11 ms·
The energy crisis and Europe’s astonishing luck
- jmyeet 4y agoWe shouldn't forget that this whole energy crisis was the result of bad EU policy. Even though Putin's unjustified invasion of Ukraine was the spark that set the fire, EU's dependence on Russian natural gas was foreseeable and foreseen and warned about for years prior [1]: > U.S. President Donald Trump launched a sharp public attack on Germany on Wednesday for supporting a Baltic Sea gas pipeline deal with Russia, saying Berlin had become “a captive to Russia” and he criticized it for failing to raise defense spending more. But it didn't start there [2]: > U.S. President Barack Obama told the European Union on Wednesday it cannot rely on the United States alone to reduce its dependency on Russian energy, as relations with Moscow chill over its seizure of Crimea from Ukraine. The US foresaw and planned for the rise in demand for LNG, something Europe did not do [3]: > The last time the United States was a net exporter of natural gas was in 1957, when Dwight Eisenhower was president. That should change in 2018 when the country is expected to become the world’s third-largest exporter of liquefied natural gas (LNG). It went so far as Germany building an LNG terminal to mollify the US [4]: > Germany will chose where to build a liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminal by the end of 2018 as a gesture to the United States which wants to ship more gas to Europe, the economy minister said on Tuesday. And now Europe complains about the price they have to pay for LNG [5]. Don't lose sight of the fact that the entire European energy crisis is the result of poor strategic planning, avoidable dependence on Russian energy and poor policy. I'm glad there's been a heat wave to alleviate winter-related heat issues. The UK, for example, has "warm hubs" [6] for people who literally cannot afford to heat their home. Remember too that passing on those high energy costs to customers is also a policy choice by the various governments. [1]:https://www.reuters.com/article/us-nato-summit-pipeline/trump-lashes-germany-over-gas-pipeline-deal-calls-it-russias-captive-idUSKBN1K10VI https://www.reuters.com/article/us-nato-summit-pipeline/trum... [2]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-eu-summit/obama-tells-eu-to-do-more-to-cut-reliance-on-russian-gas-idUSBREA2P0W220140326 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-eu-summit/obama-tells... [3]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-natgas-lng-analysis/after-six-decades-u-s-set-to-turn-natgas-exporter-amid-lng-boom-idUSKBN1700F1 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-natgas-lng-analysis/a... [4]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-energy-usa-russia/germany-to-build-lng-plant-in-gesture-to-u-s-drive-to-sell-more-idUSKCN1LY25H https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-energy-usa-russia/germ... [5]: https://www.politico.eu/article/cheap-us-gas-cost-fortune-europe-russia-ukraine-energy/ https://www.politico.eu/article/cheap-us-gas-cost-fortune-eu... [6]: https://www.wrccrural.org.uk/services/wrcc-warm-hubs/what-are-warm-hubs/ https://www.wrccrural.org.uk/services/wrcc-warm-hubs/what-ar...
- switch007 4y agoHear hear! In this 1984 world: the NHS crisis is due to COVID, the energy crisis is due to the war in Ukraine. The UK has a scapegoat for almost every crisis. We’re very good at that.
- int_19h 4y agoNever mind US; Russia has been openly using gas supply as a geopolitical pressure tool - at first, against Ukraine - since 2005. And opposition / anti-war folk in Russia have been talking about the insanity that is the European energy policy and its Russia dependence and its likely long-term consequences since at least 2008, after the war with Georgia (some were at it even longer, since Nord Stream became a thing). There were ample warnings all around for those willing to listen.
- bandyaboot 4y agohttps://archive.ph/FaZYK https://archive.ph/FaZYK
- tboyd47 4y agoThe mercy of God.
- bandyaboot 4y agoOr wrath depending on whose perspective you’re looking at it from.
- edgyquant 4y agoIndeed. 2022 was the year we realized God doesn’t like authoritarians. All the talk of an American decline and yet in a single year all (except NK) of the major world authoritarian regimes have been facing real crisis. In the west our crisis seem to be overhyped both by the news and said authoritarian regimes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- midoridensha 4y agoThe crisis is real, and the western democracies are very poorly (and frequently corruptly) run. The western powers have been doing a great job of shooting themselves in the foot. However, it seems the authoritarians are even more incompetent and/or corrupt than the corrupt Western powers. Imagine what kind of society humanity could have if people didn't constantly allow incompetent and corrupt leaders to take over.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoThe curse of dictators. The longer you stay in power, the more detached from reality you become because everyone treats you like a god
- ClumsyPilot 4y agobillionaires as well. look at an interview woth a famount billionair when they jusy made their wealth, and 10 years later. The dofference is plain to see. Oower gets to your head. Human psycology is notndesigned to cope with like a million people qued up to kiss ass and suck your dick
- BMc2020 4y ago"National leaders must make the most of the good weather" saved you a click.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoThe EU really focused on importing rather than conserving natural gas. A huge solar/wind install which significantly reduced the need for natural gas turbines over the year doing as much to fill tanks as their new LNG terminal while providing more long term utility. Instead by focusing on being able to import and store vs conserve and store they further spiked prices. I am not saying they wanted to maximize misery for political reasons or profits for the energy sector. However, I can’t help but feel they mismanaged this even though the worst predictions like rationing or 10x price increases never happened. Perhaps I should give them more credit and say their plan actually worked reasonably well even if it’s benefitted from unusual weather. Winter is far from over and they are already in the clear.
- kzrdude 4y agoWhat kind of solar install could have been finished by now?
- Retric 4y agoI don’t really know, my point was really more about them seemingly putting all their eggs in one basket even though the total drop in natural gas as a percentage of energy generation supply wasn’t that big. A rough ballpark to see if it could have been meaningful, they had most of the year and annual production is something like ~200GW of solar panels vs average electricity production in the EU is ~300 GW. I have no idea how much could have been fast tracked but moving the needle quite far seems possible. But again I am not an expert and their plan seems to have worked.
- kzrdude 4y agoDiversifying it is a good point. While gas was maybe the focus for this winter, of course it would be good to start the solar initiative at the same time so that it can be ready for some future year.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoAnd what kind of yield would you get in December - February when you really need to heat the houses? Europe is much higher north than many assume
- Barrin92 4y agowhat stands out to me is that hopefully this crisis has broken up some of the static mentality we've had here. We had for the most part adopted the narrative that Russian energy is necessary, the economy will die otherwise, and so on. Now we're building LNG terminals in Germany, we're building a pipeline to Norway for hydrogen, all that stuff is suddenly possible in months when it took us decades to built a trainstation in Stuttgart. When shit hits the fan apparently we can still move things. The entire last year has made me oddly enough more optimistic. The continent is holding together, in addition to the weather the demographically tight labor market is sort of a blessing as unemployment remains low even with economic hickups and there's a real awareness that the status quo on many fronts wasn't sustainable.
- tasuki 4y ago> Now we're building LNG terminals in Germany That's not a good thing. LNG is not a good solution, apart from being easy and readily at hand.
- lakomen 4y ago[flagged]
- coffeebeqn 4y agoHave you not seen any reports from Ukraine?
- UncleMeat 4y agoInvading a neighboring nation and bombing their cities in order to capture more territory for yourself is pretty darn bad.
- knowaveragejoe 4y agoRussia is not operating as a misunderstood "good guy", the person you're replying to is caught up in contrarianism for its own sake.
- Animatronio 4y ago
- fijiaarone 4y agoThis just proves that chemtrails are real and the CIA is controlling the weather.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 4y agoI for one welcome our fictional conspiracy theory overlords.
- schiffern 4y agoYou don't have to believe in "chemtrails" to believe in weather modification. Weather modification is not science fiction. In fact, numerous weather modification projects are registered with NOAA.[1] "Chemtrails" seems like a classic misdirect-and-discredit campaign. If I was running the CIA, right now I would be warming Europe like there's no tomorrow (and denying it to avoid international blowback and to shirk blame for any side-effects). [1] https://library.noaa.gov/Collections/Digital-Collections/Weather-Modification-Project-Reports https://library.noaa.gov/Collections/Digital-Collections/Wea...
- pfdietz 4y ago"Warming Europe" is not a result any sane assessment of weather modification could suggest is possible.
- rr808 4y agoI've been genuinely scared of global warming and such mild winters but this year I appreciate the benefits.
- ilyt 4y agoIt's just world's 50 year plan to invade russia in winter /s
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe 'good weather' may have some problematic knock-on effects some months down the road if it keeps up, even if the lower demand due to record winter warmth has reduced spot prices on the LNG market. Warm weather trends could mean less snowpack across the region and potential drought conditions, which could impact everything from agricultural production to reduced summer hydroelectric production to problems with the cooling water supply for France's fleet of nuclear reactors: > "So while the current mild weather is viewed by some as having prevented a deeper power crisis stemming from gas shortages, the low snow and rain totals this winter may themselves pose an even greater risk if the warm and dry conditions continue." https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/europes-mild-weather-reprieve-this-winter-may-come-bite-by-summer-2023-01-11/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/europes-mild-wea... Notably, the trend of winters warming at a more rapid rate than summers in continental interiors is a long-standing prediction of climate models. Another feature is increased climatic instability associated with the gradually increasing water vapor content of the atmosphere (~7% increase per 1C temp rise), meaning long-term predictions are less reliable. Another factor that might be influencing the current relatively low European gas price is the trend towards de-industrialization in Europe, which is not a good sign for long-term economic health: > "Energy-intensive industries, such as aluminium, fertilisers, and chemicals are at risk of companies permanently shifting production to locations where cheap energy abounds, such as the United States. Even as an unusually warm October and projections of a mild winter helped drive prices lower, natural gas in the United States still costs about a fifth what companies pay in Europe." https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/energy-crisis-chips-away-europes-industrial-might-2022-11-02/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/energy-crisis-chips-... There is long-term potential for renewable energy to replace most natural gas demand, and if 10X as much effort had gone into it over the past ten years, Europe might not be in this bind at all.
- melenaboija 4y ago> Warm weather trends could mean less snowpack across the region and potential drought conditions, which could impact everything from agricultural production to reduced summer hydroelectric production to problems with the cooling water supply for France's fleet of nuclear reactors. The problem for agriculture there is not only water, it also needs cold periods for better harvests and fruit production.
- walterbell 4y agoChina is sometimes proactive on weather, e.g. for large events like the Olympics, https://www.cma.gov.cn/2011xwzx/2011xqxxw/2011xqxyw/202112/t20211221_589354.html https://www.cma.gov.cn/2011xwzx/2011xqxxw/2011xqxyw/202112/t.... > The Artificial Weather Impact Center mainly participates in the formulation of technical standards and norms related to artificial weather impact, is responsible for the construction, operation and maintenance of business systems, equipment research and development, test assessment and support, and the promotion of new technologies, organizes major national scientific and technological projects and large-scale scientific experiments, and is responsible for the program system of large-scale aircraft operations nationwide. https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/olympics/2022/01/24/olympics-china-weather-control/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/olympics/2022/01/24/ol... > China has been ramping up its program to levels seldom seen, either there or around the world. In December 2020, government officials announced a major expansion, setting as its goal triggering rain over more than two million square miles — an area larger than 187 of the world’s countries ... These efforts could have major consequences for both China’s 1.4 billion people and neighbors like Myanmar, India, and Nepal, raising a kind of ethical-meteorological tension between national sovereignty and global responsibility. What would happen if two neighboring countries attempted to influence the weather near their border?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yalogin 4y agoVery interesting. Under normal circumstances this would be considered to be dire. It would mean water problems in the year. However the Ukraine war made it into a favorable condition.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoI wouldn't call it entirely unpredictable. I've had probably five successive years of my birthday (the 20tht of October) being unusually warm. Warm as in being closer to 20 degrees celcius; or in one case warmer than that. The previously expected temperatures would be closer to zero. Like it reliably was every year when I was younger. 5 degrees would be normal. 10 degrees would be warm. 20 degrees would be ridiculous and unthinkable. Except that has now happened or nearly happened more than five years in a row. 18 degrees last time. And it hit 23 degrees a few days after. I actually walked outside in a t-shirt and a hoody in Berlin on the 31st of December. It was 17 degrees Celcius during the day. It never dipped below 14 degrees that day. That was only a few degrees warmer than the year before. This is the new normal for western Europe. It's long, cold winters that have become unusual. We haven't had one of those for quite a few years. The couple of weeks of snow we had last year don't count. The two weeks of freezing temperatures we had a month ago don't count. That's actually what used to be normal and expected for months on end. The anomaly is that this only happens for very short periods of time now. And some winters it doesn't happen at all anymore. I haven't actually had my heating on since December. The temperature in my apartment never dips below 18 degrees. In January. That's a first. That has never happened to me. This is not luck but climate change. The real lucky event is that Putin is forcing our hands years before we were ready to do something about that. LNG and coal are the short term expensive solution that is obviously bad for the climate. But they are also an enormous financial incentive to switch to renewables. Energy bills have gone up by 200-300% for people. It sucks. People are switching off their heating systems and wearing multiple sweaters for financial reasons. People I know, like my sister and my parents. And they are not even poor. This sucks more for people that literally need to choose between feeding themselves, paying the rent, or staying warm. There are plenty of those people. Everybody that has the option is now considering roof top solar, heat pumps, etc. Whatever they can do where the math adds up. And in some cases even when it doesn't add up. Demand for that stuff is simply enormous. Everybody is looking at ways to cut their energy bills whichever way they can and as fast as they can. There's a sense of urgency with people to fix their energy independence. We didn't have that before 2022. That's a really positive change from my point of view.
- martin_a 4y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted, I can just nod to everything you say. I remember that as a kid (25-20 years ago) there were winters where school busses would just not show up, because it was too cold and public service could not clear roads from snow and ice fast enough. We went out with sleds to the hills around town and ride them down all day. That was normal in my childhood from December to mid-February. The children of my friends never went to the same hills with sleds, because there's just no snow anymore. Maybe 2-5 cm that last for three days, but that's it. And not even that does happen every year. Climate is changing. Period.
- voytec 4y agoI find it hard to agree that we can call climate change-related weather "luck". If anything, European politicians will not learn their lesson and calling it luck is a shallow, short-term thinking.