7 ms·
Iran is not some backwater and it's not north korea. When politicians sing about "bomb Iran" these are the innocent people they are talking about killing http
by ck2 15y ago
Iran is not some backwater and it's not north korea.
When politicians sing about "bomb Iran" these are the innocent people they are talking about killing
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6v6kF8i-mbw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6v6kF8i-mbw
http://www.theatlantic.com/infocus/2012/01/a-view-inside-iran/100219/ http://www.theatlantic.com/infocus/2012/01/a-view-inside-ira...
Before 1970 you would not be able to identify pictures of iran from parts of the usa
http://www.pagef30.com/2009/04/iran-in-1970s-before-islamic-revolution.html http://www.pagef30.com/2009/04/iran-in-1970s-before-islamic-...
Currently Iran is just the result of what happens if conservative fundamentals got ahold of the government of a country.
Yeah the nuclear bomb makers and holocaust deniers have to be stopped, but let's show some care and understanding for innocent people under their rule first.
- ctchocula 15y agoAm I being paranoid or did "A View Inside Iran" link get deleted from Hacker News? edit: Yes, I was being way too paranoid. The article only has 3 upvotes and isn't on the first three pages, which surprised me, but I suppose more technologically interesting articles such as this one may be more appreciated here.
- zalew 15y ago> Before 1970 you mean before 1979 > but let's show some care and understanding for innocent people under their rule first. if they cared, they'd lift the embargo on aircraft parts so these people don't die because of badly maintained passenger planes
- burgerbrain 15y ago"if they cared, they'd lift the embargo on aircraft parts so these people don't die because of badly maintained passenger planes" Huh? He is saying that we should show care... I think you should re-read what he wrote.
- zalew 15y agoIn the context as a whole it looks different for me. But does it really matter? offtopic: from the fluctuation of upvotes/downvotes on my few last comments in the last few hours, I see some people treat hn like reddit - downvoting based on opinion. Not that I care about those 3 karma points, just sayin'.
- burgerbrain 15y agoThe entire sentence is: "Yeah the nuclear bomb makers and holocaust deniers have to be stopped, but let's show some care and understanding for innocent people under their rule first." The context is condemning people who think of Iran as "something that we should bomb", without considering the human factor. Your comment is just very bizarre to be honest. I can only interpret it as a complete non sequitur. offtopic: In my experience, fluctuations in voting indicate that people are experience a significant amount of confusion when reading your post.
- zalew 15y agoMaybe, but you can easily assume that the ones who can 'stop' (bomb makers and holocaust deniers have to be stopped,) aren't hn readers but govs. Other thing is, a lot of people aren't aware that such embargos not only hurt the regime economically, but directly affect the safety of those innocent citizens for decades. Misunderstood or not, the case is still valid. ot: it was not about this particular comment exactly, but whatever. I just don't use downvote here to express I don't agree with someone. let's leave it alone, doesn't matter.
- mahmud 15y agoDo people earn their humanity by their proximity to Standard American Ideals? What about those who are very much unlike Americans? Do you they deserve to get nuked back to the $EPOCH?
- yid 15y agoUm...he was actually supporting your point.
- dextorious 15y agoYeah, but he also adds: "Currently Iran is just the result of what happens if conservative fundamentals got ahold of the government of a country." Well, not all can be explained by "conservative fundamentals getting ahold of the government". This amounts to "their people are really like us, it's their government that's bad". There EXIST people/populations/countries that are conservative/unlike Americans in general, and have every right to live however the f* they want to. Western media turn a blind eye to millions of Iranian/whatever people that WANT to live like they do, and RESPECT their country's ideals, and instead celebrate a few hundred idiots with tweeter accounts and blogs that want to live like westerners and are totally unrepresentative of the general population -- a lot of them sponsored by foreign countries (at least with lectures, sponsorships etc). What exactly is specifically bad about the Iranian government that other countries have not already did, including the US? US has: the death penalty (including teens), segregation until, what, the 60s (!!!), 500% more black people in jail than white, one of the largest prison populations in the world, hollier than thou attitude, tons of fundamentalists and bible yielders, tons of wars around the globe to secure oil and resources, huge corrupted multinationals, some 20% of the population below the poverty line, on of the lamest popular cultures worldwide, PIPA, SOPA, the Patriot Act, detention and/or murder of foreign nationals without trial, etc...
- dendory 15y agoWhen people talk about Iran it's more about the things that are, by any definition, wrong, than their traditional or religious choice. You simply cannot, in any modern society, discriminate against someone because it happens to be a woman, or throw stone at someone until they die because you didn't like his opinion. You can defend ideals, you cannot defend barbarism. Some of the things these people do (and others in various parts of the world) are uncivilized in any society.
- corin_ 15y agoSo it's not OK to bomb Iran but North Korea and you have no problem - are you under the impression that everyone in North Korea is evil?
- StavrosK 15y agoI would like to see this answered as well. The OP's point makes no sense to me. Is North Korea inherently filled with evil people, or what? Every country is full of innocent, misguided, and often oppressed people. Why is there justification to bomb anyone? At most, bombing might be a necessary evil, but no country's residents "deserve it".
- nl 15y agoI think the author's point was that Iran is a sophisticated industrial society ("not a backwater") and the people have a wide range of views ("not North Korea").
- ck2 15y agoYou are correct, that is exactly what I meant about the sophistication level. Hence no surprise they could dissect a drone. By no means was I implying it would be acceptable to bomb north korea!
- rospaya 15y ago> When politicians sing about "bomb Iran" these are the innocent people they are talking about killing Isn't that every country?
- jbooth 15y agoFor the 2nd part, yeah, for the first part Iran's the only place you hear glib talk about how we should bomb it to prove how tough we are in presidential debates.
- michaelcampbell 15y agoI haven't been keeping up with the GOP speeches (I assume you're referring to the GOP nominees), but all I've been able to come up with is Santorum mentioning Iranian nuclear sites, and only if they weren't open for inspectors rather than some sort of display of machismo. Are there others I've missed?
- rpeden 15y agoIt was John McCain a few years ago: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-zoPgv_nYg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-zoPgv_nYg
- jbooth 15y agoAt a couple of the debates, basically everyone except Paul was competing as far as how badly they wanted to bomb Iran. I'm hoping that they weren't serious and were just cynically talking about killing lots of people in order to get a good soundbite for the rubes, but it's scary any way you interpret it. It's like these people are totally disconnected from the fact that they're talking about war. First article for "republican candidate iran" from Google: http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/12/07/us-usa-campaign-republicans-idUSTRE7B61OH20111207 http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/12/07/us-usa-campaign-re... EDIT: Here's an account of the exchange I was thinking of, Paul made the extremely controversial statement that he wasn't in favor of starting a war, and they all piled on him immediately. The fox news guy said he "jumped the shark" by not advocating immediate war. http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Elections/President/2011/1216/GOP-candidates-blast-Ron-Paul-over-Iran-policy.-Is-one-side-crazy http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Elections/President/2011/1216/G...