4 ms·
The problem is this is mostly due to screening, not progress at treating advanced cancer, although that has improved too.
by paulpauper 4y ago
The problem is this is mostly due to screening, not progress at treating advanced cancer, although that has improved too.
- hooande 4y agoWhy is this a problem? The point of screening is to find and treat the most common forms cancer before they become advanced.
- nluken 4y agoI get what you're saying: it's a bit of an apples-to-oranges comparison since better screening means we're comparing cancers of different severities. I don't necessarily see that as a problem, though, since a lot of these earlier screened cancers would have become more advanced cancers down the line. If our testing were perfect such that we could detect all cancers early enough to stop, that would functionally be a cure, no?
- jagraff 4y agoThe thing we don't know is which early cancers actually progress to advanced cancer. It's possible that we detect more things that look like cancer, but that would not have ever progressed into full blown metastatic cancer (at least, not before the patient died of something else). So that could artificially make it look like we've gotten better at treating cancer, when actually we've just gotten better at detecting non-life-threatening cancer.
- chimeracoder 4y ago> So that could artificially make it look like we've gotten better at treating cancer, when actually we've just gotten better at detecting non-life-threatening cancer. No, because the death rate is measured at the population level, not at the incidence level. Fewer people are dying today of cancer than 30 years ago. The only way that detection bias could impact that outcome is if you make the argument that a large number of terminal cancer cases were going undetected in 1991 at the time of death.
- pasquinelli 4y ago> If our testing were perfect such that we could detect all cancers early enough to stop, that would functionally be a cure, no? no. being able to detect cancer doesn't mean people are getting tested twice a year for their whole life. for example, you wouldn't have routine cancer screenings for children, but sometimes they get cancer, and on those occasions it'd be nice to have better treatment options.
- nluken 4y ago> it'd be nice to have better treatment options. No disagreement with you there. By "perfect screening" I assumed a "perfect" patient set where problems brought up at annual checkups lead directly to tests which lead to detection, but perhaps that's a naïve assumption to the point of uselessness. Still, I think it's easy to write off screening advances as skewing the data set vs. actually saving lives, when they do in fact help people that otherwise could have been much sicker.
- tshaddox 4y agoWe wouldn’t normally even consider talking about these things as if they’re in any way mutually exclusive, would we? Like normally we would all understand that it’s good for cars to get safer and for trauma care to get better.
- kragen 4y agoif cancer screenings for children were painless, lower risk than the cancer, and cost five dollars, you would totally have routine cancer screenings for children i mean maybe not in the usa but in sane places
- timerol 4y agoThe "US Cancer Death Rate" talked about in the article is measured in deaths per 100,000 population, not deaths per detected cancer. So we are comparing apples to apples, but finding and treating cancers earlier could be helping to result in fewer deaths.
- londons_explore 4y agoOr it could simply mean that another cause of death has increased. Like heart disease/diabetes from ever increasing obesity rates. A person can't die twice, so if heart disease gets them first, then they won't die of cancer.
- chimeracoder 4y ago> Or it could simply mean that another cause of death has increased. Like heart disease/diabetes from ever increasing obesity rates. You could hardly have picked a worse counterexample. Deaths from heart disease have fallen dramatically over that time period, even faster than cancer deaths have dropped. Deaths from strokes - which at one point equalled deaths from all cancers combined - have fallen as well, although much of that drop occurred before the time period in question. Deaths from diabetes are actually quite few in number compared to heart disease and cancer. They've sort of plateaued over this time interval, which isn't good news, but hardly the alternate explanation for the reduction in cancer deaths. Now, there is one big cause of death which we haven't addressed: COVID-19, which causes about 3x the number of deaths as diabetes, and over half the number of deaths as all cancers combined. But that only began in 2020, and this data shows a decrease across the entire interval, so it's not relevant here.
- TylerE 4y agoDiabetes is almost never the direct cause of death, but it’s damn hard in the body. Hurts circulation, hurts your nerves, hurts your organs… and it can flare badly in reaction to some medications. So, the cause of death won’t be “diabetes”, it’ll be heart attack, stroke, chronic infection, something like that. Similar to AIDS in that it doesn’t kill you directly (not that we know that juvenile diabetes is a thing, and we routinely test for it), it just makes any other health challenge much dicier.
- xupybd 4y agoScreening, the HPV vaccine and dropping rates of smoking. It would be nice if we could stop advanced cancers but at least we're getting better at prevention. I lost my dad to cancer last year. It's a horrible disease. I really had no idea how horrific it is. My dad had a year longer than his initial prognosis thanks to new immunotherapy drugs.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> The decline in smoking rates in the U.S., better early detection and innovative treatments including immunotherapy drugs have driven a drop in death rates since 1991, the report said, averting an estimated 3.8 million cancer deaths in that time. Yes. I expected to find that the decline in smoking has also lead to the decline in fatal cancer — and there it is. Still a good thing.
- cokeandpepsi 4y agoit's crazy how fast smoking died out in the US even 10 years ago it felt people were puffing away all over the place
- caeril 4y agoIndeed. Now we just need to do the same for overeating.
- melling 4y agoThat’s not a problem, it’s the key to curing cancers, according to Craig Venter @15:40 early detection is the way to eliminate cancer: https://youtu.be/iUqgTYbkHP8 https://youtu.be/iUqgTYbkHP8 https://youtu.be/iUqgTYbkHP8?t=15m37s https://youtu.be/iUqgTYbkHP8?t=15m37s The reason people die from pancreatic cancer when they get it is because we can’t detect it early.
- ZainRiz 4y ago"problem" is a bit of a strong word, but when someone says "Cancer Death Rate Dropped" dropping people assume "Cancer Rate Dropped", which is not at all the same thing The article provides no numbers about cancer rate dropping. Yet the false association between the two ideas is so strong that even the authors themselves seem to theorize that the cancer rate itself is dropping because people don't smoke as often now. Conflating those two concepts seems like a Very Bad Idea
- Retric 4y agoThe % of the US population that dies every year from cancer has dramatically reduced. The % the US population that is detected to have cancer is up dramatically. The rate of people getting cancer in the US is a different question, but presumably it’s been increasing due to the aging population independent of other causes. https://www.statista.com/statistics/241494/median-age-of-the-us-population/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/241494/median-age-of-the...
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoI think this would only matter if some of the additional detected cancer would have gone away on its own. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that's impossible. It's different for e.g. Flu, where more testing = more detection of an illness that would not necessarily have become serious, had it gone undetected.
- stonemetal12 4y ago>detected cancer would have gone away on its own. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that's impossible. What if they detect a slow growing cancer that wouldn't have become a problem before you hit the age of 150? Not every cancer is aggressively trying to eat its host whole.
- msla 4y agoThere have been some wonderful advances in cancer therapy, such as immunotherapy. For example, Rituxan (rituximab) only dates to 1997, but it's already in a number of chemotherapy protocols, leading to a clear improvement in survival rates in previously difficult-to-treat cancers such as aggressive non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rituximab https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rituximab https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6398399/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6398399/ Flashier, and something I've already talked about, is CAR T-cell therapy, the first generations of which were approved in 2017. This therapy has definite risks of severe side-effects, but it can result in complete remission of cancers that have survived multiple lines of chemotherapy, as happened with me. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAR_T_cell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAR_T_cell Immunotherapy isn't just promising, it's here, and, because of it, so am I, but even more exciting is that it gives us more avenues of research to build off of known-useful therapies.
- Hackbraten 4y agoCongrats for your success!
- jorvi 4y ago> For example, Rituxan (rituximab) only dates to 1997 It is kind of scary to me that drugs these days have such long regulatory lead times that a drug developed in 1997 is just now being entered into treatment regimens. I understand why that is (the Thalidomide tragedy stuff and like that), but I also clearly remember reading an article ~10 years back that asked why cancer treatment seemingly hadn’t made any leapfrogs since the ~70s, and the answer was back then they could aggressively iterate on treatments.
- msla 4y agoI think you misunderstood: I said it dates to 1997 because that's when it was first approved for use in America. It's not that new in cancer therapy, with R-CHOP (the CHOP protocol plus Rituxan) apparently being introduced in the early 2000s: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9036549/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9036549/
- codegeek 4y agoI wouldn't use the word "problem" but to explain it better, cancer rate itself has not dropped necessarily but due to early detection, number of deaths from cancer has dropped. We still have a long way to go to actual be able to cure cancers especially in advanced stages. Still a good win but more work to do.
- smt88 4y agoIt's mostly due to the reduction in smoking, not screening. Screening helps, but it often extends lifespan and healthspan rather than preventing a death.
- vikingerik 4y agoAvoiding cancer in the first place matters too. Lung cancer is a lot less common, now that nobody smokes any more. The rate of lung cancer deaths for men has halved since 1991, which itself accounts for half of the overall decline.