3 ms·
It's a simplified POV for generic people's cognitive toolkits. If they can internalize this idea, then you can move on to trying them on the caveats and details
by jerf 15y ago
It's a simplified POV for generic people's cognitive toolkits. If they can internalize this idea, then you can move on to trying them on the caveats and details and levels of falseness and etc etc etc. But way too often, the existence of caveats and details is used as an excuse to simply discard the undesirable theory, or to claim that theory A has caveats (example: "Newtonian physics isn't quite right") and theory B has caveats (example: epicycles), so why not just go with theory B?
You're not wrong, but the more sophisticated approach you're suggesting is also more dangerous in its own way.