4 ms·
As time went on, and the buildings appreciated in value during a real estate boom -- loans from the mortgage company allowed the owners to "strip mine" the equi
by cperciva 15y ago
As time went on, and the buildings appreciated in value during a real estate boom -- loans from the mortgage company allowed the owners to "strip mine" the equity from the buildings. This is a common slumlord modus operandi -- they suck money out of a building rather than put money back in for maintenance.
Strip mining the equity? It's their building, isn't it? Seems to me that if someone wants to own a pile of cash and a worthless building instead of owning a well-maintained building, that's a business decision they should be entitled to make.
- mikeash 15y agoI suppose it depends on whether you think the person "strip mining" the building should be allowed to expose the building's tenants to raw sewage and high levels of lead, and not pay their utility bills.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoPeople are entitled to make that decision, but they are not entitled to also rent out an "uninhabitable" building while doing so (or to avoid paying utilities). The slum lords here juggled ownership between different LLCs in order to avoid that little problem.
- ams6110 15y agoWhy would the tenants continue to live there? Most cities have landlord/tenant regulations that tilt towards (if not strongly favor) the tenants. I would have just moved out.
- __david__ 15y agoBecause the properties are probably the cheapest around meaning that the people who live there would have to move up, not sideways. Not everyone can afford that.
- InclinedPlane 15y ago"Most cities have landlord/tenant regulations that tilt towards (if not strongly favor) the tenants." Maybe you missed the part where the landlords were blatantly in violation of those regulations. Also, the tenants continued to live there largely because they didn't have many options. For most of these people the only option otherwise available to them would likely be a homeless shelter.
- SilasX 15y agoOr living in a less expensive area where people aren't trampling over each other to bid for such valuable real estate. I understand the sympathy for the poor, but that sympathy should not extend to giving them inefficient subsidies through rent control of high-value real estate. There are good ways to help the poor; letting them crowd out better uses of critical real estate that a thousand other people would thankful to live in at ten times the rent ... isn't one of them. (If you're wondering what rent control has to do with this, it's the reason that slumlords have to resort to such elaborate tactics to clear out a building for redevelopment in the first place.)
- anigbrowl 15y agoI'm also against rent control from an economic standpoint, but poisoning your tenants is not the right way to protest the issue. A fifth amendment suit about rent control as an indirect taking (and pursuit of appropriate compensation) would be a better approach.
- anigbrowl 15y agoBecause they are poor and stupid. I don't mean that as a pejorative: they don't have many resources to expend on pursuing their rights against the landlord, which can take time, and if they're being continually exposed to lead (eg via water pipes or ventilation), they're likely suffering from chronic low-level brain damage, especially those who have been occupants of the building since childhood. That's what makes the landlords' behavior so objectionable; the property they are renting out is not merely unpleasant, but dangerous to both the physical and mental health of the inhabitants, at least some of whom are more likely to end up participating in crime - at further danger to themselves, and to the community at large.
- barrkel 15y agoBuildings are not owned in isolation. It affects the whole community, potentially the whole neighbourhood.
- brudgers 15y agoBuildings with sewage leaks, inadequate electrical systems, and vermin infestations are a public health hazard, e.g. fires from electrical malfunctions. Thus, it may be argued that local governments have a legitimate interest in setting minimum property standards. Typically, owners are given the opportunity to correct violations and fined if they do not. As fines accumulate, governments will often work with prospective purchasers in order to make transfer of the building's ownership economically viable and provide relief to owners who are unable or unwilling to comply with minimum property standards established by law. Keep in mind that these buildings are inhabited -- the tenants of these buildings are citizens. The city government represents their interests - in the US property ceased being the basis for citizenship a number of years ago - and that other citizens are also paying for fire protection and other services which must be rendered by the jurisdiction.
- cperciva 15y agoBuildings with sewage leaks, inadequate electrical systems, and vermin infestations are a public health hazard, e.g. fires from electrical malfunctions. Right, and that's why (most) cities have building codes. Typically, owners are given the opportunity to correct violations and fined if they do not. As fines accumulate, governments will often work with prospective purchasers in order to make transfer of the building's ownership economically viable and provide relief to owners who are unable or unwilling to comply with minimum property standards established by law. It seems to me that the fundamental problem here is that landlords can dodge fines by selling a building. If the tenants of sub-code buildings received a statutory reduction in rent until the building is back to code requirements, there would be no incentive for landlords to operate sub-code buildings. The issue of imposing externalities on tenants is, however, entirely orthogonal to the issue of building equity which I was responding to.
- Vivtek 15y agoRight, and that's why (most) cities have building codes. Right, and that's why it's only profitable to strip mine for equity if you engage in fraud to avoid the building codes.