4 ms·
Yeah, I assumed they meant they were going to federate Medium articles, so you could follow a Medium author on a Mastodon instance and see their articles in you
by kragen 4y ago
Yeah, I assumed they meant they were going to federate Medium articles, so you could follow a Medium author on a Mastodon instance and see their articles in your feed. (You could also display replies from the rest of the Fediverse as comments on the Medium article; that way the reply authors wouldn't lose their writing when Medium goes out of business or sells to Google.) That would have been a huge announcement; possibly good, possibly bad, but either way of huge impact.
This is still somewhat significant because if you see comments from @someone@me.dm you'll know it's the person who goes by the same name as a Medium author, who you might know from elsewhere. This would be more effective if the Mastodon instance were at something like fed.medium.com though.
- toastal 4y agoYou could and should do this with Write Freely or similar today. I don't think a company’s desire to close off its ‘product’, host ads, and require sign-ins align with that the Fediverse wants to do. This isn’t like a co-op where funds are spent just to cover maintenance and server fees.
- kragen 4y agoThat's why I was so surprised to see the headline! I'm not used to seeing Medium respect other people. But it is what Tumblr plans to do, apparently.
- saurik 4y agoActivityPub is a protocol. It can try to define itself as a community all it wants, but at the end of the day it is as much of a community as SMTP is a community. If a for-profit company wants to send e-mail notifications to its users about blog posts--and even if it also wants to embed really horrible advertisements--it should not only get to send e-mail, it should be encouraged to send e-mail instead of only using proprietary centralized replacements for e-mail (such as mobile push notifications).
- tonystubblebine 4y agoTo me, ActivityPub support is for a different goal and that's because I see short form and medium-form (i.e. blogs) as separate use cases in practice. Mastodon represents a short form corner of the fediverse. To participate in this corner via a medium-length tool would mean participation from people who are blindly syndicating at worst, and having a disconnected experience at best. It'd be disrespectful to the community there. Instead, Medium authors should be fully present as short form participants, even if all they want to do is share a link. To speak in the town square you need to be present in the town square. In the case of Mastodon, that means reading and writing from a short-form app. The point of adding ActivityPub (both ways) would be to be part of a much, much smaller blog-length corner of the fediverse. It's interesting, but is fundamentally a different goal.
- kragen 4y agoMastodon works okay for reading and writing 10–1000 word pieces, but it does start to work badly at 10_000 or 100_000 words, where you want more granular addressability, and where reading is better with an explicit choice of which piece to read. But I feel like most Medium pieces are closer to 1000 words than to 10_000. And there are Fediverse participants (like Write Freely, mentioned asidethread) that are focused more on those longer pieces.