4 ms·
This system is a rule of free market economics summarized as "the price of a commodity is its marginal cost". So changing this system means meddling in the fre
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
This system is a rule of free market economics summarized as "the price of a commodity is its marginal cost".
So changing this system means meddling in the free market. There are times and places where meddling is appropriate and this is likely one such, but there are significant consequences and side effects to doing so, so shouldn't be done lightly.
- hdkrgr 4y agoThere are also significant consequences and side effects to having a 'free market', they are called externalities and in the case of fossil fuels they lead to huge unconsidered costs. I'm putting 'free market' in quotes, because even beyond externalities, the current system with zonal uniform pricing is only 'free' for a very narrow view of what constitutes a commodity or a marginal cost. Consider two households: (a) in northern Germany close to the Danish border, located in a small town with lots of local wind turbine capacity, (b) in Southern Bavaria with very limited renewable energy production close by. There's also no adequate power transport infrastructure to get the renewable energy from the North (or elsewhere in Europe) to household (b), mostly because local politicians in Bavaria oppose putting up any visible infrastructure, whether power lines or wind turbines). Now, during peak wind hours, a significant portion of the wind turbines in the north will go offline because the network cannot handle the load, while household (b) still needs to get their power from gas. [This is not a contrived example, but reality in Germany.] Yet (a) and (b) both pay the same price -- that of the gas producer. How is this a 'free' market? But to your point, the good news is that people are taking electricity market design very seriously, not lightly. (Section 6 of this white paper is a good read that outlines many of the current market inefficiencies (Disclaimer: my former academic advisor and a few former colleagues are coauthors)): https://synergie-projekt.de/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Electricity_Market_Design_2030___2050__Shaping_future_electricity_markets_for_a_climate_neutral_Europe_final.pdf https://synergie-projekt.de/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Elect...
- the_third_wave 4y agoElectricity is not sold on a "free market" anyway - I can not just hook up my nuclear power station without paying a specific tax aimed at just nuclear power generation - here in Sweden it is called "effektskatt" (output-power based tax) and is responsible for making it very hard or impossible to profitably run nuclear power stations [1]. The government went so far as to change the leadership for the state-owned power company Vattenfall because the existing leadership was not deemed to be cooperative in leading the change to "renewable" power sources. On the other hand I may be able to put a wind turbine on my premises and get subsidised for doing so which has the opposite effect of the mentioned tax on nuclear power in that it makes it easier to generate wind power profitably. Some users are freed from all sorts of taxes which all others have to pay, here in Sweden this is - or was, the current government seems to want to change this policy - the case for the likes of Facebook, Google and Microsoft who were allowed to establish data centres with the promise of nearly tax-free electricity. These data centres take so much power that the regions where they have been established have found it difficult to allow other energy-intensive industry to establish there for lack of power. Margin pricing on electricity is counterproductive and should be abolished since it makes it more profitable to underinvest in more efficient power generation technologies since that would have a negative effect on market prices. It is better to keep a few inefficient gas turbines online and make sure these are needed at peak hours since they will drive up the market price for all generated power. As long as margin pricing is in place I do not expect something like grid-scale battery storage for peak demand to take hold since that has the potential to drive down prices. [1] https://naringslivets-medieinstitut.se/det-var-marknaden-som-stangde-karnkraften/ https://naringslivets-medieinstitut.se/det-var-marknaden-som...
- Gwypaas 4y ago> Electricity is not sold on a "free market" anyway - I can not just hook up my nuclear power station without paying a specific tax aimed at just nuclear power generation - here in Sweden it is called "effektskatt" (output-power based tax) and is responsible for making it very hard or impossible to profitably run nuclear power stations [1]. The government went so far as to change the leadership for the state-owned power company Vattenfall because the existing leadership was not deemed to be cooperative in leading the change to "renewable" power sources. The "effektskatt" was removed in 2018. > On the other hand I may be able to put a wind turbine on my premises and get subsidised for doing so which has the opposite effect of the mentioned tax on nuclear power in that it makes it easier to generate wind power profitably. The subsidies for wind power in Sweden was phased out in 2021 due to not being necessary anymore.
- the_third_wave 4y agoThat these taxes are changed does not change the fact that they, and others, existed (for many decades) and exist and will continue to be imposed. The electricity market is not a "free market", it is a controlled market and as such it would not be "meddling with the free market" to change the control to remove some of the negative effects of such. The marginal pricing mechanism is a prime example of something in need of change.
- Gwypaas 4y agoThe marginal pricing mechanism is near impossible to change on a market made up of multiple players. Unless you want to fundamentally alter the market to a more monopolistic market where the state selects or owns the power generation. Like the nice market P&G have in California. How would you do it? If you keep the current market with multiple independent actors then they would try to predict the most expensive generation required and bid at that price. Or you could tell them that since you are "coal" you get this price. But then that would be unfair to someone who made a different business case based on their availability, or their costs, or whatever. You essentially end up in a quagmire of 5 year planned production. Marginal pricing solves this, and is what is applied to all raw resource markets due to these issues. If you do not like marginal pricing you have all the possibility in the world to buy electricity futures, which of course nets you less income as a power generator and costs more for customers, because the risk is still exists.