3 ms·
I may be an outlier but I really liked the idea of citizen, but just wish it had a better implementation (UI and filters) . People often complain that it led t
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
I may be an outlier but I really liked the idea of citizen, but just wish it had a better implementation (UI and filters) .
People often complain that it led to fear-mongering, but I thought it was a valuable tool for Environmental awareness and community policing.
The people can't reconcile the reality of the world around them with their and irrational fears, that strikes me as a personal problem. I for one just wanted the real time data and could take it from there.
Example of times where it would have been helpful was when there was a an arm suspect hiding out in my neighborhood and another time where I went to a shopping center where there was a armed standoff. More mundane examples are understanding why the Bay Bridge is closed or roads are blocked.
Twitter and local news are the next best alternative, but the time delay and poor geolocation make them unsuitable alternatives.
Hopefully another company comes along with a better business model for aggregating police radio data and eyewitness reports
- smoldesu 4y agoHopefully, people stop profiting off this information in the first place. A for-profit company is possibly the worst arbiter of criminal information, as-evidenced by their CEO putting out warrants for homeless people. They simply can't side-step due process like that. If you need a subscription service to stop yourself from being a victim in a mall shooting, maybe we should reflect on how that effects the greater population.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI dont have a problem with a for profit solution based on anecdotal evidence. You could level the same criticism at anything. What the CEO did wasn't good, but there are tons of examples of public servants, news outlets, and even non-profits grandstanding and fearmongering too. The ideal application would strip away the BS and just provide data access. I dont care if it is non-profit or for profit. What I really don't agree with is the sentiment expressed in this thread and others that individuals shouldn't have access to this data because they are too fragile or stupid to handle reality.
- smoldesu 4y agoIt's not "reality" though. As you said, it's entirely based on anecdotal evidence, which leads to things like the CEO making false accusations. There might be a version of this system that works, but currently Citizen is not it. I suspect that nobody will be able to get it right until they remove the money and focus on credible reporting.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThe meat of the data is police scanner dispatches and individual photography. These are "real" unless you think they a faking police calls and doctoring images. User posts should be given the same credibility as a stranger on facebook or twitter. Even user posts are "real", unless you think they are psyops/bots.
- mrguyorama 4y agoYou should understand that just because someone calls 911 and reports a crime, that doesn't mean a crime has actually been committed. There are many many many instances of assholes and busybodies calling 911 to report a crime when the reality was that they were irrationally upset a black person was in the park. We have videos of these exact people pulling guns on someone with no justification.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI understand that very well, it is not an issue I struggle with.
- BoorishBears 4y agoIf you live in the Bay Area and you think it's a widely useful tool, I'd say you're not doing as great a job reconciling your fear with the reality of things as you think you are. I moved to SF from NYC, and it went from barely useful to the most useless thing I've ever seen. Here Citizen shows extremely stale data and seems to truly struggle with surfacing widely relevant news, because widely relevant things rarely happen here. You described finding out there was an armed suspect hiding out in your neighborhood, but there is no way on earth Citizen should be how you find that out: I had that happen in another city and it didn't take 5 minutes for the area to be swarmed with officers putting the area in lockdown by blocking all entrances and issuing warnings over loudspeaker. Same deal with an armed stand off in a shopping center... you're telling me there was an armed standoff and an app was what was keeping people from entering? Or you mean an armed standoff happened where you weren't and Citizen went out of its way to ping you? - Citizen isn't fear mongering because raising crime issues is fear mongering. Citizen is fear mongering because: > The people can't reconcile the reality of the world around them with their and irrational fears, that strikes me as a personal problem. Is such a widespread "personal problem" that people will say that, then claim they need a personal real-time crime feed.
- s1artibartfast 4y ago>You described finding out there was an armed suspect hiding out in your neighborhood, but there is no way on earth Citizen should be how you find that out: Im not a fearful person, so I am looking for utility and data. I am also the worlds foremost expert on my opinions and experiences, so I can tell you what happened, not the other way around. In the case of the suspect hiding in our neighborhood, our block was swarmed by cops but nobody notified us what was going on. We checked citizen and other scanners to find out what was happening and found out. This let us take practical precautions like locking the front, back, and side doors to the house- which we normally keep open. In the case of the shopping center, I didnt use the app and was driving around the parking lot. Saw about 20 cops and asked a bystander what was going on and I got the fuck out of there. I got the full details 24 hours later from searching the news- a high speed chase had led to the shopping center and the suspect fled inside. In this case, a notification would have been really helpful. Those are the most extreme examples. Much more common is seeing something like the bay bridge being stopped and being able to pull up pictures from the people stuck in traffic. I have used that to determine if it is something like a semi on its side or a flat tire and plan my day accordingly. I haven't used the app in a while, because like I said, the UI is crappy. I do live near a higher crime area and frequently hear gunshots. I'm thinking about going back to the app because I would like to know how often these are real incidents requiring medical response versus people just "having fun". I have read the city crime reports and used their crime database, but it is very delayed and has a terrible UI itself.