4 ms·
Buildings with sewage leaks, inadequate electrical systems, and vermin infestations are a public health hazard, e.g. fires from electrical malfunctions. Right,
by cperciva 15y ago
Buildings with sewage leaks, inadequate electrical systems, and vermin infestations are a public health hazard, e.g. fires from electrical malfunctions.
Right, and that's why (most) cities have building codes.
Typically, owners are given the opportunity to correct violations and fined if they do not. As fines accumulate, governments will often work with prospective purchasers in order to make transfer of the building's ownership economically viable and provide relief to owners who are unable or unwilling to comply with minimum property standards established by law.
It seems to me that the fundamental problem here is that landlords can dodge fines by selling a building. If the tenants of sub-code buildings received a statutory reduction in rent until the building is back to code requirements, there would be no incentive for landlords to operate sub-code buildings.
The issue of imposing externalities on tenants is, however, entirely orthogonal to the issue of building equity which I was responding to.
- Vivtek 15y agoRight, and that's why (most) cities have building codes. Right, and that's why it's only profitable to strip mine for equity if you engage in fraud to avoid the building codes.
- hncommenter13 15y agoThis shouldn't be an effective strategy. In many municipalities, the code enforcement bureau can record abatement liens, which must be paid before title to the building can transfer. In some cases, civil penalties enforceable in a court of law may also be applied to the property, which the current owner may disclaim if they existed at the time of purchase (so the prior owner must pay). See, for example, the FAQ from Sonoma County (outside of SF). http://www.sonoma-county.org/prmd/faq/code-enf.htm http://www.sonoma-county.org/prmd/faq/code-enf.htm
- brudgers 15y agoAs a practical matter, municipalities often hesitate to encumber problematic properties with large liens because they make transfer of property to a new owner with better promises less economically viable. The theory that the prior owner must pay, is simply not the case. First because liens run with the land regardless of ownership, and secondly, because a new owner's name cannot be recorded on the deed until the lien is cleared (and thirdly because everything in a real-estate transaction is negotiable).
- hncommenter13 15y agoIf you read the link, it says that in the case of a civil penalty (not a lien), the prior owner can be excused from paying under some circumstances.
- brudgers 15y agoBuilding codes regulate construction. They do not regulate existing structures. That is why there are property maintenance codes (as well as fire codes).
- cperciva 15y agoI think in my area (Vancouver) there's a set of codes which cover both new and existing buildings; but yes, I should have been clearer.
- brudgers 15y agoConstruction occurring on existing buildings falls under the building codes. However, existing buildings in which no construction is taking place are not regulated by the building codes - as noted previously, building codes regulate construction. Thus, they are silent in regards to the maintenance of existing structures and the ways in which they are occupied, hence property maintenance and fire codes respectively - e.g. the building code inspects a fire sprinkler system when it is in installed, a property maintenance code may require continuous water service to the structure, and the fire code require that the system is regularly tested. Here is the Vancouver, Washington Property Maintenance Code: http://www.cityofvancouver.us/MunicipalCode.asp?menuid=10462&submenuID=10478&title=title_17&chapter=14&VMC=index.html http://www.cityofvancouver.us/MunicipalCode.asp?menuid=10462... With proper Canadian propriety, here is Vancouver B.C.'s "By-law to prevent the existence of untidy premises within the City of Vancouver": http://vancouver.ca/bylaws/4548c.PDF http://vancouver.ca/bylaws/4548c.PDF
- ori_b 15y ago> If the tenants of sub-code buildings received a statutory reduction in rent until the building is back to code requirements, there would be no incentive for landlords to operate sub-code buildings. However, then there would be an incentive for tenants to the building damage through neglect or abuse in order to avoid paying rent.
- yason 15y agoHowever, to counter this as renters the tenants are or should also be liable for any neglect or abuse that falls out of regular wear and answer to the landlord. Deliberately breaking property or failing to notify the landlord of, for example, water visibly leaking into the building structures or occasional light smoke out of the fuse box means that while the tenant could try to legally avoid having to pay rent but end up paying (likely) much more for the damages. Or is this not true in the U.S. or certain states or cities in the U.S.?