9 ms·
Uncloaking a Slumlord Conspiracy with Social Network Analysis
- ChuckMcM 15y agoOk, I thought that was cool. Its a bit scary, in that it will force such conspiracies to become more complex (its an arms race after all), and it highlights a 'good' use of an analysis technique which the evil doers can use against their enemies, but still.
- billybob 15y ago"Its a bit scary, in that it will force such conspiracies to become more complex (its an arms race after all)" I'd say rather that it will push smaller players out of this kind of corrupt business. If you can't sell the business to your uncle without someone making the connection, you have to have a wider circle of trusted conspirators. If you're the mafia, that may not be a problem. If you're just a crooked family, you might just go out of business.
- r00fus 15y agoExactly. Keeping it in the family allows for easy trust... once that trust-web is exposed, it only leaves those who have heavily invested in "enforced non-traceable trust" (ie, the mafia, etc).
- redthrowaway 15y agoI'm reminded of Julian Assange's essay[1] on the nature of conspiracies, and how leaks serve to impose a 'secrecy tax' upon them, further obfuscating and reducing the power of information-sharing links between nodes. In his view, the additional complexity and reduction of trust among members of a conspiracy that results from leaks reduces its ability to properly react to novel stimuli, eventually leading to its downfall. It's an interesting essay, and I'm somewhat surprised to see such a germane example here. [1] http://cryptome.org/0002/ja-conspiracies.pdf http://cryptome.org/0002/ja-conspiracies.pdf
- Vivtek 15y agoI think in the end it may make it more profitable not to extract equity at the community's expense, but rather to engage in honest business. I love this kind of article.
- tibbon 15y agoI wonder if this type of business behavior explains some of the places in Boston I saw that were always "going out of business" only to reopen the next day, as practical the same thing. There was a rug store on Boylston that was like that. I swear it must have had 10 going out of business sales.
- xxdiamondxx 15y agoIn high school I was working at a failing grocery store that decided to go out of business. In the weeks prior to the going out of business sale we marked up everything in the store by at least 33%. Then we had the "sale". I remember the manager telling me we were making $30,000 a day during the week-long sale. I guess "going out of business" is good business, haha.
- jordan0day 15y agoYeah, I remember a few years back when a lot of businesses were going out of business reading online accounts of these tactics. One that especially sticks out is when the Circuit City chain went under. I remember reading about how they brought in an outside company to handle the sales, and the first order of business was to raise all the prices on everything in the store. DVDs that they couldn't sale at $10 were suddenly flying off the shelves at $20 (don't remember the exact numbers). It makes you realize what a fine line (which each person has to draw for themself) there is between clever marketing and slimy, manipulative tactics.
- tadfisher 15y agoThis practice is an interesting play on expectations; namely, that a fire sale implies deep discounts on goods. It is similar to the tactic used at Black Friday at just about every major retailer: have a few major loss-leaders in your ad, and discreetly mark up everything else in the store. Is this manipulative? I wouldn't call it that, at least not more than any other retail tactic. Consumers have more price information available to them than ever before, yet they are still amazingly susceptible to the idea that they are getting a good deal, nevermind that the widget that they are saving 25% on costs half as much on Amazon. If using psychology as a sales tool is unethical, then the idea of advertisement and "sales" must be as well.
- djb_hackernews 15y agoThat was interesting. If you like this kind of sleuthing and analysis, you'll enjoy http://sharesleuth.com/ http://sharesleuth.com/ - Which is a Mark Cuban pet project that investigates shady listed companies in search for shortable targets.
- scrod 15y agoImagine how much easier this is when the subjects openly declare their connections on Facebook.
- jdp23 15y ago"How to research a slumlord", from last year, has a lot more information about the process: http://drpop.org/2010/04/how-to-research-a-slumlord/ http://drpop.org/2010/04/how-to-research-a-slumlord/
- baq 15y agothe link's so good it's even included in the article.
- johnohara 15y agoThe diagrams remind me of the hand-drawn ones FBI agent John O'Neill created after the USS Cole incident and continually updated prior to the attacks of 9/11. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/knew/etc/connect.html http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/knew/etc/conne...
- laconian 15y agoI'm no slumlord, but the fact that people can do this analysis with public data does spook me more than a little. Still, that's good detectivework and a great outcome!
- bri3d 15y agoA fun way to explore some (very different) data in a similar manner is to use Palantir's https://analyzethe.us/ https://analyzethe.us/ - the Palantir client is pretty complex but extremely powerful for this kind of social network analysis.
- civilian 15y agoAnd now I want to start a conspiracy. It just looks so cool!
- cperciva 15y agoAs time went on, and the buildings appreciated in value during a real estate boom -- loans from the mortgage company allowed the owners to "strip mine" the equity from the buildings. This is a common slumlord modus operandi -- they suck money out of a building rather than put money back in for maintenance. Strip mining the equity? It's their building, isn't it? Seems to me that if someone wants to own a pile of cash and a worthless building instead of owning a well-maintained building, that's a business decision they should be entitled to make.
- mikeash 15y agoI suppose it depends on whether you think the person "strip mining" the building should be allowed to expose the building's tenants to raw sewage and high levels of lead, and not pay their utility bills.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoPeople are entitled to make that decision, but they are not entitled to also rent out an "uninhabitable" building while doing so (or to avoid paying utilities). The slum lords here juggled ownership between different LLCs in order to avoid that little problem.
- ams6110 15y agoWhy would the tenants continue to live there? Most cities have landlord/tenant regulations that tilt towards (if not strongly favor) the tenants. I would have just moved out.
- __david__ 15y agoBecause the properties are probably the cheapest around meaning that the people who live there would have to move up, not sideways. Not everyone can afford that.
- InclinedPlane 15y ago"Most cities have landlord/tenant regulations that tilt towards (if not strongly favor) the tenants." Maybe you missed the part where the landlords were blatantly in violation of those regulations. Also, the tenants continued to live there largely because they didn't have many options. For most of these people the only option otherwise available to them would likely be a homeless shelter.
- wtvanhest 15y agoI guess I'm confused. I can see how real estate owners and mortgage companies have relationships with each other. (A lot of small owners have investments from family and friends and use a single mortgage financing company with experience closing tough initial investment deals) What I don't understand is how the social network analysis led to a conviction. What does the connection mean? Can someone else explain it?
- gwillen 15y agoIf you are cited for code violations, then you sell the property to your brother before the deadline to comply, and claim compliance is no longer your problem, that's fraud. This kind of analysis can be used to show a pattern of that kind of fraud.
- spiffytech 15y agoIs the problem that I sold the property before complying, or that I sold it to my brother? What makes selling to my brother any different from selling to a stranger? [supposing we live in different households with independent assets]
- zacharycohn 15y agoThere was a whole group of people who were doing this constantly. So all the properties stayed within the same group. Normally, you could sell the property to a stranger... but then you wouldn't be able to benefit from it anymore. This way it "stays in the family."
- wtvanhest 15y agoThis seems unlikely due to the taxes and paperwork expense of transferring property even with no brokerage fees. I really don't see how the social network proves wrong doing. I'm actually worried that an overzealous prosecutor and advocacy group prosecuted people who were not guilty. Obviously I don't know all the details so maybe they should be convicted, but they weren't provided, so it is hard for me to evaluate.
- uiri 15y agoIt just seems unlikely that every single state will require the actual owner of the LLC to be in public records. If that is the case, good luck finding the owners. Ideally the slumlord will have a different registered agent (person in the relevant state who handles the LLC paperwork) for each LLC and the superintendent only deals with a lawyer. Again, different lawyer for each building/LLC. You can sue the LLC, but the only asset that'd own is the building itself. So, properly done, it seems that slumlords can get away with it. Of course, paying all these lawyers might be more expensive than being a decent landlord, it is probably a lot less work. I feel like I'm missing some practical uses of knowing the superintendent, local and out-of-state lawyer for each building (or building/LLC combo). I only skimmed the linked How To Research a Slumlord, although the results seems to be "render the LLC useless by suing the actual owner".
- dhotson 15y agoWe do this kind of analysis where I work for detecting fraud. I can't go into too many details, but I can probably show you a simple example: http://i.imgur.com/feJLd.png http://i.imgur.com/feJLd.png This is showing some of the relationships between users in the system. You take a user that you know is dodgy, and then start looking at what they have in common with other users. Also, slightly offtopic—I open sourced the graph visualisation part: http://github.com/dhotson/springy http://github.com/dhotson/springy
- ivan_ah 15y agodhoston/springy is awesome !
- bane 15y agoReminds me of the kind of analysis in http://www.palantirtech.com/government/analysis-blog/insiderthreat http://www.palantirtech.com/government/analysis-blog/insider...
- cartouche86 15y agoA similar situation in the state of Texas: multiple units under a condominum regime with a (now majority) owner who wants to buy all remaining units, raze the structures and convert the land to commercial use. A minority of condo owners want to continue to live in well-maintained condos in a nice part of town where commercial real estate is _very_ expensive. You guessed it, the majority owner is a shell corporation with the church/school behind it. The majority owner has slowly purchased units, stripped them of utilities and let them lie fallow without renting them. The subdivision has well-written deed restrictions limiting the land to residential-only use. Commercial entities are specifically disallowed (churches and private schools are commercial entities in Texas). The deed restrictions can be changed only by majority subdivision vote once every 10 years (2020 next vote). The church/school does not own a majority of the land in the subdivision. Through these shell corporations, the church/school has quietly purchased properties at residential rates in this deed-restricted residential-only subdivision and then converted the land to commercial use (IMO a clear violation of the deed restrictions). Commercial land in the same neighborhood is _very_ expensive. The city is allowed to enforce deed restrictions but is reluctant to do so. The condo regime requires that units be kept for the welfare of the owners and residents but soon the majority owner will take over the condominium board. Minority owners fear that the majority owner will use the condominium association's powers to drive them out.. To me there appears to be a legal conflict of interest: all condo owners sign an agreement to support the condo regime and the welfare of all owners in perpetuity, yet this particular majority owner seeks to liquidate the condo regime. Anyone have expertise in handling this type of case in Texas? Or who can direct me to someone familiar with this type of takeover? What does this have to do with conspiracy? The ties of the church/school to the city government, the local legal community and real estate developers are deep and intricate. Most real estate attorneys we have spoken to have some affiliation with the church/school (which is a very large and very wealthy organization) and cannot or will not sell their services to us. For years the companies that were acquiring units in the condo used multiple shell corporations to do so. It was not clear what was happening until fairly recently.