5 ms·
The end of the high school essay
- Finnucane 4y ago"We’ll never again need to hire someone to write a pretty good press release, a pretty good medical report or a pretty good investor deck. " See also: glass houses, throwing stones.
- Pet_Ant 4y agoThe way I explained it to a friend is that GPT will put writers out of business much in the way that Lorem Ipsum did. If you want something that looks real-ish from across the room, sure, but when you need it to be real then it's not going to cut it. Would you trust a legal document generated by a probabilistic model and not proofed by a lawyer?
- ghaff 4y agoFor that matter, Seth presumably knows better about things like press releases and investor decks. They may be formulaic. But those had better be real approved quotations and legal is going to want to see backing for any claims you're making or numbers you're using. Writing the press release is pretty much trivial. It's all the other stuff that's hard.
- wudangmonk 4y agoI get the idea but I'm not sure I agree on the example. To me, writing a legal document and translating from legalese seems like something an AI would be great at. An example like a novel would be something I agree more with since I don't see that happening at the moment.
- Pet_Ant 4y agoTranslating from legalese into English for reference is fine because it can be wrong... because the binding form is the legalese contract so any deviation from it is already risky.
- jleyank 4y agoGiven that these engines know how words are associated but not their meanings, some amount of human editing is required to avoid bogus text. Things like a missing not or pro-/anti- switches or removing any biases in the training set. But an editor can look over a whole lot of generated documents.
- thanatos519 4y ago"The answer is simple but difficult: Switch to the Sal Khan model. Lectures at home, classes are for homework." I think this could actually work!
- ksd482 4y agoMost of the students won't have the discipline/environment to watch lectures diligently at home.
- screamingninja 4y agoWe cannot really call them "students" then, can we?
- nickthegreek 4y agoNot in America it can't. I've worked for a 15,000 student K-12 online school.It is truly tragic hearing about the home/living conditions that many of the students had to deal with.
- yamtaddle 4y agoLike 99% of "what if we just..." suggestions, especially (but not only!) from those outside of teaching and education, are obviously bad ideas to anyone who's had even a little insight into how those fields actually work.
- 4y ago
- edgyquant 4y agoAll this will do imo is push the needle. People will get better at writing and better at seeing that it’s an auto generated text blob. Also you can still quiz the kid on the writing and the understanding of the concepts: thinking that having to write about them (and forcing them to pad their thoughts to a certain number of words) is the only way to ensure understanding is Byzantine and conservative for conservations sake.
- retrac 4y agoWhen I was in school in Ontario, about 30 years ago, homework was for practice. It was evaluated usually, but not a major part of the final grade; grades for homework were mostly for simply (trying to) complete it. Some students will get their parents or friends to proofread it. Some don't have parents who can read. Some students will cheat; there's software out there that'll make doing homework easier than it should be. (Very guilty of that one myself even back then.) We were expected to write essays in class, during class time. Most of our grades were based on that. In my later years of high school, my teachers stopped even checking my homework for math etc, unless I wanted them to. Grades for my final year courses were almost entirely from in-class exams and projects. From what I've heard it's still similar here, even with remote schooling. (Though that certainly creates its own issues!) Is it different elsewhere?
- skeaker 4y agoIt is different elsewhere, yes. Your school was unfortunately a rare exception. Most schools everywhere I've been mandate homework and give it significant value towards your final grade. If you have multiple classes (which you do), they will often have no regard for each other when assigning homework, so you are often left with no time to meaningfully absorb any of the assignments (and occasionally no time to possibly so much as complete all of them). Self guided schooling like yours is unfortunately still viewed as a new wave hippy-esque thing.
- annyeonghada 4y ago>new wave hippy-esque thing Strange because I'm from [country in EU]: homework generally have no bearing on the final grade and considering homework it's considered permissive and hippy-esque: they can cheat, copy, make the parents/siblings do it, ask the Internet to do it and so on. The actual, rigorous evaluation happens in class and only in class, homework assigned so you can prepare for the actual test.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- agnosticmantis 4y agoFor English speakers, of course, for now.
- Pet_Ant 4y agoOh come on, how difficult can it be for any language with a considerable corpus available? I mean maybe not for Linear B, but French, Spanish, German, Japanese, and Chinese should easily be next. In fact, it might be even easier due to their stricter grammars. Only considerable barrier is marking up the training data... how hold do you think that damn will hold?
- cgranier 4y agoChatGPT is quite capable of generating content in Spanish. Not sure how many good lectures are available on YouTube though.
- bigpeopleareold 4y agoI was playing with ChatGPT in Norwegian a few weeks ago and the results looked good. Of course, that's not a typical language, but there is at least a lot of source material. I wanted to try it now but they are having issues :)
- corytheboyd 4y agoA take I haven't heard yet that isn't just "chat robots bad": It's not like the output of a teenager means anything, the whole point is that they activate their brain to critical thinking and learning. The exercise of making ChatGPT output look convincing, and familiarizing yourself with that output to defend it if questioned, is still a learning exercise. It looks different, but it's honestly just as impressive as them writing about what Hamlet was thinking when his dad died or whatever the fuck that was about.
- annyeonghada 4y ago>critical thinking and learning If my experience with essays means anything is that to receive a good grade you need to regurgitate the teacher pet causes using the most flowery language possible. No thinking involved.
- corytheboyd 4y agoIt's not like business is any different... in which case it's just as easy to call that a sign of intelligence, depends on how you look at it
- yamtaddle 4y agoI was pretty surprised to discover that no-one in business gives a fuck if you cite your sources. On the rare occasions when you really need to, they also don't care if you use any kind of special formatting for it, and might even find it weird and off-putting if you did. They also don't mind if you "cheat" (seek extensive help on a piece of work without asking if that's OK first, or "steal" something that already exists). Usually, they prefer you do. Results matter, and maybe not breaking the law. Beyond that, nobody cares. I've also not once used all that business letter-formatting crap we wasted so very much time on in elementary school. WTF.
- corytheboyd 4y agoYeah I remember fretting so much over things like MLA, but then you get a job and your bosses boss can't seem to figure out the complex landscape of their/there/they're... preeeettyyy frustrating
- nashashmi 4y agoUntil we understand the limitations of ChatGPT (see Stephen Wolfram's post), it is entirely premature to immediately begin identifying the ways in which learning should change. Seth is posting a rant against essay writing. As a millenial (who saw the advent of the internet change school curriculum), I know that our workload became more intense after internet became more pervasive. Before it would take a trip to the library to write a paper. Now, we were doing 4 times as many papers and consuming 4 times as much information, making us X times(!) smarter than our predecessors. And we changed the rules of the workplace dramatically. (We were usually just as competent, if not more competent, as the more senior people in the office. & We were usually underestimated.) AI is going to do the same to education. It is not going to make children less capable of writing, but far more capable of writing. Children are literally going to go over AI generated information and make it better. I should start fearing the next gen of young adults. I am going to be just as outdated as the boomers are today.
- stcroixx 4y agoAnd we changed the rules of the workplace dramatically. (We were usually just as competent, if not more competent, as the more senior people in the office. & We were usually underestimated.) I hope this is a joke.
- nashashmi 4y agoIt isn’t. And I don’t mean better from a woke agenda perspective. I mean technically better with stronger work capabilities. We used to lack in the experience game 15 years ago. But that has changed now. https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/02/14/millennial-life-how-young-adulthood-today-compares-with-prior-generations-2/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/02/14/millenn... https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/06/what-can-we-learn-from-millennials/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/06/what-can-we-learn-fro... https://techcrunch.com/2015/07/05/how-old-school-management-kills-work-culture/ https://techcrunch.com/2015/07/05/how-old-school-management-... https://techcrunch.com/2015/07/20/hold-up-millennials-we-dogs-still-know-a-few-tricks/ https://techcrunch.com/2015/07/20/hold-up-millennials-we-dog... https://techcrunch.com/2015/06/27/the-millennial-delusion/ https://techcrunch.com/2015/06/27/the-millennial-delusion/
- frgtpsswrdlame 4y agoI don't know, did Wolfram Alpha end homework problems for Calc 1? Not really, because it's useful practice for the test you will probably take. Pointless essays will be diminished but for stuff like AP English exams, where you have to sit down, read a passage then write an essay analyzing it, essay-writing is still the most useful homework. If anything, I think it just enables a larger gulf between those who know and those who don't. I knew plenty of people who in my HS Calc class used Wolfram to do all their homework and then flubbed the tests. I also knew kids who did the homework the way the teacher intended and then I knew some of us who used Wolfram as a way to get unblocked. I see that as more where these language models fit in. Not that never again will a high school student have to write a dumb essay, but never again will a smart kid writing a dumb essay be stuck with writer's block staring at a blank page. Run GPT, generate 1000 words, read, start stealing and rephrasing and reworking until you get back in the flow.
- whyenot 4y agoChatGPT is also (superficially) good at grading high school essays. I find it slightly amusing that students may be submitting essays written by AI, that then some instructors may be grading it with the help of an AI. BTW ChatGPT does not seem to have a very high opinion of its own writing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- timmb 4y ago"that AI will be the death of learning & so on; to this, I say NO! My student brings me their essay, which has been written by AI, & I plug it into my grading AI, & we are free! While the 'learning' happens, our superego satisfied, we are free now to learn whatever we want" Attributed to Zizek by https://twitter.com/LuminanceBloom/status/1600598003391266816 https://twitter.com/LuminanceBloom/status/160059800339126681...
- lelandfe 4y agoThere's no way that ChatGPT allows for an entire essay in a prompt, right?
- jmcphers 4y agoOn the contrary, ChatGPT appears conversational because it basically feeds the entire chat history into the model to generate each subsequent response.
- lelandfe 4y ago...which is to say, that you partition feeding the essay over many prompts? The token limit of the entire chat history is different than what's permitted in a single prompt. Paste in a large amount of text and you'll see it for yourself.
- ShamelessC 4y ago
- fishtoaster 4y agoI spent my school years from grade 4 or so to grade 10 writing the most awful bog-standard school-style essays for assignments. The 3-paragraph structure, the rigid sentences, the fact regurgitation... I got good grades, but I'm sure the teachers hated reading them as much as I hated writing them. In a similar timeframe (starting from grade 7 or 8), I started writing online. I mostly participated in online debate forums because I couldn't find anyone with (in my highschool opinion) an open mind to argue with in my small town. I'd happily write detailed 12-paragraph posts on the topic dejour in a natural voice with independently researched and well-cited sources. I distinctly remember being in 11th grade when a switch flipped. I was writing another dreadful essay on the meaning behind The Scarlet Letter for an English class when it occurred to me: what if I wrote this like I was posting on onlinedebate.net? Instead of writing a "persuasive essay" as half a decade of school had taught me, I wrote A Post arguing a point like the internet had taught me. I got an A and the teacher loved it. I wrote everything from there on out like how I actually wrote, not how I thought HS essays were supposed to be written. I don't know that I have a strong lesson from this. I learned nothing about how to write from school and a lot from the internet. No idea if that's generalizable, though. All I can say with confidence is that I hated (and still hate) The Highschool Way of writing essays.
- yamtaddle 4y agoSimilar story here. Seems silly, maybe, but I credit more of my ability to write a college-quality passage or short paper, by the time I graduated high school, more to... way too much time spent posting on Slashdot, of all places, as a kid, than to school. Helps when you don't have to pad your writing to hit a page count, and can just get straight to the point :-) Went into college with fewer bad high-school-induced writing habits than others usually have. As soon as I figured out the professors wanted my Slashdot-writing, not my shitty high school essay writing, it was smooth sailing.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThe school writing rules are helpful but are table stakes to good writing. I don’t think it’s either or.
- lofatdairy 4y agoI like the Sal Khan model personally, but given the difficulties with online school w/ regards to adherence and attention I'm not sure it universally scales. Add onto the fact that students might have questions and will have to save them for the day after, leading to being behind overall -- I'm not sure it extends that well. Essays aren't fun to write and are obviously trivial w/ LLMs, but the in class solution could definitely work. In high school they're obviously shallow and formulaic, but idk if there's no benefit at all. Even writing shallow comments on internet forums benefit from practice writing coherent sentences lol
- ghaff 4y agoAt some point, you need to give a shot at teaching writing (and, for that matter, presenting) in high school. I'm unconvinced on the write an essay in class idea; seems like sort of a waste of class time. Writing is not a mostly a real-time collaborative exercise. (Writer's room I know but that's not high school. As a group exercise, you'd end up with one student probably doing all the work.)
- lofatdairy 4y agoI suppose less an real-time collaborative exercise, and more of a way to encourage short bursts of repetition -- in line with how debaters have to quickly formulate and synthesize speeches in high school and college. Writing is obviously not trivial to learn nor to teach, but rhetoric used to be the center of education during the classical period and being able to quickly organize ones thoughts is just as important as turning it into language.
- ghaff 4y agoI never did debate--though I've seen it--and my understanding is it turned into a pretty formulaic enterprise. It's pretty different from a 5-10 minute presentation on a topic (which we did on a rotating basis in high school English).
- nluken 4y agoEssays might not be the best way to assess reading and writing skill, but this article's reasoning leaves a lot to be desired. The author seems to value an essay insofar as it demonstrates reading comprehension, and not as a vehicle for teaching writing skill. Students need to understand what they are reading to write an essay, but the writing itself is another skill entirely that the author here doesn't seem to address. I read a lot of my peers' works in college and came to the conclusion we need to encourage more writing skill, not less. > Students get more points for good typing and clear sentence structure than they did for actually thinking deeply, questioning the status quo or changing their minds. I hear this all the time from engineering types. Writing well means finding a clear, compelling way to communicate your ideas. Sure, we should try to avoid hiding bullshit behind a façade of flowery prose, but a great idea communicated poorly is useless. > If you grew up in a household with verbally agile family members, you probably did way better on essays than your peers, but not due to much effort on your own. And? If you grew up in a household with engineers, you probably did better at math. I don't get how this affects any one given assignment type over another.
- klodolph 4y agoI think it's even worse--the value of learning writing is that it means learning to think clearly. The only reliable way to write clearly is to think clearly. For complicated topics, writing and thinking go hand in hand. Most people simply can't keep large subjects in their head, at least, not at first, not without tons of extra time and effort. If you are trying to write a paper and you have gaps in your understanding of the topic, you'll discover those gaps in the writing and fix the gaps in your understanding. If you make a guess that seems intuitively right and write it down, the lack of justification will stare you straight back in the face. I think writing essays about Jazz in 10th grade social studies classes helped my career as a software engineer.
- a4isms 4y agoAs an author, I agree with what you are saying 100%. But I'm not sure that you are disagreeing with the OP. His point--as I understand it--is that you don't get better marks for writing an essay about Jazz that is clear, complete enough not to have gaps, and deep enough to display comprehension versus writing something that is digestible and flows. In other words, you are being graded on the superficial form of the essay, not the depth and completeness of your thinking. You may have chosen to close the gaps and dig beneath the surface, buta s he says, the system strongly discourages teachers from grading you on your thinking. Unless the essay was in a music course, how could a teacher know enough about the subject matter to grade you well, except by happy accident that they are also a Jazz afficionado? If an essay asks every student to write about their favourite hobby, which teacher can grade all the essays at that level? I agree that one of the great values of writing is to force you to think a thing through, but my read of TFA is that unless you are holding yourself to that standard, you need a reader who will hold you to that standard, and a high school teacher is statistically unlikely to be that reader. And therefore, assigning essays in high school for the most part does not help students. Those students who hold themselves to a higher standard than trying to efficiently acquire high marks will benefit, but the rest will not.
- csw-001 4y agoMy inclination would be to actively require students to use AI in drafting. It seems plausible to me that successful work in the future will require AI collaboration. The skill we are looking for is apparently output based (like much of the work we turn in for pay later in life - we get paid for output, not process) - getting to the final product with AI shouldn't just be rewarded, it should a skill that is actively taught. It's a tool kids need to learn how to be good with, akin to "googling", it has its limitations that kids should learn first hand. Edit: typos... because this wasn't written by AI...
- sacrosancty 4y ago[dead]
- bitwize 4y agoProps to them for shouting out Danny Dunn and the Homework Machine. Danny Dunn was the kid star of a series of youth-oriented novels from the 1950s that were early exemplars of the "kid and scientist adventure" genre that's persisted in media to this day in the form of Jonny Quest, WarGames (original concept), Back to the Future, and Rick and Morty. His eccentric neighbor Professor Bullfinch would invent sci-fi gizmos or involve himself in scientific malarkey that Danny would get sucked into and cause all sorts of trouble. In this case, the gizmo was Miniac, a powerful but miniaturized (fits in a room), clanking 1950s computer. It had a microphone that you could ask questions into and it would type out cogent answers (much like GOT today!). Danny Dunn, placed in care of Miniac while the professor is out if town, instantly realizes the homework automation potential of the machine, but the mean kid breaks it causing it to output wrong answers and he and his friend Irene must actually know their stuff in order to see that the answers are wrong and fix it. Finally their teacher basically tricks them into using it as a research tool and actually expanding their minds. I'll leave the implications for today's GPT-equipped kids as an exercise. It's a great book and a great series. I wish more kids were exposed to its like today.
- a4isms 4y agoWhat may have even more impact on HN readers is the possibility that we are seeing "The end of the bloviating blog." I say this as someone who—under the pen name raganwald—built much of my public reputation writing blog posts. But looking back, many of my blog posts were low-effort and superficial. The ones I'm really proud of in hind sight are few and far between, and they were the ones where I had something to say, and put some work into both researching and saying it. The rest could easily have been written by AI, if not now, soon. And just as the author says is the case with high school essays, the correlation between blog posts I'm proud of today and the payoff at the time (marks for high school essays, online popularity for blog posts) is tenuous at best. Popularity is driven by a bunch of factors, and a decade ago, a lot of those factors involved cosplaying an insufferably overconfident techno-priest. (I am not saying I wrote great stuff that nobody liked. The ones I'm proud of also touched people in some way. But looking back, social media was not set up to reward putting a lot of work and thought into writing, not even HN.) I'm kind of happy that AI is able to automate and industrialize relatively shallow and low-effort writing. The sooner we recognize that it is not a signal of either hard work or deep thought, the better IMO. That is... If we as a species recognize it. If not, we are on our way to a really boring dystopia where public sentiment is driven entirely by deep-pockets gaming every form of social media we create.
- blueridge 4y agoRead... Autocomplete: Coming to terms with our new textual culture https://hedgehogreview.com/web-features/thr/posts/autocomplete https://hedgehogreview.com/web-features/thr/posts/autocomple... and https://blog.ayjay.org/the-media-ecology-of-college-writing/ https://blog.ayjay.org/the-media-ecology-of-college-writing/
- yamtaddle 4y ago> There’s not a lot of evidence that getting good at writing book reports or regurgitated essays under typical high school conditions leads people to success or happiness later in life. Possibly true, but most people never get good at writing. Or at reading, for that matter. Including college grads. Perhaps, for the ones who do, it does lead to success or happiness later in life! The story with language skills isn't all that different than math skills: most folks top out around the middle grades, or maybe early high school, and never get much better. People just treat them very differently. They'll volunteer that they suck at math, while lots of poor readers and writers take any suggestion that they're not good at those activities as a grave insult. "Bad at math" is regarded as normal, while "bad at reading" is considered pretty close to "moron". > The first challenge of the essay was the asymmetrical difficulty in giving useful feedback. 30 essays, 5 minutes each, do the math. It doesn’t scale, and five minutes isn’t even close to enough time to honor the two hours you asked a student to put into the work. This is true. Grading in writing classes is incredibly time-intensive, if you want to do a good job of it. It scales very poorly, as some schools and teachers discovered when they tried to put higher student loads on remote language arts teachers during Covid. > Students get more points for good typing and clear sentence structure than they did for actually thinking deeply, questioning the status quo or changing their minds. If you grew up in a household with verbally agile family members, you probably did way better on essays than your peers, but not due to much effort on your own. Well, sure, but also grading standards can only be as rigorous as admin and parents allow them to be. Start demanding that kids get actually good at writing to receive good grades and you're likely to have a bad time. Grading must be tuned so that practically all kids who show up (and many who rarely do) will pass, and a very high proportion will receive A and B grades. Rocking that boat is not usually a great career move. You'll have admin and parents up your ass in a hurry. > So, now that a simple chat interface can write a better-than-mediocre essay on just about any topic for just about any high school student, what should be done? > The answer is simple but difficult: Switch to the Sal Khan model. Lectures at home, classes are for homework. Mmm. Given the level of compliance I saw in college, when it came to reading assigned material, I'm not convinced this is a good solution to widely deploy. Or, the experience of many with remote school during Covid. It's worth remembering that tons of strategies that work great for ideal students fall apart when applied to average or poor students. I have a feeling this would just turn into the teacher trying to cram the lesson into the first 10 minutes of class, so their classes' test scores don't fall down to the Earth's core. > In a school that’s privileged enough to have decent class sizes and devices in the classroom, challenge the students to actually discuss what they’ve read or learned. That's... just expensive prep schools. Especially the decent-class-size part. Vanishingly few public school teachers have an average class size under 15—mainly special ed, or high school teachers who are lucky enough to mostly teach "smart kid" electives. Most are more like 18-23, and quite a few are a lot higher. Ask any teacher and they'll tell you class runs way smoother, discussions are better and the students more engaged, and they get more material covered when a large chunk of a class is out because the flu's raging through. Ignoring all the rest of this and just cutting the average class size in half would be a huge improvement, but it's also not going to happen. Meanwhile, yes, four- to ten-student discussion-based courses that expensive prep schools often use absolutely are a very good model—if you have the money. > At first, this is harder work for the teacher, but in fact, it’s what teachers actually signed up to do when they become teachers. > This is far less cohesive and controllable than the industrial model of straight rows and boring lectures. This seems to assume at least better teachers, on average, and possibly more of them. Either of those means far more spending. It's not happening. > If we want to train people to take initiative, to question the arguments of others, to do the reading and to create, perhaps the best way to do that is to have them do that. This is what elite prep schools already do. We know that model's better—it didn't suddenly become true when ChatGPT came around. Public schools just don't have the money (or freedom to kick out highly-disruptive students) that is required to do that. > We’ll never again need to hire someone to write a pretty good press release, a pretty good medical report or a pretty good investor deck. Those are instant, free and the base level of mediocre. The opportunity going forward remains the same: Bringing insight and guts to interesting problems. I do wonder what's going to happen when poor readers and writers not only start judging AI writing, but their feedback (via which passages they choose to keep, if nothing else) is incorporated into the model to encourage it to produce more writing like that. I've known business owners who couldn't write coherent instructions for making a peanut butter sandwich—and I mean for a normal person to follow, not the excessively-precise kind that's sometimes used to demonstrate how computer programs work—and degree-holding managers and bureaucrats whose writing could be outdone, in terms of how well it communicates a message, by a somewhat-bright fifth grader. What kind of writing are they going to select, when they tell ChatGPT 8.0 to generate, say, marketing copy? Will it be "pretty good"?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Gatsky 4y agoPerhaps there is a role for those writing tools which record everything you write as you go including edits, revisions etc. Faking this reliably will be pretty tedious. It'll be like showing how you arrived at the answer in maths. You submit the finished work and your recorded writing process. Not sure why this isn't already used, since it would stop people paying someone to write the essay for them as well.
- subjectsigma 4y agoI took German in high school. My senior year German teacher was chill as all hell and there were only like six or seven people in the class. Our final exam was oral and we were supposed to answer a set of five prompts with a minimum of 2-3 minutes per prompt. I was really dreading the exam because I’m a fairly shy person, but ended up loving it. After we got through the first prompt she ditched the exam and we ended up just having a 15-minute conversation in German. (My German was significantly more developed than it is now, after years of not practicing…) Was much more engaging and a better judge of my knowledge than filling in multiple choice bubbles. I wonder if (for places that can afford it) we will go back to a model where students are required to be on-prem and speaking aloud. Significantly harder to cheat or fake answers. Extremely time consuming and also vulnerable to biased teachers, though.
- alex_young 4y agoChatGPT has some interesting thoughts on the subject: The argument that the end of the high school essay is a good thing is misguided. While there may be some challenges associated with the traditional essay format, such as difficulty in giving useful feedback and a lack of emphasis on deep thinking, banning the use of GPT-3 and other technology is not the solution. Instead, we should use this opportunity to find a better way forward. First, we should acknowledge that the traditional essay format does have limitations, such as the difficulty in providing useful feedback and the emphasis on superficial elements such as typing and sentence structure over deep thinking. However, these limitations do not negate the value of the essay as a tool for developing critical thinking and writing skills. Instead of banning GPT-3 and other technology, we should explore ways to use them to enhance the essay-writing process. For example, GPT-3 could be used as a tool for providing feedback and helping students improve their writing. Additionally, we should focus on finding ways to provide more meaningful and effective feedback to students, rather than relying on superficial metrics. Furthermore, we should also consider the reasons why essays are assigned in the first place, and ensure that the assignments are aligned with these goals. Essays are not assigned to simply prove that students can read and write, but to encourage deep thinking, questioning the status quo, and the ability to develop and express persuasive arguments. In conclusion, the end of the high school essay is not a good thing, but rather an opportunity to find a better way forward. We should not ban GPT-3 and other technology, but rather use them to enhance the essay-writing process and focus on providing more meaningful and effective feedback to students, while also aligning essay assignments with the goals of developing critical thinking and writing skills.
- lostmsu 4y agoThis is probably 10th+ article on the topic on HN. And still good part of the comments are focused on the essays problem. Considering the rate of the progress, grading high students in the next 5 years is not going to be the most important thing to worry about.
- anthlax 4y agoMy current best use-case for chatGPT is to shorten emails. I’m the kind of person that will add a lot of prose to emails - I plug much of my writing into chatGPT saying “please shorten this email” and it works well. Not perfect (sometimes cuts out important info) but well! This is to respect my teammates times.