3 ms·
HN headline does not reflect the actual headline ("Why did teenage suicides decline during America’s first covid-19 lockdowns?") It also makes a claim that the
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
HN headline does not reflect the actual headline ("Why did teenage suicides decline during America’s first covid-19 lockdowns?")
It also makes a claim that the article wisely doesn't make. Compare the OP:
> The paper concludes that in-person bullying is the likeliest explanation for the rise in suicides when schools reopened.
No suggestion that any evidence was used in making that conclusion. The finding is that suicide rates dropped due to school closure.
- MobileVet 4y agoTo this point, my buddy is a 20 year teacher. He says that the difference between bullying today and 30 years ago when we were in school is that then it stopped at 3 when we went home. Social media provides the ability for bullying to continue 24/7 and it does. It is a huge problem as text and posts go on and on late into the night. Being always on and connected is a scourge for youth trying to find themselves in a historically and biologically tough time.
- headsoup 4y agoThis would not support that suicides dropped though would it? Kids would be online more and likely face bullying continuation. Not that I disagree with it generally being a horrible scourge on childhood experience.
- everdrive 4y agoIf this is the case, wouldn't cyberbullying have increased during the pandemic since kids would have been on devices more often?
- mgkimsal 4y agoIf there’s no IRL activities to bully about, the bullies’ attention is likely drawn to other things more quickly.
- headsoup 4y agoI assume no consideration appears to be made for "children spend more time with family" and so gain the health benefits of such a thing. Modern society is way to busy downplaying the importance of foundationally secure emotional connections. Busy instead pushing 'independence' and outsourcing of childrens' time and affection for the sake of income.
- jevgeni 4y ago> No suggestion that any evidence was used in making that conclusion. You'll find the suggested evidence at the end of the article.