4 ms·
Gas stoves aren't a significant _environmental_ problem, certainly in terms of CO2 (in fact, unless your electricity is almost entirely renewable or nuclear, th
by rsynnott 4y ago
Gas stoves aren't a significant _environmental_ problem, certainly in terms of CO2 (in fact, unless your electricity is almost entirely renewable or nuclear, they're probably marginally better than electric from a CO2 perspective). There is a concern that they're a health risk, though (though the evidence that there's a large effect is somewhat weak).
Personally, I like my gas stove, though I expect to have to adapt to something else in my lifetime (the big push in Ireland is towards heat pumps, and once gas heating goes it will not be economic to maintain the home gas network just for stoves).
- bryanlarsen 4y agoA CCGT is about 60% efficient, and an induction stove is about 3x as efficient as a gas stove. So cooking directly with gas uses over 50% more gas than cooking on an induction top using electricity generated from gas.
- rsynnott 4y ago> A CCGT is about 60% efficient Depends exactly where you live, but it's unlikely that all the gas generation is by CCGT; a lot of places would use far less efficient plants for peaking at least. > and an induction stove is about 3x as efficient as a gas stove Hmm, where are you getting this? From a quick look, gas stoves are about 40-50% efficient, induction about 85%. You also have to consider transmission loss, and the possible (in many places likely) presence of coal in the electricity supply. In any case this is all pretty irrelevant; stoves just aren't a big enough piece of peoples' energy consumption.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIt was a quick Google that I can't find again. Efficiency numbers vary widely, since the size of the pot makes a big difference in the efficiency of gas or conventional electricity. In one experiment, using coal fired electricity to boil a pot of water on induction released 0.29 pounds of CO2. Using natural gas to boil a pot of water released 1.16 pounds. https://zeroenergyproject.com/2016/10/24/induction-cooks-better-gas/ https://zeroenergyproject.com/2016/10/24/induction-cooks-bet... As you said, it's fairly irrelevant. The point is to reduce natural gas heating and methane leaks. Natural gas cooking is a side effect.