3 ms·
I think the intention matters. If you did it to spite the guy behind you then you are at fault. If you did it because you thought something might cross the road
by scotty79 4y ago
I think the intention matters. If you did it to spite the guy behind you then you are at fault. If you did it because you thought something might cross the road and just wanted to be safe then it's not your fault even if nothing crossed the road or nothing was really there.
- abduhl 4y agoTesla’s FSD/autopilot does not act with intention as we understand it.
- scotty79 4y agoNo intention, no fault. But definitely unsafe lane change, I think.
- abduhl 4y agoHow convenient for Tesla. I doubt we would think this way if your wheel flew off your civic because of a design flaw in the axle.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- noobermin 4y agoWhy is this being downvoted? Intent isn't everything. While it is important, design flaws are worth getting the book thrown at you over.
- klyrs 4y agoThat's because we'd fully expect them to recall the effected models and fix the design flaw. Since Tesla knows about erratic lane-changes and phantom braking, and has for years, why haven't they recalled the vehicles and fixed the design flaw or at least disabled the feature?
- Faark 4y agoI agree with your original example ("good reason => OK", "bad reason => BAD"). But for the in-between we should default to "not OK" as well, since stopping on a highway is just dangerous. But damn, I really have little sympathy for all the inattentive drivers not being able to stop in time for the pileup (and hope damages have to be payed accordingly). Maybe, Tesla FSD does not make the streets more dangerous than they already are, after all.
- masklinn 4y ago> No intention, no fault. Nonsense.
- scotty79 4y agoImagine it is a human driver saying that shadows on the road made him believe there was a person there so he slowed down to make sure. He wouldn't be at fault for slowing down (after checking his eyesight). Lane change is what makes Tesla at fault here, not unreasonable slowing down.
- smileysteve 4y agoor lack of intention. If an engine throws a rod, if a driveshaft pole vaults, if a wheel falls off, or a suspension component catastrophically fails. These are all realistic sudden stop issues that our laws mostly accommodate.
- userbinator 4y agoNo, those are not "sudden stop" situations either. In fact the worst thing to do is to stop suddenly. Even if a wheel falls off, you do not slam on the brakes unless you want to lose even more control.
- smileysteve 4y agoIf a wheel falls off, the driver doesn't have to apply the brakes... A quarter of the car is digging in and melding itself to the asphalt. If the differential fails catastrophically, it applies more braking force than the brakes do, so you'll have brief period of being airborne and then at least 1 rear wheel will sheer off (seen it). If the driveshaft or trailing arms fail the wrong way, they result in a steel shaft digging into the roadway at a downward angle in front of the wheels and the driveshaft will stop the differential as above, until it sheers off.
- jjav 4y ago> If a wheel falls off, the driver doesn't have to apply the brakes... A quarter of the car is digging in and melding itself to the asphalt. That's not necessarily true. I've been in a car where the rear wheel parted ways with the car and passed us. For a few seconds we wondered where that wheel came from until realizing it was from our car. The car was balanced just fine on three wheels, there was plenty time to lift off the gas and make way to the breakdown lane safely. Even if it's a more heavily loaded wheel (e.g. front wheel on front engine front wheel drive car), it'll slide on the brake disc or the disk cover (whichever is lower, varies by car). A good amount of sparking but you'll have enough steerage to pull over.