4 ms·
It's certainly not healthy to be perusing Citizen throughout the day, but it's also certainly not "panic fetish". I live in a neighborhood that has a certain a
by crazygringo 4y ago
It's certainly not healthy to be perusing Citizen throughout the day, but it's also certainly not "panic fetish".
I live in a neighborhood that has a certain amount of crime, and Citizen is super valuable to know what's going on, purely from a safety perspective. You ask if I can personally do anything about the "danger" all around me? Yes, I can make sure as hell to avoid certain blocks for a couple hours. And I can find out whether the sirens right now are because of a fire (fine to go for a walk) or because of exchanged gunfire (not).
I just looked it up according to official stats -- 568 shootings in my neighborhood since 2015, resulting in 102 deaths. Maybe you live somewhere where you consider this "panic fetish", but people in some areas don't have that luxury.
It's just basic neighborhood safety awareness of where not to walk.
- troutwine 4y ago> It's just basic neighborhood safety awareness of where not to walk. Sure, I disagree with none of this particularly. My fundamental contention here is that Citizen with its sloppy text-to-speech of the police scanner plus no real follow-up on reports drives users to perceive their environment as more hazardous than it really is, their basic motivation being to push for pumping money out of people. Having awareness of your neighborhood is great but it strikes me that the better way of getting that awareness is through your community, not someone trying to pull cash out of your pocket. I'd have no problem at all with an app like to Citizen that plugged directly into community emergency services, run by the community as a public good.
- crazygringo 4y ago> no real follow-up on reports... drives users to perceive their environment as more hazardous than it really is I don't know about your neighborhood, but when I check Citizen real events get filled with hundreds of verifications, comments, and videos. It's not a case of Citizen trying to invent things that aren't there, sowing some fake sense of hazard. > the better way of getting that awareness is through your community I don't know what the mechanism of community awareness is supposed to be, except Citizen? That is the community awareness, as people are posting and verifying there. > I'd have no problem at all with an app like to Citizen that plugged directly into community emergency services, run by the community as a public good Citizen is plugged directly into community emergency services -- that's the police. And I just don't see how any app is going to be "run by the community as a public good". That makes as much sense to me as saying people shouldn't use Gmail, but an email app run by the community as a public good. It's not scalable or viable.
- troutwine 4y ago> I don't know about your neighborhood, but when I check Citizen real events get filled with hundreds of verifications, comments, and videos. It's not a case of Citizen trying to invent things that aren't there, sowing some fake sense of hazard. Hey, so they do manage to fulfill their stated aims in your neighborhood. Pretty cool. Looking in my own I still see multiple weeks old "shots fired" that my city determined were kids letting off firecrackers. Judging by other comments on this post the, uh, flexible understanding of truth Citizen has is the default, absent a very active-on-Citizen neighborhood. > I don't know what the mechanism of community awareness is supposed to be, except Citizen? That is the community awareness, as people are posting and verifying there. For me, personally, I'm on friendly terms with neighbors I meet on walks, plus the ones that live in proximity to me. The news gets shared as it always has done. I don't live in a small town either. > Citizen is plugged directly into community emergency services -- that's the police. And I just don't see how any app is going to be "run by the community as a public good". That makes as much sense to me as saying people shouldn't use Gmail, but an email app run by the community as a public good. It's not scalable or viable. Why not? If Citizen is working in your community, as you say, then it's already piggy-backing off a considerable amount of free effort that you all do to augment the data it gets for free from your community. What's the point of a for-profit middleman here? I sure can't go to a public meeting and complain to the city council that Citizen is misfiling firecrackers, although I can do that for any misfiled data in my PD/FD's transparency website. And have done. Government services generally aren't 'viable' in the sense of turning a profit anyway, we just all agree to pay into the kitty to fund stuff we more or less get utility out of. (Ignoring that Citizen itself doesn't seem to be viable.) I'm not really sure what your concern about scaling is, but I will note that governments all over, small and large, manage to provide digital services to their constituencies.
- crazygringo 4y ago> For me, personally, I'm on friendly terms with neighbors I meet on walks, plus the ones that live in proximity to me. The news gets shared as it always has done. Except by the time it gets to neighbors on a walk it's yesterday's news. What I'm talking about is up-to-the-minute safety for events that have happened in the past 15 minutes. Only online communication and instant phone alerts are fast enough for that.
- renewiltord 4y agoThat's crazy, man. I can't imagine living like that. But I'm glad you have the tools to protect yourself.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoIt is about the same level as Nextdoor, which is littered with posts that makes you question when your neighbors have time to engage in that level of vigilance. I am comfortable with assigning 'fetish' qualifier to it. It genuinely is that bad. As much I as do not like people losing their jobs in general ( as it tends to have a lot of downstream effects ), I am starting to believe, a good chunk of current internet must go down in flames for society to survive. I am not exaggerating. My personal belief at the beginning of 2023 ( without coffee kicking in yet ) is that, social media is a pox upon this earth that must be eradicated. << It's just basic neighborhood safety awareness of where not to walk. Wait. I thought pointing out facts about stuff like that is racist.
- klik99 4y agoThere is a place where a tool like Citizen can be useful - however a company with VC funding needs to generate returns quickly, which incentivizes growing engagement, which "panic fetishism" is a pretty attractive way of achieving that. Citizen has a pretty solid and valid value proposition, however I don't think the VC model incentivizes a healthy way of building the engagement. You may engage with it healthily but I've seen a personal friend go down a spiral of anxiety and had to delete the app to feel better.
- zirgs 4y agoSo around one shooting per week in just one neighbourhood? That's crazy.
- Balgair 4y agoYou really need to move somewhere else. 1.5 shootings per week for 7 years straight is not okay. Please, move.