2 ms·
Offsetting demand natural gas demand in June also lets you stockpile that natural gas. The EU produces a great deal of natural gas and can store it just fine,
by Retric 4y ago
Offsetting demand natural gas demand in June also lets you stockpile that natural gas. The EU produces a great deal of natural gas and can store it just fine, they simply needed to make up a deficit.
- loeg 4y agoThat would not have helped for this winter.
- Retric 4y agoNatural gas in a tank is just as useful if it’s there because it was imported or stockpiled.
- loeg 4y agoYou misunderstand. For it to be useful this winter, additional solar would have needed to have been deployed at the beginning of summer. Your timeline is: Russia invades February 24. Your most effective solar window is April-October. The solar would have needed to be built in 1-2 months to offset summer gas use.
- Retric 4y agoIt’s more effective to bring solar online sooner because it’s providing power every month after being installed thus providing a longer window to stockpile natural gas. However, while output is lower in December it’s still useful for December, January, and February and then continues to provide power into the future. The EU is very much still concerned about having enough natural gas for next winter.
- tialaramex 4y agoAs an example the UK "stockpile" of gas is notionally 9 TWh although in practice you definitely shouldn't treat that whole volume as slack because if it ever runs out everything is fucked. The UK uses typically maybe 700 GWh per day of electricity. So the stockpile you're talking about is less than two weeks of electricity you've "offset" from the summer. OK, and now what do we do for the remaining months of winter ?
- Retric 4y agoUK doesn’t supply 100% of electricity from natural gas only 38.5% and they continue to produce natural gas in the winter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_the_Unit... Let’s suppose the deficit is 40% of natural gas which represents a daily deficit of ~40% * 0.385 = 15.4% of electricity generation. So that 9 TWh represents 9,000 / 700 / 0.385 / 0.4 = ~83 days which is already quite close to spring without any additional imports. But, I am also suggesting bringing more power generation online which further decrease the gap. PS: Even just 3% of total daily electricity being covered by new generation that ~83 days to ~104 days, again before considering any extra imports.
- tialaramex 4y agoThe 38.5% figure you're using is a mean over the course of a year so you're double counting, and the 40% you've chosen to discount by is an arbitrary fiction, the question is about the value of a "stockpile" and so arbitrarily assuming we can just buy more gas as we please to fill some of it back up begs the question.
- Retric 4y agoPoint to a specific calculation where 38.5% double counting. That 40% was a ridiculous over the top doomsday estimate as the UK procedures a lot of natural gas and only ~7% of their imports came from Russia in 2021. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1324377/uk-natural-gas-imports-by-origin-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1324377/uk-natural-gas-i... The only reason to use 40% is to simulate the EU is reducing global supply and it’s impact wasn’t even close to that severe. As to just buying more natural gas, that’s what actually happened so I don’t need to assume anything. The entire EU was able to successfully replace all Russian natural gas from the global market.
- tialaramex 4y ago> Point to a specific calculation where 38.5% double counting. The calculation you did. It uses this figure, but the figure itself is already accounted for in what you were trying to model, that is what double counting is. The annual 38.5% includes both very windy days, and very sunny days, in which consequently PV input and wind power input were very high, as well as the dark and cold but still days in which neither produces very much power. But the problem scenario we care about is long dark cold days of winter. You can't use a figure which averages in a bright but gusty June morning and use that as representative of a miserable January, you need to look at what it's like on such days, and it's much higher than 38.5%. Remember, your original thesis is that somehow not using gas in June will save you needing gas in January and I've shown why that's nonsense, the "stockpile" involved is just far too small for this to make any sense. For what you wanted to do to actually make sense the UK would need to buy at least ten times as much storage as it has now, ie enough to last out a nasty winter. But it shows no sign of wanting to do that, if anything exactly the opposite, preferring to "leave it to the market" and then acting confused when the market does what you'd expect, ie gouge them for every penny it can.