4 ms·
The EU really focused on importing rather than conserving natural gas. A huge solar/wind install which significantly reduced the need for natural gas turbines
by Retric 4y ago
The EU really focused on importing rather than conserving natural gas.
A huge solar/wind install which significantly reduced the need for natural gas turbines over the year doing as much to fill tanks as their new LNG terminal while providing more long term utility. Instead by focusing on being able to import and store vs conserve and store they further spiked prices.
I am not saying they wanted to maximize misery for political reasons or profits for the energy sector. However, I can’t help but feel they mismanaged this even though the worst predictions like rationing or 10x price increases never happened.
Perhaps I should give them more credit and say their plan actually worked reasonably well even if it’s benefitted from unusual weather. Winter is far from over and they are already in the clear.
- kzrdude 4y agoWhat kind of solar install could have been finished by now?
- Retric 4y agoI don’t really know, my point was really more about them seemingly putting all their eggs in one basket even though the total drop in natural gas as a percentage of energy generation supply wasn’t that big. A rough ballpark to see if it could have been meaningful, they had most of the year and annual production is something like ~200GW of solar panels vs average electricity production in the EU is ~300 GW. I have no idea how much could have been fast tracked but moving the needle quite far seems possible. But again I am not an expert and their plan seems to have worked.
- kzrdude 4y agoDiversifying it is a good point. While gas was maybe the focus for this winter, of course it would be good to start the solar initiative at the same time so that it can be ready for some future year.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoAnd what kind of yield would you get in December - February when you really need to heat the houses? Europe is much higher north than many assume
- Retric 4y agoOffsetting demand natural gas demand in June also lets you stockpile that natural gas. The EU produces a great deal of natural gas and can store it just fine, they simply needed to make up a deficit.
- loeg 4y agoThat would not have helped for this winter.
- Retric 4y agoNatural gas in a tank is just as useful if it’s there because it was imported or stockpiled.
- loeg 4y agoYou misunderstand. For it to be useful this winter, additional solar would have needed to have been deployed at the beginning of summer. Your timeline is: Russia invades February 24. Your most effective solar window is April-October. The solar would have needed to be built in 1-2 months to offset summer gas use.
- Retric 4y agoIt’s more effective to bring solar online sooner because it’s providing power every month after being installed thus providing a longer window to stockpile natural gas. However, while output is lower in December it’s still useful for December, January, and February and then continues to provide power into the future. The EU is very much still concerned about having enough natural gas for next winter.
- MandieD 4y agoLots of 5-10 acre-looking parks along the Autobahns outside of cities, financed by various regional power companies and run by specialized solar operators, often outside their home regions (example: an EnBW park run by a company based near Stuttgart, located next to a rest stop in Thüringen)
- throwawaysleep 4y agoI imagine the lead time on even a 3x increase in solar panel production would be well over a year. They had 6-8 months to solve this problem. Enough natural gas exists in the world outside of Russia to power Europe. Is that true of solar panels?
- Galaxeblaffer 4y agoalso it's winter and much of Europe is pretty far north, so short days and allot of clouds with rain and maybe some snow.
- Retric 4y agoEurope produces natural gas, the need is to offset an import deficit not completely replace all electricity and home heating across the EU. For scale average electricity profusion in the EU is 300GW, vs 200 GW of worldwide solar panel production. So, it could have clearly moved the needle.
- JustLurking2022 4y agoEven if they could somehow magically install gigawatts of solar power, all those furnaces in people's homes still run on natural gas.
- midoridensha 4y agoThat's the fundamental problem: heating in Europe generally requires gas, because that's how the infrastructure was designed. They should be pushing for conversions to electric heat pumps, to avoid this kind of thing in the future: electric can run on any power source, whether it's fossil fuel or solar or nuclear.
- axelthegerman 4y agoHeat pumps are not efficient at all for large temperature deltas. Electric is general bad for heating (efficiency wise) unless we literally manage to generate tons of it for very cheap (e.g. fusion).
- tialaramex 4y agoBig chunks of Europe don't get cold enough for the delta to be unacceptable. A 20K delta (so e.g. you want it to be 20° C inside, but the outside air temperature is 0° C) is still well inside the range where the heat pump has > 100% efficiency. When it's really cold, which even in Northern Europe is only a few days per year, air source heat pumps would be < 100% efficient and you'd step to resistive heating, but it's weird to optimise for a worst case scenario. And ground source heat pumps are a thing, unlike the air the ground has a relatively stable temperature we can leverage to stabilise home temperatures.
- midoridensha 4y agoGround-source heat pumps fix that problem I believe. Of course, drilling a hole is extra work and expense. For multi-unit housing, it should be a lot more economical since you could drill one hole for coolant circulation and share that among all the units.
- deleted 4y ago
- zihotki 4y agoSolar electricity supply is not elastic and obviously doest't work at night. And installation won't happen overnight as well as production. So stocking gas was the only viable short term option
- Retric 4y agoSure but it’s been 11 months, assuming the concern was this winter that’s quite a bit of time to do something.
- kergonath 4y ago11 months is no time at all for any kind of large-ish project. And small-scale projects are getting harder due to the economic situation as well. You just cannot do much of anything in 11 months.
- Retric 4y agoAssuming you don’t treat it as an emergency 11 months isn’t that long. But, look at how quickly and how many COVID vaccines where created and entered mass production. Or how quickly Germany got their new LNG terminal online from scratch. We normally take forever to build a bridge, but 15 days after a hurricane Florida got large temporary bridge ready for traffic. https://practical.engineering/blog/2022/12/15/how-this-bridge-was-rebuilt-in-15-days-after-hurricane-ian https://practical.engineering/blog/2022/12/15/how-this-bridg... That’s the kind of response that gets stings done. So, 11 months is a long time when people actually decide acting right now is important.
- hem777 4y agoIt does work at night, for about 4-6 months if you’re far enough North.
- TheRealPomax 4y agoHave... have you lived here? Solar makes zero sense in most of Europe: most of the year it would barely trickle charge the grid. Yeah, it'd work brilliantly at small scale for a few months every year, but grid storage is measured in "at most a few days", no technology exists that would make solar even remotely sensible in most of Europe. And no, "building it where it's sunny, then sending it on" would be nowhere near enough to cover the rest of Europe. People did consider that. Then they actually ran the numbers. Then they went "oh... okay that's never going to work".
- Retric 4y agoNo one solution needed to be be total. It’s been 11 months and the concern has already shifted to next winter that’s a long time for wind/solar to be reducing demand for natural gas turbines. Burning less gas in July let’s you have that gas to burn in January assuming you have storage capacity. My point is the plan seems to be “let’s just import it whatever the cost” rather than saying what can we do to minimize the need while also increasing imports.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Burning less gas in July let’s you have that gas to burn in January assuming you have storage capacity. Britain has bulldozed all of ita gas storage, we are all neoliberal just-in-time supply chains believe in the market. If the rest of the world stops supplying Britain with energy snd food there will be frostbite and famine in 1 week Ge5ting planning approval for a wind turbine takes 5 years. During the energy crisis, conservative government has moved to make solar illegal on agricutural land
- magnuspaaske 4y agoSolar is being rolled out like crazy and the main constraint is not the available sunlight but rather getting a connection to the grid. In fact if you look at where there's the most solar power in Europe, it's north western Europe (Benelux + Germany) even though one might expect it would produce more in Southern Europe
- jiggawatts 4y agoThere are many renewable energy projects already going on, including large solar power stations in the Sahara desert that feed into the EU grid via submarine cables. E.g.: https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/solar-energy-egypt-europe-sahara-b2199482.html https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/solar-energy-egypt-europe...
- Retric 4y agoThe point is 2022 installs have been business as usual rather than in response to spiking energy prices. This crisis was predicted 11 months ago with the invasion and they are already forecasting issues next winter that’s a long time fast track stuff.
- jiggawatts 4y agoSolar installations are limited by production capacity of the panels. There may be no significant options available for fast tracking. Germany did complete some energy projects in record time, such as the construction of a new LNG facility to enable more gas imports by ship.
- Retric 4y agoGlobal production capacity is on the order of 200 GW, that dwarfs the deficit from reduced natural gas imports from Russia. And that LNG facility was my point, that’s far less useful once Russia’s pipelines open up again. It’s a massive investment with limited long term gain on top of also paying higher natural gas prices.
- r00fus 4y agoThere is the possibility that Russian gas lines never open up (in the near future). Ukraine war is likely going to turn out to be a massive political realignment.
- kergonath 4y ago> And that LNG facility was my point, that’s far less useful once Russia’s pipelines open up again. It’s a massive investment with limited long term gain on top of also paying higher natural gas prices. It is strategic. Sometimes you do need to pay more to keep some options open and diversify your sources. The last year has shown how foolish it would be to get back in bed with Russia. Buying their gas is fine, getting dependent on it is not.
- Animats 4y agoA liquid natural gas port was fast-tracked. It worked.
- sandos 4y agoInstalling wind that fast is "impossible". Remember that Europe needs to import stuff, and most things are in scarce supply at the moment. Thats not even mentioning lack of workforce, competence and permitting! It is happening, but it takes 5 years to get going and 10 years to see the results.