3 ms·
He's missing dividends. The average S&P 500 dividend yield is 1.37% according to something I just found on Motley Fool. If that's accurate, that's pretty substa
by mattmaroon 18y ago
He's missing dividends. The average S&P 500 dividend yield is 1.37% according to something I just found on Motley Fool. If that's accurate, that's pretty substantial.
Too bad they didn't have SPDRs in 1950, he could have been much more accurate with the same amount of effort.
- tomsaffell 18y agoThe analysis has now been updated to include dividends, and posted on my blog: http://saffell.wordpress.com/2008/10/26/does-timing-the-market-work/ http://saffell.wordpress.com/2008/10/26/does-timing-the-mark...
- eru 18y agohttp://www.crossingwallstreet.com/archives/2006/03/sp_500_total_re.html http://www.crossingwallstreet.com/archives/2006/03/sp_500_to... has a chart of the total return. Or you can make your own at http://www.economagic.com/em-cgi/charter.exe/fedstl/trsp500 http://www.economagic.com/em-cgi/charter.exe/fedstl/trsp500 By the way more modern indices like the German DAX are already performance ones.
- mattmaroon 18y agoRight, I just meant it would have been nice to see that incorporated into the variance.
- tomsaffell 18y agoGood point. I would like to analyze returns assuming re-invested dividends (TSR), which I will try to do in my next analysis. However, as I search around the web I'm having trouble finding enough data (SPDRs only go back to '93, and even the economagic data only starts in 1970, which isn't really enough data to meaningfully look at 'average' 30 year investments) Does anyone have access to data going further back? I will continue looking myself, maybe also looking at DJI data. In the spirit of hypothesis lead analysis, perhaps we (or I) should lay out hypotheses for how the TSR analysis will differ (Total Shareholder Return). Clearly the curves will be shifted to the right, probably by the ~1.37% that Matt mentions. But what about the variance? (which is more interesting IMO). I need to think about that..
- bokonist 18y agoHere is a dataset that includes the value of the S&P and dividends, going back to the 1800's. http://www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/data.htm http://www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/data.htm The dividend yield used to be much higher, the long term average is 4-5%. The current yield of 2% is pitiful. Dividends are really how you make money investing in stocks, the price appreciation is really just a proxy for money supply growth, see http://www.cashflowanalytics.com/news.php?articleID=172 http://www.cashflowanalytics.com/news.php?articleID=172. You can get that same kind of appreciation investing in gold, art, 1950's baseball cards - anything that people value and find hard to dilute. I've wondered if the appreciation of the S&P index takes into account the constant reweighting that needs to be done. For instance, there's a lag as the company falls out of the index and when a mutual fund can actually sell it. I've also wondered if it takes into account the dilution rate of stocks, which traditionally has been around 2% a year.
- tomsaffell 18y agoExcellent - thanks for the link. I'll redo the analysis with the new data.