8 ms·
The US now has nearly a century of union activity. Over that almost-century, labourers have been completely rolled by people who own capital, who have become fa
by roenxi 4y ago
The US now has nearly a century of union activity. Over that almost-century, labourers have been completely rolled by people who own capital, who have become fabulously wealthy.
I don't think the unionists have assessed the situation correctly. A strategy of co-ops and legal structures to let workers take on more economic risk (like what shares allow) would have gotten much better long term results.
A union is basically a 2 step plan - first, identify the person willing to pay you the most. Second, pick a fight with them. This might be a locally OK strategy, but it isn't workable in the long term.
- hgomersall 4y agoExcept that unions typically form the other way round: workers feeling aggrieved by their employers unionize to apply leverage to improve things. You're probably right that the lot of workers as a whole could be done better, but for an individual that's irrelevant.
- WalterBright 4y agoUnions always treat their employers as adversaries. This does not make for a win-win relationship.
- LightHugger 4y agoEmployers often treat their employees as adversaries. Thus the need for unions in those situations... You appear to be placing blame for the situation on the party with less power in the situation, the employee, rather than the one with more power, the employer. this is a bit silly!
- WalterBright 4y agoConsider the union negotiating tactics. They don't negotiate, they demand. They carry signs and verbally attack the company. They threaten. They offer nothing in return. It's entirely framed as win-lose by the union. How do they expect the company to want to deal with them? Consider how businesses negotiate. Each side offers something in return for better terms. They come to a mutually agreeable win-win solution. That's what I do when I've negotiated with employers. I frame it as a friendly win-win negotiation, and both parties go away pleased with the result.
- LightHugger 4y agoUh, have you just not noticed employer tactics? They don't care about it being win-win. You clearly have extreme anti-union bias to the point you havent noticed how incredibly employee hostile the companies that unions form around are, to an absurd extent. It's gone so far that the magnitude of a win for the employer is so much higher than for the employee that the goal posts have shifted to absurdity. You're still putting the onus for improving the situation on the party with far, far less power. Which makes no sense.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhen I see a union offering win-win solutions, I will change my mind. I am not anti-union. I am anti the tactics they use. Unions are part of the free market. A union is a business that sells labor.
- atoav 4y agoAnd companies are businesses that exploit labor to make profits. One creates value for many people, the other for few. The ethics on this one is not hard.
- WalterBright 4y agoUnder capitalism, man exploits man. Under socialism, it's the other way around.
- thuridas 4y agoIt doesn't need to be like this. There can be collaboration to find the best solution for all parties. They can become a communication channel for problems including security issues. And here is Amazon the one that is treating their employees both bad and as adversaries
- WalterBright 4y agoI don't know any specifics about that case. But in Seattle, the Starbucks employees went on strike to form a union, and they went into the street with signs saying how bad Starbucks was, and how they could afford to pay them more, lots of shouting and hate. Who wants to partner with people who do that?
- fullsend 4y agoIt’s just as easy to tell a story about how the employees tried to be decent, were ignored or silenced, and had to speak out more aggressively. Your view is clearly biased and it’s a take as old as time - if that darn Dr. King didn’t block the streets, he’d get better results. Just calm down and have a chat, says the already wealthy and happy worker.
- WalterBright 4y agoMy story was as reported in the Seattle Times, which is consistently pro-union. Besides, even the wealthy like to make money. The employees show them how to make more, they'll listen. If the employer won't listen, the usual thing to do is quit, start their own business, and outcompete them. There are lots of small business coffeeshops. They aren't terribly hard to get going.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fullsend 4y agoTalk about cherry picking. The first article I see is a plain report.
- danielheath 4y agoThat's a common talking point, and I have no doubt it matches what you've seen, but as a counterpoint to "always" - I've only seen unions deal with management twice, and both times it was productive and mutually respectful. Negotiations like "The industry has moved and we are going to be out of business if we don't cut costs" lead to unions asking for concessions like voluntary redundancies (before involuntary ones to make up the difference) and on-site cross-training. In return, the employers got buy-in from staff, which meant smoother knowledge transfer from departing employees.
- WalterBright 4y agoThank you, that is a good example of the right way to do things. Normally what I see, and what is abundantly clear in this thread, is unions are going for win-lose deals.
- danielheath 4y agoSo, the other thing to bear in mind is that in a jurisdiction like the USA a union can’t meaningfully exist without a threat, because there needs to be something they can offer before a negotiation makes sense. Where I live, the government sets quite a few conditions on employment, but many of them can be bargained away by a union, meaning there’s meaningful incentive to negotiating with one.
- atoav 4y agoEmployers tend to view their employees at adversaries first. Nobody wastes time with an union if their employer aims to treat them in a way that both sides win. You unionize, when your employer fucks you over once too much. Employers typically do all of that to extract more value than is rightfully theirs from their employers or to make their own lives easier at the expense of their employers (e.g. by ignoring safety regulations). So unions naturally form when employers go to far. A clever employer who is after an actual win-win situation might anticipate this and skip the entire thing by providing actual countermeasures against the tendency to fuck over ones employess themselves.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Employers tend to view their employees at adversaries first. Then take the high road first. > e.g. by ignoring safety regulations If employers do that, then the employees need to report them to the regulators. Don't need a union for that.
- atoav 4y ago> If employers do that, then the employees need to report them to the regulators. Don't need a union for that. Good luck on thst. The regulator is in the same country club as your boss. On top of that most of the worker rights and safety rules that regulator is meant to check came to be because unions fought for them. Read on the history of these rights and regulations in the dawn of worker movements. This is not some new unknown topic, but something people have fought for over centuries. The incentives of the regulators and governing bodies will rarely align with workers rights, hence the need for those people to organize for their own good. Don't get me wrong here I do not suggest that employers are always evil and unions always good, this is not what history shows. Far from it. Yet historically whenever workers lives improved, there is a big chance unions were involved as a driving force. I'd love to see a world where companies would treat their employees in such a way, unions don't need to exist. But that is not how companies operate in most cases.
- WalterBright 4y ago
- newswasboring 4y agoA win win relationship can only occur when both parties start from the same position. When one party is starting from not even having basics in their favor (pay, working hours etc.) the other side has to give a lot more. You cannot start with all the bananas and then declare all new bananas will be split evenly as a win win.
- WalterBright 4y ago> A win win relationship can only occur when both parties start from the same position. I'm so sad hearing people believe this. Your power is the value you provide. That is worth money. Negotiating is a matter of convincing the other party that you will provide more value.
- newswasboring 4y agoI am going to be incredibly rude now. This comment is so out of touch with reality I wonder if I'm falling for a troll. I am probably in the same boat as you. I've negotiated my contract with biggest monopolies in my industry. That was done despite the existence of a thankfully good union. Unions only negotiated for basic stuff, pay, hours, healthcare etc. Perks were negotiated by me. But if you think for a second we are in the same boat as a Starbucks barista or Amazon warehouse worker, I'm sorry but you need to sit down with some of these people and hear their stories. If money is your language, then think of it like this, it takes close to hundred thousand euros to replace me while it takes orders or magnitude less to replace labor in a warehouse. Or maybe think about how if a store closes down it doesn't put that much of a dent in Starbucks' 7billion dollar bottom line, but workers can lose homes and sometimes healthcare. In what universe is this an equal position to start from? They are arguing over most basic things like pee breaks man, do you really think management is arguing in good faith if this is a talking point? I know I'm not going to change your mind on an internet forum, but you probably have this issue (also just like me) where it's hard to imagine other people's life situations. That's why I talk with people before judging their movement. Posting a marketing link to show what Starbucks advertises as perks (doesn't even address the low pay) is at best a bad argument and at worst deliberately insulting to a lot of people.
- pvg 4y agoI don't think that's an accurate description of the history of the labour movement in the US. For one thing, it's been around for quite a bit longer than 'nearly a century'. Over that almost-century, labourers have been completely rolled by people who own capital 8 hour work day, not child labour, worker safety, etc, etc, etc A union is basically a 2 step plan - first, identify the person willing to pay you the most. Second, pick a fight with them. This might be a locally OK strategy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Hoffa#National_Master_Freight_Agreement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Hoffa#National_Master_Fr...
- roenxi 4y ago> 8 hour work day, not child labour, worker safety, etc, etc, etc 1. That is a list of issues that have legal complications. That goes to my core point - organising to effect political change is far more effective than the typical union. All the workers on Straten Island would be just as politically effective whether they have union representation on their day job or not. 2. I'm not sure what you are trying to say with the Hoffa article, but note that the union is called the teamster union. The obsolescence of draft animals and, by extension, the end of teamstering as a profession did more for their working conditions than the union did. 3. That list is made up of pretty pathetic achievements vs what the capitalists have managed. Wealthy capitalists have doubled and doubled their wealth in the same time. I'd work 10 hours a day in exchange for that sort of money. And the capitalists don't need to take risks they are uncomfortable with because they own the business. Not sure about the child labour thing. The unions won what they asked for, and it turned out what they were asking for wasn't very clever. They should have been asking for ways to build an ownership stake in businesses, taking some of the risk and reaping some of the reward.
- pvg 4y ago1. That is a list of issues that have legal complications. [...] organising to effect political What does that mean? Labor unions have always been political organizations. I feel like it's my core point that's being confirmed here - your description of labor movement history is pretty much wrong making the basis of your argument wrong. You didn't even address the national agreement I linked, a specific policy goal of one of the most influential US unions. It flatly contradicts your narrative about 'local changes'. It also happened 60 years ago.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]