3 ms·
> Intel recently demoed the chip hitting 6 GHz on two cores with standard off-the-shelf Corsair AIO water cooling So only 2 cores. They forgot to say for how m
by hulitu 4y ago
> Intel recently demoed the chip hitting 6 GHz on two cores with standard off-the-shelf Corsair AIO water cooling
So only 2 cores. They forgot to say for how many microseconds can the chip sustain this speed.
And 400 A ? Per nanosecond or what ?
Thank god it will mainly wait for I/O and has enough time to cool itself. /s
- NobodyNada 4y ago> 400 A ? Per nanosecond or what ? Amps are already over time — 1 amp is 1 coulomb (6e18 electrons) per second.
- Scene_Cast2 4y agoI think the parent comment was saying "how long was 400a sustained for".
- danbruc 4y agoThat is what they were asking in the sentence before. They forgot to say for how many microseconds can the chip sustain this speed.
- dboreham 4y agoThat was funny.
- elzbardico 4y agoWhen we talk about current we are usually talking about the rate. So the question is: for how long can the chip sustain this level of current.
- danbruc 4y agoNitpicking. And 400 A ? Per nanosecond or what ? Ampere are already coulomb per second.
- Dagger2 4y agoIt's okay for a unit to have multiple "per second"s in it. A/ns is simply a measure of how fast the current ramps up or down.
- danbruc 4y agoSure, but that's besides the point. The article talks about the peak current, why would you want to talk about the current gradient here? Not that the current gradient can not be important, it will determine how quickly the processor can change the clock frequency, but this seems to just be the same confusion that often happens between energy and power. EDIT: Just out of curiosity I looked up what voltage regulator slew rates for modern processors are, and it seems to be on the order of 100 A/µs, in case someone is interested.
- eightysixfour 4y agoIt isn’t besides the point, it is like saying a car can do 250mph, but can only do it for 1 second before the tires explode. A CPU that can hit 6ghz while pulling 400amps but can only do that for a few milliseconds before throttling itself is not particularly impressive.
- danbruc 4y agoLook at the original comment again, they address this very point. They forgot to say for how many microseconds can the chip sustain this speed. This is exactly what you are saying, they are asking how long can it run at 6 GHz before they have to throttle. Then they continue with the sentence I originally responded to. And 400 A ? Per nanosecond or what ? I see mainly two possibilities. The first one is that they made a typo and what they actually wanted to write is »And 400 A? For one nanosecond or what?« which would essentially be repeating the exact same question as in the sentence before, just in terms of current instead of clock frequency. But this is not what they wrote, they wrote »And 400 A? Per nanosecond or what?« which leads to the second possibility and the one I consider more likely. They were confused about the unit, the equivalent of responding to »The average US citizen consumes 10 kW of power.« with the question »Per day? Per month? Per year? In its lifetime?« which obviously makes no sense. That would be an appropriate response to the statement »The average US citizen consumes 89 MWh of energy.« Without the author telling us, we will never know for sure, but I find it more likely that they were confused about the unit than that they repeated the exact same questions twice and made a typo in the second one that just makes it look like they were confused about the unit.
- helf 4y agomy i9-13900K can sustain 6.4ghz on 4 cores with just a Noctua air cooler for a minute or two before having to throttle down some due to heat.. And that is just a decent air cooler. People have this weird view of modern chips. Yeah, they /can/ use a lot of power and produce a lot of heat.. Under terrible loads most people dont actually hit for any sustained period. even gaming, you arent going to be pegging all 24 cores.
- spicymaki 4y ago400A (amps) is icc_max which is how much current the CPU allowed to pull when working at 100%.