4 ms·
I think many US highway signs are too wordy. Seems that European signs are more iconic. They are faster to recognize and more pleasant to look at but maybe take
by SoftTalker 4y ago
I think many US highway signs are too wordy. Seems that European signs are more iconic. They are faster to recognize and more pleasant to look at but maybe take a bit more education to understand. US driver education is woeful by most other first-world standards, so maybe that's part of why we seem to need so many signs that explain things in words.
- cameldrv 4y agoIt's probably more that the U.S. is mostly monolingual, but in Europe you can drive a few hours and the main language can change multiple times.
- bombcar 4y agoThis is entirely it - and the reason that EU stop signs say STOP: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_sign#Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_sign#Europe
- inciampati 4y agoIt's also dramatically more efficient and safe to have a quickly readable visual symbol. Maybe that's just my opinion but it seems reasonable to assume it factored into the design.
- vladvasiliu 4y agoThere's also the fact that it's understandable when you're looking at it the wrong way. It's useful to gauge who should stop and who has right of way. For example, in France (and most of Europe, I think), the default is for traffic coming from the right to have right of way. So if you're coming from the left and see the back of the sign, you know you don't have to yield.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _benedict 4y agoThe U.K. is even more monolingual and still uses icons for the obvious UX benefit of faster recognition with less distraction from the road.
- rubylark 4y agoDo you have examples of wordy US signs that are only symbolic in the EU system? All of the ones I see on the article are either city names or pedestrian signs with complex instructions that I don't think could be conveyed effectively in only symbolic form. The ones I can think of that are words only that might have a better symbolic notation are Dead End, No Outlet, and No Passing Zone.
- playingalong 4y agoNot the OP, but let me try. Some like "cross only at cross walks" or "no pedestrian crossing" are not a sign at all in EU. They are either implied by general traffic rules, or implied by traffic rules for given road category, or enforced with infrastructure. "One lane bridge" EU has specific signs for lane cross section (not for bridges specifically). "Pavement ends" I even consider funny. What comes next after that? "A meadow starts?"
- jetbalsa 4y ago"Pavement ends" normally means the road is going to be a dirt road or gravel road. Pretty common in rural areas
- yamtaddle 4y ago"Slow the fuck down now, speeder—yes, you!—or be very unhappy when, a few seconds from now, you try to brake on gravel at high speed and spin out"
- karaterobot 4y agoDepending on where you are in the U.S., a "cross only at crosswalks" sign is necessary because all intersections are considered to act as crosswalks even when there are no solid white lines. Pedestrians can still cross, and vehicles should yield the right of way. That sign could indicate an exception to the rule, due to some dangerous, non-obvious condition that makes it unsafe for pedestrians to cross the road.
- rmnwski 4y ago
- crazygringo 4y agoI'm not sure what US driver education has to do with it, or on what basis you consider it "woeful". But I've driven in both the US and Europe, and while a lot of the European signs are easy to figure out, a lot of them seem not only non-intuitive but also inconsistent, as well as difficult to read. For example, "no stopping" is a red circle with a blue background and an X, while "no parking" is the same red circle with the same blue background and a slash, or half the X. Not only is all of this totally arbitrary, but there's almost zero contrast between the red and blue, so the opposite of being fast to recognize, or pleasant. And then a slash in some cases means "end of" (end of no passing zone) but in other cases it means "no" (no left turn). So it essentially means both "allowed" and "not allowed", but I guess it's based on the color or orientation or something of the slash, or multiple thin slashes vs one big thick one? I find myself very much preferring the help of "wordiness" in this case. The top priority while driving is clarity in messaging, not economy of space. What the US does, which is actually to combine symbols in many cases with text, gives both quick recognition and unambiguous information.
- cesarb 4y ago> For example, "no stopping" is a red circle with a blue background and an X, while "no parking" is the same red circle with the same blue background and a slash, or half the X. Not only is all of this totally arbitrary It makes sense if you think of "parking" as sort of a "long term stopping". That is: no stopping at all (includes no parking), short stops only (stopping allowed but not parking), stopping fully allowed (both short stops and parking).
- Swizec 4y ago> I'm not sure what US driver education has to do with it, or on what basis you consider it "woeful". I got my driver's license in EU first (Slovenia). Then had to pass it again in USA (San Francisco). The US test was a joke. No parallel parking portion, no highway portion, no complex intersection portion, no hill start portion (in SF!!!), no first aid portion, no ... many things were missing actually. But I did have to show hand signals!? Lol what. The US test took 10 minutes and we drove around the block. The EU test took an hour, came with mandatory 30 hours of licensed instructor training, and the instructor had to certify on pain of losing their license that I spent at least 3 hours driving at night during training. Nowadays the EU license, at least in Slovenia, requires passing a "stunt driving" course within 2 years of getting your license. It's been decided knowing how to control a skid in icy/snowy conditions is mandatory, for example. > a lot of them seem not only non-intuitive but also inconsistent There is a visual language you have to learn as part of the licensing process. You spend about 5 hours of classroom instruction before even getting your permit to start learning how to drive. There is a logic behind how the signs are structured and you don't have to memorize. Different countries do use different signs but the iconography is very similar for the most part. > The top priority while driving is clarity in messaging, not economy of space I find the EU signs faster to recognize because pictograms are easy. I've got most US signs memorized by now so they work like pictograms. But when you do have to read the sign, takes a lot of attention away from driving imo.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]