3 ms·
I remember when Google/pagerank first came out. My experience at the time is that Google was dramatically and undeniably better than the other search engines of
by sokoloff 4y ago
I remember when Google/pagerank first came out. My experience at the time is that Google was dramatically and undeniably better than the other search engines of the time (ones that many people can't even name now).
The catalog/directory style sites were instantly made almost valueless by Google's better mousetrap. Google gave better search results than the previous leader, Altavista (IMO).
Whether Google results of 1998 were worse in some measures than Google results of 2023 doesn't say much about whether "giving great search" gave people a super power that they didn't have before. I think it did (though I agree that someone else would have eventually done so, obviously).
- wyclif 4y agoFor me, it was AltaVista. When Google came out, it was simply mind-blowing how much better it was and I switched immediately.
- lll-o-lll 4y agoWhat I think people tend to forget in this discussion is the genuine value that google brought when it first came out was not “better search” so much as it was “resilience against gaming”. The pre-www search engines (gopher, Archie, jughead) were pretty sophisticated by allowing you to combine search expressions “and, or, near, phrase”, in essentially a regex style fashion, and they were getting better and better. Early www search engines followed the same approach, operating in the way that some library catalog systems still do. The problem is that they were easily gamed by bad actors. This wasn’t an issue for some time, but the very instant making money become a possibility on the internet, everything changed. People remember google trouncing Altavista, but this was the broken Altavista that couldn’t defend against the scammers. The war had been going on for some time by then, with search engines starting well and failing once their weaknesses were discovered and exploited. That google “topic + reddit” is now a thing says to me that the gamers have again won, and a new search approach is needed.
- tstrimple 4y agoWhile I'm often annoyed if not downright frustrated by Google search results today, it's perfectly clear to me that I wouldn't have the level of career I have if it wasn't for the value Google provided to early internet searches. Compared to the folks who had 10+ years of experience on me in 2000 it certainly felt like a super power.
- ghaff 4y agoGoogle and just the amount of accessible information. I sometimes think that if I were transported back to my pre-web job, the level of sheer frustration I would have at the limited, out-dated information I would have access to for everything would be immense. Of course, most everyone else would be in the same boat but we're accustomed to trivially looking up so much stuff that would have required significant time and/or money to find out--if it were really even available at all.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoI do a lot of heavily-NDA'd firmware work during the day and play around with web stuff at night There's absolutely nothing available for my day job online, so you could say I've been living without Google for a decade. It's not as tough as you'd think. You just have to remember some basic syntax in your head or write it down in your notes, and look up APIs when you use them. It doesn't honestly take much longer to do something sans-Google at work than it does to cobble web stuff together with Google and StackOverflow's help. It's OK
- ghaff 4y agoI didn't and don't do a lot of software development. I was a product manager for a long time and then an IT industry analysts. As a product manager, to pick on one particular point, we had very cursory competitive information. We had some expensive subscriptions to analysts who essentially acted as a clearinghouse for data sheets that companies couldn't get from each other directly. But it tended to be very shallow and out-of-date. Certainly not everything is on the web with or without paywalls. And, as when I was doing software development at night pre-web, I could just have a library of books. But for a lot of things, you made do with taking longer, being more shallow, and making more mistakes.
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoI do miss the old style directory search engines for the ability to explore them. I could click on a topic and keep drilling down, down, down and endless rabbit hole and learn new things. Now I use wikipedia, but it doesn't quite have that mind blowing feeling I felt as a kid.