4 ms·
Simple solution - gender equality for time off related to pregnancy. Paternity leave for the same length of time.
by zdw 15y ago
Simple solution - gender equality for time off related to pregnancy. Paternity leave for the same length of time.
- masterleep 15y agoSimpler solution. Let people make arrangements they want.
- swombat 15y agoSimplest solution: move the fuck out of Hungary.
- andorjakab 15y ago5 out of 10 friends have already done so. Sad thing is, it won't work on a European level. You can't just say, everybody move the fuck out of Europe. :)
- _delirium 15y agoBoth approaches seem to work well in various situations, which is why I'm skeptical of the value of these kinds of rants which lack comparative analysis. Apparently it works badly in Hungary; but works well in Sweden. It'd be more enlightening to read some analysis of the differences, since it empirically isn't the case that strong parental leave policies always and everywhere cause high unemployment, even if they anecdotally cause one dude in Hungary to not want to hire women. (I'd personally guess that culture and corruption have more to do with the large economic differences between Sweden and Hungary than taxation or parental-leave policies do, so I think he's barking up the wrong tree.)
- droithomme 15y agoIf it's really true that someone who just started work can immediately take three years maternal leave off, fully paid, and then be due 2.5 months accrued paid vacation time when they return, then I can't imagine how that could work. I don't know if it really works that way in Hungary though, or in Sweden for that matter.
- justincormack 15y agoIt doesnt work like that. The company doesnt pay you, the state does, and you get less. You do not get vacation time.
- lflux 15y agoIn Sweden you wouldn't get 2.5 months of accrued paid vacation, it's more like 10 days, as the first 120 days (of 480) (pa/)maternal leave is counted towards vacation. Then again you have the legal right to take 25 days of vacation per year, but not all of these have to be paid.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoApparently it works badly in Hungary; but works well in Sweden. Or perhaps Sweden has a strong enough economy to compensate for the harms caused by this policy, but Hungary does not.
- sliverstorm 15y agoOr possibly an established enough economy. How many startups are there? Billion-dollar companies don't have to worry about it nearly as much as tiny ten-man ventures.
- _delirium 15y agoSweden has a reasonable number of startups relative to its population: MySQL, Spotify, Wrapp, Mojang, Massive, Absolicon, etc. But I agree that the economies are quite different, which is why I prefer careful analysis (preferably based on data) to anecdotes.
- hendrix 15y agoHow can the government mandating the kind of paid-leave in Sweden be good for a startup? Tell me how this sort of policy can increase a new startups short-term cash flow? You can't exactly advertize superior working conditions (Google w/ free food/massages/nerf guns/paid child-related leave) since you do not have any track-record of being the hot new startup. Even if you did have the best working conditions available having to pay out for an employee who is not producing anything would probably kill the startup. Culture/location/talent/vc $ is what makes a company though and to some extent trumps unfavorable tax/labor laws, this is IMO why SV & California have most of the startups as compared to Arizona/Texas or why Scandinavia>Eastern Europe.
- lflux 15y agoI'd say it's good for talent since you don't have to pick a startup depending on what benefits you get (vacation time, health insurance, parental leave) due to the government providing well enough to begin with. Of course employers here can differentiate by offering more vacation, privatized health insurance, pension deals, but the swedish government seems to provide a better package than most US employers do.
- fedd 15y ago> Simpler solution. Let people make arrangements they want. for example, in hard times, or to pay debts, allow to sell oneself into lifetime slavery.
- dextorious 15y agoOnly that doesn't work. The owner of a 100/1000/10000 people company has much more power than the employee in need of work negotiating his salary/working conditions. Not everyone is a "rock star" employee that managers are bending over backwards to accommodate. That doesn't mean that the rest of the hundreds of millions of workers have to work with whatever conditions they can arrange for themselves. If managers could have their way, everybody would be working 18/7 for substinence salary. A society has to make laws to protect the public from that. Politics used to mean: "a way to protect the common folk from bigger powers".
- daniel-cussen 15y ago3 years paternity leave?
- cmars 15y agoRequire equal paternity leave, and the author will be forced to consider married men just as risky a prospect. Better solution: make the employment restrictions apply to a company of a certain size. A large enough company should be well-enough equipped to take care of its employees. A startup company isn't.
- jcdavis 15y agoI am definitely not an expert on US discrimination law, but I believe that is actually the case to some degree-many of those laws only apply to companies with more than 15 people (eg Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964).
- SomeCallMeTim 15y agoI know that some only apply once the company goes past 50 people; I was working for a startup as employee #4 and was looking at the rules for paternity leave (with respect to my then imminent second child) around the time the company passed 50 employees, and it at least kicked in some features of California law, if not Federal law.
- billswift 15y agoIndeed, OSHA is another. That is why a lot of small businesses, mechanics and machinists for example, purposely stay small. They can't afford to grow because of the increasing regulations. There were several studies at the time of the early-1990s recession and again about the time of the dot-com crash about this, investigating the causes of "non-growth", because most new hiring usually occurs in mid-size companies. I don't really understand why anyone surprised that the economy (especially unemployment) is still screwed-up this long with the hammering mid-size companies have taken in the past decade.
- neilk 15y agoEven better solution: don't penalize any employers for their employees' reproductive choices. If the state believes it's a good idea to have a parent at home, the money for maternity and paternity should come out of the state's coffers. And I'd encourage everybody to be open about their plans to have kids or not. If this results in undue discrimination against people raising kids, offset it with a corporate tax break for employing people with dependents. This would be really expensive, but probably cheaper than the costs that a destitute single mom or a poorly-parented kid can inflict on society. And at least the costs would be borne by everyone, and both businesses and their employees could be honest and plan realistically.
- Xylakant 15y agoWe do have something pretty close to that in germany since roundabout two years. Either parent of the child may take paternity of up to 12 month in total. I think the mother gets a little extra time and there is a bonus of two month if both parents choose to take a leave of at least two month (so then it's 14 month in total). You get paid the lions share of the wage you had by the state. There's quite a couple of fathers that take at least the two extra month, but I actually know personally two fathers that opted for the full twelve month with their wifes taking the extra two. It will probably take another couple of years until that's widespread though. I can look up the exact details if anyone's interested. I think this is a pretty good solution to balance the fact that it's women that need to carry the child - now companies have less of an incentive to penalize them for that.