hates the idea of learning anything.
- nszceta 4y agoThere are at least two answers to that question: 1. Knowing things lets you know more things faster and they stick: associative memories are very durable because they are mostly groups of references to existing objects in memory. Much less novel information that needs to be encoded. Repetition and memorization matters. 2. Look up latency: Same problem as computer cache misses and L1 vs RAM lookup times. You will take 100x longer to achieve the same result by looking up reference material all the time. Also important questions typically have answers from many different problem domains (social, scientific, philosophical, ethical) and its important to have a lot of knowledge memorized to see a solution to a novel problem holistically.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tester457 4y agoWhile letting the slackers slack more, it lets the diligent learn more. I do self guided study and it's perfect for generating questions to quiz oneself on based on a text, and create answers based on that text. Doing this prevents the ai hallucinations. Not to mention creating flashcards and simple shell scripts for any task to manage it all. There so many ways this revolutionizes learning for erudite people.
- moralestapia 4y agoHow so? ChatGPT is quite popular on HN and other similar tech-savvy spheres, but is still far from enjoying mainstream success. Maybe like 1% of students have used it yet, and for a month at most, so it's quite the hyperbole to say that it's been "affecting" them already. Or, conversely, if this kind of thing worries you today, you're in for a wild ride ...
- londons_explore 4y agoIt's pretty widespread on tiktok in the student circles I'm in... And the fact openAI is still struggling to handle the load in peak hours 2 months after launch tells me they must be seeing pretty big user growth.
- nebula8804 4y agoOr they haven't properly designed their cloud arch to even moderately scale. We can obviously see their AI and CS talent, but do we have any gauge on their internal systems and IT talent? I've used ChatGPT maybe 3 times since launch and 2 out of 3 attempts resulted in a "come back later" type message. It would make sense to see which accounts are the heavy users and throttle them in favor of lightly used accounts but I guess they didn't think of that or decided against it for some reason?
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIn all likelihood GPT is not embarrassingly parallelizable. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embarrassingly_parallel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embarrassingly_parallel This changes how easy it is to scale.
- zwischenzug 4y agoMy son's (he's 17) peers are all using it for homework at school. Agree on the wild ride though. This is like the advent of the electronic calculator on maths study, but the difference here is everyone has got it at once.
- sillyquiet 4y agoEat your own dogfood right?
- KVFinn 4y ago>This sentence is out of nowhere, did ChatGPT write this article? How could someone think something so new is suddenly negatively impacting students across the board. Ironically if it were impacting learning I think it would be specifically if ChatGPT was NOT being used across the board, but by only a subset of students. So some kids doing assignments the hard way while others have the equivalent of a calculator/secretary/genii. But if every student has the same GPT access then the class can simply raise the expectations for the quality of the student work across the board and it's cool again.
- amanj41 4y agoIf the model gets as good as they strive for, its outputs would be indistinguishable from those of PHD level students. There would be no point in augmenting its results with human contributions
- KVFinn 4y ago>If the model gets as good as they strive for, its outputs would be indistinguishable from those of PHD level students. There would be no point in augmenting its results with human contributions I don't disagree but in a world where every GPU on the planet is as intelligent as PHD student, the next year each GPU is twice as smart as the smartest human on Earth, and not long after that every person on Earth is either dead or turned in pure energy or something and homework isn't on anyone's mind...
- dragonwriter 4y ago> But if every student has the same GPT access then the class can simply raise the expectations for the quality of the student work across the board and it's cool again. You can’t “raise expectations” to address work being done by LLM based on its corpus instread of students based on their knowledge of the material; it fundamentally eliminates both the direct learning use and the assessment use of certain assignment classes, for those doing it, whether it is consistent across the class or not.
- dcsommer 4y agoCumulative damage may be very small now, at the beginning of this age, but educators I talk to certainly are having a reckoning about it. Whether this will ultimately be bad for education is an open question, but with the way many classes and homework are designed now, students using ChatGPT to answer questions certainly do learn less.
- jerpint 4y agoEducation today seems broken, perhaps this will be a way to fix a broken system. They don’t teach abacus use in schools anymore as well as how to use log tables
- est31 4y agoYeah, homework was designed as a way to make self study monitoring and verification scalable. It's not a bad solution but if the availability of AI makes it hard to control that someone has done their homework instead of giving it to an AI, then you have to look for alternatives. Thankfully, in such a world, AI is available to the "teacher" side as well and can serve as a way to both check that the student is doing their job and also to answer their questions, like a personalized teacher of sorts.
- shagie 4y agoThe "if I was a teacher" thoughts on how to handle a ChatGPT that can do short answer questions for English, History, and Social Studies classes... I'd have a set of N questions that shouldn't take long to answer but demonstrate that the material has been read. Yes, ChatGPT can answer them. The second part would be in class, after the homework had been handed in pull a name and number out of a hat and have that student answer that question again and answer a followup question on that material. The oral part of it makes it so that having another do the homework for the student and not do the reading means that the student would show a lack of understanding of the question or its followup. (note: my sophomore English teacher did this... and I messed up answering questions about the Miller's tale which I hadn't read)
- mattferderer 4y agoDramatically improving my learning. The ability to ask questions & ask for examples has helped me learn far faster than books, videos, blogs, etc. Yes, I know the information isn't always 100% accurate. Neither are the books, blogs, courses, etc., I pay for. They also don't let me ask "what about this scenario..." This gives me such a strong base to build from which I can then use other sources to verify.
- phailhaus 4y ago> Yes, I know the information isn't always 100% accurate. Neither are the books, blogs, courses, etc., I pay for Those are two completely different things. ChatGPT has no obligation to be correct, and isn't even trying! It is a chatbot. Its prime directive is only to sound believable. Those books, blogs, courses, etc are at least trying to be correct and provide you with reliable information on a topic. Try using ChatGPT on a topic you know really well.
- omnicognate 4y ago> Try using ChatGPT on a topic you know really well. And read what it says carefully. On many occasions I've seen it say something in a subject I know well and it's started correct so I've mentally autocompleted and assumed it had the whole thing right. Eg. This for "What is Gell-Mann amnesia?" - contrast to the actual meaning. [1] > Gell-Mann amnesia is a term coined by science writer Michael Crichton to describe the phenomenon where people tend to forget information that contradicts their preconceptions or beliefs. The term is named after physicist Murray Gell-Mann, who won the 1969 Nobel Prize in Physics for his work on the theory of elementary particles. > According to Crichton, Gell-Mann amnesia occurs when people encounter information that contradicts their beliefs, but rather than updating their beliefs to reflect the new information, they simply forget the information and continue to hold onto their preconceptions. This type of cognitive bias can be a significant barrier to learning and can lead to flawed decision-making. Learning from ChatGPT as if it's similar to "books, blogs, courses, etc" really doesn't seem like a good idea. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Crichton#GellMannAmnesiaEffect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Crichton#GellMannAmn...
- 4y ago
- varispeed 4y ago> “However, ever since the chatbot has come into action, it has been negatively impacting students' learning.” Aka welp students prefer to learn from ChatGPT rather than our teachers who have poor knowledge transfer skills. I've been using ChatGPT daily and it is an incredible tool. I feel that I learned so much more through that time than if I had to use Google and books.
- okamiueru 4y agoAs long as you can process it in a productive and skeptical way, and not accept it with the same confidence it is presented, it can be a powerful learning tool. However, if it teaches kids to no longer need to structure sentences or logical arguments, and to trust whatever it says. That seems bad in general. I found ChatGPT to be very useful in two areas: 1. where the problems are simple, and the question requires rudimentary knowledge, but of something very domain specific. Where, I would be 100% able to find a better answer myself by reading up on it, but I can get there 90% of the way, and figure out the 10% that is missing or wrong out of context. If you don't have the ability to fix or identify that last 10%, you might suffer more for it. You'll get there more quickly, but you end up at slightly the wrong place. 2. When the questions are creative in nature. Suggest an imaginary setting, character, describe properties associated with, etc.
- babyshake 4y agoThere is an article today in the New York Times about ChatGPT and education, indicating that teachers view ChatGPT as a threat. Treat it like a search engine. It's important to not always use it to replace basic reasoning skills, but ultimately it needs to be treated like a tool that is incorporated into the curriculum. Of course, educators won't know how to do this for a number of years. But maybe ChatGPT can explain to them how to do it.
- arcticfox 4y ago> indicating that teachers view ChatGPT as a threat. Not what they meant, but it may be somewhat of an existential threat to the profession of teaching, the thing is a killer tutor in subjects that it is confident in. It is a perfect fit for language, especially, since it can carry a full conversation with you and correct every single one of your mistakes. Obviously it has major issues with inventing things out of whole cloth and accuracy problems, but human teachers also aren't 100% reliable or knowledgeable about everything, so it's not like it has to be perfect.
- weird-eye-issue 4y agoThe ChatGPT Discord is incredibly active and is largely students
- moneywoes 4y agoDid the verification work for you?
- weird-eye-issue 4y agoSorry, what verification?
- Obertr 4y agoI believe this is going to transform the way people learn. Instead of learning in a structured they are going to learn exactly what they need. You don't need to know about physics molecules until you face a task related to it. And ChatGPT can direct you to learn more about it. I am in my bachelor's right now and I see how I can skip a lot of knowledge regarding some low-level computer science skills until I really need them. And at the moment if I can't go further without learning how to effectively optimize ML algorithms using CPP I will hear from ChatGPT that I need to go that way. Otherwise: skip. It is not good enough to provide a whole curriculum for sure. But it is sufficient to get directions to which parts I need to learn. The education is going to be transformed into "tree" | "unstructured" | "NoSQL" instead of a clumsy set of blocks everybody needs to go through. This is my opinion
- Obertr 4y agomaybe in future teachers are going to be a help to use ChatGPT. And the curriculum will be only <suggestions> which you must follow to explore the subject on your own. and at the end of the lecture you just share what is the most interesting finding you have dig up. and which experiments you can perform using that knowledge. and collaborate with others who had the same <search graph> (read interests) in this field like you.
- imranq 4y agoWon't this just make everyone much more reliant on these technologies since they cannot to any task without asking the "omniscient chatbot"?
- ihatepython 4y agoIf the majority of young people feel the same as you, the future will probably be very similar to the movie 'Idiocracy'.
- KineticLensman 4y ago> You don't need to know about physics molecules until you face a task related to it. And ChatGPT can direct you to learn more about it I don't think ChatGPT will really help you learn about actual 'tasks' related to molecules except generating short text paras about them
- localhost 4y agoHumans tend to not like change, particularly in institutions that are themselves resistant to change. Education today is very much like the education in the early 1900s - designed to educate a compliant workforce who would work in factories. Neat rows of desks lined up before an authority. Wide availability of these tools will create a new "AI Native" generation. What this will do I don't know. Some effects will be good, some bad. Narrowing to just me, I find the real value I get while learning is asking questions along the lines of "is this concept like this other concept that I know?" When I get an affirmative, then ChatGPT often goes on to tell me something else that I didn't know. These kinds of interactions are very valuable to me. Example from last night in the middle of a long chat: "How is the query representation computed? Also, is the dot product between the query and key representations similar to computing the cosine similarity between two vectors?" "The query representation is typically computed by applying a linear transformation to the hidden states of the input words, often represented as vectors. This linear transformation is typically implemented as a fully connected layer, or a matrix multiplication, followed by a non-linear activation function, such as a ReLU. The resulting query representation vector has the same dimension as the hidden state, and it's used to measure the similarity between the word and the other words in the input sequence. The dot product between the query and key representations is similar to computing the cosine similarity between two vectors. The cosine similarity is a measure of the similarity between two vectors in a multi-dimensional space, and is defined as the dot product of the vectors normalized by their magnitudes. The dot product of the query and key representations can be seen as an un-normalized version of the cosine similarity, in the sense that it computes the dot product of the two vectors. The result is a scalar value, which represents the similarity between the two vectors, the larger the scalar, the more similar the vectors are. The dot product, however, is just one way of computing the similarity, other similarity measure, like the euclidean distance, the L1 norm, or even other more sophisticated similarity measures can also be used. The choice of similarity measure depends on the task and the model architecture, also the dot product has the advantage of being computationally efficient, which is important when dealing with large scale models like transformer based models."