3 ms·
It's very much cultural. I got married and had a kid in my 20s because that's when my Bangladeshi mom said it was time. Like you we sat around for years while o
by rayiner 4y ago
It's very much cultural. I got married and had a kid in my 20s because that's when my Bangladeshi mom said it was time. Like you we sat around for years while our friends remained single and childless, and it was alienating. If I hadn't had the strong influence from a non-American culture it might have turned out differently.
- tptacek 4y agoWhat was alienating about it to you? We had our first when I was 21. I don't remember social alienation being one of the big issues (but that's just me) --- when you become a parent, your social circle changes and you tend get closer to other parents.
- rayiner 4y agoIn a society that lays out a strict life order sequence and encourages people to have kids in their 20s—such as in the subcontinent, or the US in decades past, or in the US today outside metro areas—your social circle doesn’t change dramatically. You naturally transition to parenthood with your existing circles (friends, cousins) around the same time.q You can see how this would be a disincentive to have kids. People obviously like their friends, and being the first one who has to drag a baby to boozy brunch is no fun. That’s why scolding and shaming from moms and aunties is critical to breaking the collective action problem.
- toomuchtodo 4y ago> That’s why scolding and shaming from moms and aunties is critical to breaking the collective action problem. Perhaps younger cohorts ignoring these people and their input contributes to the change in fertility rate? Depends on the culture of course, some take longer than others to discount generational advice.
- rayiner 4y agoYes, but it’s bi-lateral. Late boomers and Gen-X were the first cohorts in America fully socialized into the precept of individual sovereignty. Their kids are thus the first generation where the parents aren’t pushing for grandkids, and the kids are also comfortable disregarding whatever parental pressure exists.
- tptacek 4y agoYou say "individual sovereignty", I say "agency".
- rayiner 4y agoAgency is where you decide how to do what society has prescribed you to do. Gen X’s notion that you can reject society’s prescriptions and do pretty much whatever you want so long as you don’t hurt someone else—narrowly defined: the hurt felt by a parent who is deprived of grandchildren or by children who suffer from divorce doesn’t count—goes beyond autonomy into social libertarianism.
- tptacek 4y agoWhoah. That's a strange definition of "agency". It's suggests that the Ukrainians of the Holodomor had more agency than we credit them for, doesn't it? I'm not trying to dunk on you. I just think your definition is broken and has taken you to a weird place.
- em-bee 4y agobut that only works if there are other parents your age. if every other parent out there is 10 years older then it may be a bit difficult. especially in a society that looks down on having children when you are young.
- tptacek 4y agoWhy? Did this happen to you? It certainly didn't happen to us.
- rayiner 4y agoWhat didn’t happen to you? Having to find new friends because most of your existing ones had kids 5-7 years later than you? Or do you not see how having to find a new friend group—versus entering a new life stage together with existing friends—can be quite a drag?
- tptacek 4y agoOk, well, to start with, the assumption that you keep your existing friendship dynamics when you enter into parenthood at roughly the same time is also dubious. Like: if it's literally the same time, or you're really good friends, sure, but my experience of friends who had kids either a year before or after me is that they fell off the face of the planet. You get them back, you know? If you want to? We ended up with a superset, of the social circle we had just before we had kids (I was super young so it's weird to talk about "friends I had before we had kids", but we have a bunch) and the friends we made because we had kids. What's really corrosive is having to move a bunch. What's striking to me about this is, I'm not exactly the most sociable, go-along get-along person on this site. I'd have assumed if these were huge problems I would have experienced them.
- rayiner 4y ago> Like: if it's literally the same time, or you're really good friends, sure, but my experience of friends who had kids either a year before or after me is that they fell off the face of the planet. I don’t see why that would be the case. Out of my friends who had kids within a couple of years of us, we’ve remained good friends. What causes the distance in my experience is years of living very different lives and having less and less in common and less and less to talk about. > You get them back, you know? If you want to? We ended up with a superset, of the social circle we had just before we had kids (I was super young so it's weird to talk about "friends I had before we had kids", but we have a bunch) and the friends we made because we had kids. By contrast I had the same experience as the other poster above. Making friends with other parents was awkward, because in my circle almost all the parents were 5-10 years older. We were grinding away as junior professionals and when we’d meet other parents from say my daughter’s class, they all had our bosses’ jobs. It was only when we moved to “real America” that we started meeting other parents we could easily relate to.
- em-bee 4y agohow old are you now? i in my 40s full of energy and ready to see the world. i wish i could have had kids in my 20s, because they would be old enough by now to leave me independent. and in difference to my 20s my income is now better allowing me to afford many things i could not earlier.