3 ms·
Their interpretation of question 5 is just plain wrong. Aside from the fact that losses DO hurt more than gains (because you need to alter your plans to accomod
by kstenerud 15y ago
Their interpretation of question 5 is just plain wrong. Aside from the fact that losses DO hurt more than gains (because you need to alter your plans to accomodate losses), the assumption of equivalence is fundamentally flawed.
The problem is that the two halves are inverted. Correcting:
5a: Your base position is $900, and you have the option of risking $900 for a possible gain of $100. You have a 90% chance of gaining $100 (a trivial amount) and a 10% chance of losing $900 (a big amount).
5b: Your base position is -$900, and you have the option of risking $100 for a possible gain of $900. You have a 90% chance of losing $100 (a trivial amount) and a 10% chance of gaining $900 (a big amount).
Since you're an individual, and not a statistical average, there's no middle ground in the values gained or lost.
So the rational person is right to choose A, then B. The two are NOT equivalent to an individual. The trivial amount makes little difference as a gain or a loss, but the big amount does.