6 ms·
> "But old cars break down and are expensive to get repaired" Yes, but you don't have money to pay someone else to repair it, old cars have cheap parts and are
by mschuster91 4y ago
> "But old cars break down and are expensive to get repaired" Yes, but you don't have money to pay someone else to repair it, old cars have cheap parts and are relatively simpler to repair, learn how to do it, you're not in a position to be fussy about what skills are beneath you if you can't pay someone else to do it, stop thinking so highly of yourself and get to it!
You're ignoring the "boots theory" [1]. A new or somewhat-recent used car is like the pair of boots of the story - the poor person that buys a trash barely roadworthy 2000$ car each year pays at least 20000$ over ten years plus whatever the extra cost of maintaining a trash car each year is, higher insurance rates, more fuel and has more trouble with unreliability and the followup costs (i.e. unplanned uber/whatever fees to get to work because the car broke down). Not to mention if they do repairs themselves, they need to have or acquire the skills and tools and have the time available for doing such repairs. Neither of this is cheap.
In contrast, the rich person who either buys a decent new/recent-used car or finances it pays roughly the same amount of money if he sells the car after these ten years, paid less for maintenance, insurance and fuel, had less issues getting to and from work and a higher quality of life.
The real problem is that a full time employed person in most Western countries can no longer afford a new Western-made car without going into serious amounts of debt. Cars have gotten too expensive and wages (especially after tax, rent and basic costs of life) have gotten too low - a complete turnaround from the Ford era whose principle it was that a worker should be able to afford the product he makes in a reasonable time!
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boots_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boots_theory
- DocTomoe 4y agoAs someone who only ever bought what you would describe as "trash" cars of up to 2000 Euros, let me give you some data. Looking through my car repair/TCO excel file, I average to about 60 Euros per month in maintenance and repairs (that includes stuff like new tires every once in a while). Over the average lifetime of my cars (which is 5 years), that's 3600 Euros in repairs and maintenance. I regularly sell the cars for 500 Euros, so that's a TCO of ((2000-500)+3600) = 5100 Euros per vehicle, or about 1020 Euros per year. The initial, 6-month manufacturer-suggested service for a new car alone is upwards of 2000 Euros, for a car that should not have and trouble. Most cars are nowadays impossible to repair yourself, or repair cheaply (new headlight bulb was 3 Euros before, now you have to change the whole 1300 Euro unit). But let's assume I'll have 150 Euros in maintenance per month... that's 9000 Euros. Depreciation over 5 years easily is a third of the vehicle's value, let's say 10000 Euros overall, on top of maintenance and repairs. Together, I get to a TCO per year of 3800 Euros, or a whopping 2780 Euros more! Now, fuel efficiency. I drive about 25000 km/year. My clunkers consume - on average - 7.5 liters per 100 km - that's about 31.4 MPG. For something comparable, the manufacturer (if we want to believe them) currently lists about 5.8 liters per 100 km, or 40.6 MPG. This means that I could save 475 liters of fuel with a new car. A liter right now costs about 1.80 Euros, meaning I am leaving savings of 855 Euros on the table. So ... I pay 2780 Euros more to save 855 Euros - BEFORE the extra cost of a loan to buy a new car ... NOT a good deal.
- dusted 4y agoI'm not entirely ignoring it, but I don't believe it holds true for things like cars. I've driven bangers my whole life, I mean really driven them to death, some to the point where they die on the highway, and I will do a quick inspection to decide whether I want to fix that or just have it towed direct to junk. Now, cars are insanely taxes in Denmark, near 300%, and they lose about half their value the first year of ownership. Every 2 years, there is a mandatory inspection of the car. I buy a car with the following requirements: 1. My strong intuition that it can survive for 2 years with zero maintenance. 2. After 2 years, my TCO will be less than if I rented a new car. 3. It's freshly inspected so I don't need to worry about that for the next 2 years. Sure, I get to drive old cars, but I bear zero risk, if I crash it, or someone drives into it, or I chose to use it as a ladder while wearing muddy boots (has happned) to reach something up high, I can do it, I can treat it as trash, it does not matter, it's not losing any value because I already wrote it off. A rental car, you can't destroy.. I feel having a car that I can destroy is worth more than driving a new car. If, after 2 years, it looks like it can pass inspection, I try, and if it's cheap to fix, I fix what needs fixing, and drive another 2 years. This is a super-win situation, because then my yearly COO becomes about half of what it costs to rent. If it can't pass inspection, I toss it, and buy a new one and I have "broken even" compared to renting. I get the "don't worry about maintenance" perk of renting combined with "not getting in trouble if it's pretty beaten up when I'm done with it" perk of owning. Sure, it means that I run a risk of a sudden breakdown, in that case, I'll get it towed (to junk or home to fix) and I'll have to take the bus, work from home or arrange a day off for fixing it, but it's been my experience that it almost never happens that a freshly inspected car fails randomly within the two years until next inspection.
- mschuster91 4y ago> I'm not entirely ignoring it, but I don't believe it holds true for things like cars. I've driven bangers my whole life, I mean really driven them to death, some to the point where they die on the highway, and I will do a quick inspection to decide whether I want to fix that or just have it towed direct to junk. Yeah, but you have the knowledge and skills that you can determine if a beater car is worth the effort. Most people, however, do not have either of these... they get shafted by car salespeople who just want to push cars off their lot and fleece people later-on for repairs. And the problem just gets worse with more modern cars - I can fix up something like a Volkswagen T4 van or probably, if it comes around, a lot of shit on any 90s era car. But for anything more modern, particularly stuff where you need specialized diagnostic toolkits, 2000ish Renaults where you have to plan three to four hours for a headlight replacement [1] or built out of aluminium or worse, composite material? Fuck that, I'm out. Modern car construction has completely sacrificed repairability in favour of crash resistance, lighter weight and/or cheaper assembly. [1] https://www.ehow.co.uk/how_6471814_replace-headlight-renault-megane.html https://www.ehow.co.uk/how_6471814_replace-headlight-renault...
- buescher 4y agoThe boots theory does not really hold for mass produced items, including boots. A usable pair of cheaply made boots costs less than resoling a good pair of boots. I propose the Buzz Bissinger boots theory: Buzz is not rich because he buys fancy boots, Buzz buys fancy boots because he inherited a lot of money. https://www.gq.com/story/buzz-bissinger-shopaholic-gucci-addiction https://www.gq.com/story/buzz-bissinger-shopaholic-gucci-add... The sweet spot in TCO for cars is generally (look at Edmunds numbers) a new compact in base trim. TCO will go up with a more expensive or "higher quality" car. If you are in the position between choosing to finance a new compact at low/reasonable interest rates or pay outright for a beater, the new car will be the better deal. A used compact is actually an OK compromise if you don't have money up front or want lower payments - a 5-year-old Corolla has slightly higher TCO than a new one, but not by that much. Being able to pay on time for a compact car requires some basic financial stability but that's not "rich".
- mschuster91 4y ago> A usable pair of cheaply made boots costs less than resoling a good pair of boots. Yes, it does, but it's worse for everyone: - those who make the shoes because the conditions under which clothing in general is made are horrible (see e.g. the numerous instances of fires in Bangladeshi factories) - the environment because these cheap boots are made out of fossil resources, they have to be shipped around, and at the end of their life time they can't be recycled so they either end up in landfills or, worse, trash incinerators - for the end user since shopping boots consumes time and effort For cars, hell for virtually all mass produced items, the same principle applies. And it's only "cheaper" because a lot of the problematic factors involved are costs that are externalized.
- buescher 4y agoOh ok, I was wrong. Working people should spend more of their paychecks on boots to prevent fires in Bangladeshi factories, and then it will be more comfortable walking to work because they can't afford a car. And no shopping in your utopia either.
- 4y ago