3 ms·
> However, the discovery of Tocharian changed this situation: Tocharian was the easternmost of all early IE languages, yet was a centum language! Thus, the theo
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> However, the discovery of Tocharian changed this situation: Tocharian was the easternmost of all early IE languages, yet was a centum language! Thus, the theory had to be abandoned. We now think that neither centum nor satem languages form particularly closely-related groups; rather, the various groups each independently underwent centumisation or satemisation
I have some questions about this:
1. If the various language groups underwent independent centumization or satemization, it seems like that should have happened somewhat differently to different groups.
1a. Are there satem languages that didn't lose the /n/ in their word for 100?
1b. Are there centum languages that merged k into ḱ rather than the other way around?
1c. (Anything else along these lines? You're the expert.)
2. Why does the geography of Tocharian matter to the hypothesis that centum / satem reflects an early split between "proto-centum" and "proto-satem"? People move; it would be easy for the centum languages to divide from the satem languages and then rearrange their own geography.[1] Tocharian is spoken in a region known for its extreme mobility and ethnic turnover. Just to the west of the Tarim basin there was a region that spoke Greek ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dayuan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dayuan ); what does this tell us about how and where the division between Hellenic and its sister branches occurred?
Similarly, the Indo-Iranian languages are currently distributed with Indic languages to the east of Iranian languages, but they used to be the other way around.
[1] It would also be easy for the division to take place just as described, one time early on, but without affecting some places that are to the east of a particular longitude. Happens all the time.
A distribution like this:
ooxxxxoxx
oxxxoxxxx
tends to suggest that if the X-O split was a unitary event, the O people must have been overrun by X people afterward. But a distribution like this:
kkkkkkkkk
kkkkkssss
says nothing of the kind. That could easily be a unitary split that just remained in place over time.
- danans 4y ago> 1a. Are there satem languages that didn't lose the /n/ in their word for 100? the /n/ in the word for "hundred" in Proto-Indo-European (PIE) was a vocalic nasal /m̥/, and is reconstructed as *ḱm̥tóm. PIE Sanskrit Old Persian Latin English --- -------- ----------- ----- ------- \*ḱm̥tóm śatám satem centum "hundred" In Indo-European vowel gradation, this is known as the zero-grade form [1], and its phonetic realization evolved differently in daughter languages. /m̥/ became the -en' in Latin "centum" (the /n/ is due to assimilation with the following /t/, and "a" (schwa) in Sanskrit "śatám" (Old Persian "satem") Furthermore, this transformation occurred in all instances of the zero-grade vocalic nasal, regardless of whether it is adjacent to a PIE *ḱ. For another example, PIE *gʷmsḱeti ("goes/goeth") becomes Sanskrit "gacchati". Notice that in this case, the /m̥/ transforms to "a", just like in *ḱm̥tóm -> śatám, but here after *gʷ. This demonstrates that the transformation is independent of whether the preceding velar sound is palatalized or labialized. The original nasal /m/ is however retained in other forms of this Sanskrit verb, like its root form "gam-" (PIE: *gʷem-) which is in the lengthened grade [2]. > 1b. Are there centum languages that merged k into ḱ rather than the other way around? None that I'm aware of, but happy to learn of an example. > Why does the geography of Tocharian matter to the hypothesis that centum / satem reflects an early split between "proto-centum" and "proto-satem"? People move; You're right that geography isn't deterministic, especially as it pertains to language, and Indo European has been a very mobile language family. That said, most of the centum languages to this day are western languages and most of the satem are eastern. The big exceptions are Slavic (satem), Mittani (satem), and Tocharian (centum). 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-European_ablaut#Zero_grade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-European_ablaut#Zero_grad... 2. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E0%A4%97%E0%A4%9A%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%9B%E0%A4%A4%E0%A4%BF https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E0%A4%97%E0%A4%9A%E0%A5%8D%E...
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> This demonstrates that the transformation is independent of whether the preceding velar sound is palatalized or labialized. But that's not really what I was asking for. The claim was that (0) we used to think the centum/satem split reflected a single division in some ancestral language, but (1) now we have evidence that it actually reflects several similar independent innovations. So I was trying to ask whether (for example) the loss of the first nasal in a satem-side word for 100 is independent of whether the same sound is lost in other satem languages, not whether it's lost independent of a particular phonetic context within the same language. The idea would be that if all the satem languages feature the same set of changes, that's probably just one split. We can provide an example from the centum side; Latin (and English) preserve the nasal (ceNtum / huNdred) but Greek does not (heka_ton). But that's not enough to say that Hellenic centumized independently of Italic and Germanic; perhaps they all centumized together and then Greek's N was independently lost. I still don't understand why Tocharian being centum in the east would be considered to contradict the theory that the centum/satem split was one ancestral innovation as opposed to many independent innovations. bradrn explicitly links these two concepts, and so does wikipedia: > It is no longer thought that the Proto-Indo-European language split first into centum and satem branches from which all the centum and all the satem languages, respectively, would have derived. Such a division is made particularly unlikely by the discovery that while the satem group lies generally to the east and the centum group to the west, the most eastward of the known IE language branches, Tocharian, is centum. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centum_and_satem_languages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centum_and_satem_languages ) But what's the connection? That looks like an unrelated fact to me.
- danans 4y ago> I still don't understand why Tocharian being centum in the east would be considered to contradict the theory that the centum/satem split was one ancestral innovation as opposed to many independent innovations. The way I understand it is that Tocharian was an early branch from PIE (reflected partly in its grammatical divergence from it's relatives) that preserved the original centum pronunciation, and that the centum/satem split we refer to today came later. I'm not sure if the other commenter meant it in that way, though.