3 ms·
> Many of those we do all get vaccinated against as children. It's not relevant as I did not ask about getting vaccines for things that are a risk or where the
by brigandish 4y ago
> Many of those we do all get vaccinated against as children.
It's not relevant as I did not ask about getting vaccines for things that are a risk or where the benefits outweigh the risks. Have you thought about arguing against the points I made? I know it's convenient to use a straw man but it's really not very interesting and it looks weak.
> It sounds like you're opposed to vaccines until they pass a magic "recently dead" threshhold?
I'm opposed to medical interventions where the benefits do not outweigh the risks. You know, like doctors and people like that. It's why they usually don't give out medicine like sweeties. <cough> opioid crisis <cough cough>.
> Apparently that threshhold is higher than 6.7 million, which is COVID's death count so far. So where's it at?
As I've pointed out (repeatedly), the vast, vast majority of those were with comorbidities such as age and/or health problems related to obesity. Those people, who we know are at high risk and for whom the benefits outweigh the risks should probably get vaccinated, if they wish to.
> Or perhaps you erroneously believe it's possible to live in a functional society where nobody has any responsibilities whatsoever to eachother and the maintenance of that society?
Thank you, Chairman Mao, for your insightful words. The nail that stands up truly should be knocked down! How many more straw men while I have to endure…?
> lol, should we stop vaccinating against polio (in that list you linked) cause nobody's died from it recently? I mean, the chance of dying from polio is 0, right?
…and there we have another straw man, apparently by a teenager, "lol". The benefits of the polio vaccine outweigh the risks. I can keep repeating this until you get it into your head. "lol".
> Even if the risk of outright death to you is low, you have a responsibility to create a link in the herd immunity chain
No, I don't, and there will be no herd immunity for COVID-19. This has been known for at least 18 months now (even the NYT will reported that[1], on a loooong time lag) and was the likely outcome long before that.
> That's not even mentioning that COVID doesn't necessarily have to kill you…
The risks of disease severity that correlate with known comorbidities hold for every stage of the disease, from hospital admission, to ICU admission, to use of respirator, to death. It's not that you get healthy people all the way to the ICU and then suddenly it's the fatties getting respirators and dying. Jesus wept. If you won't look at the data at least apply some common sense.
> i know plenty who got infected pre-vaccines that suffer long term side effects in terms of their breathing ability, one of whom was a marathon runner. Tell me he wasn't healthy before?
Anecdotes are not data, and such a small number of healthy people have encountered severe disease that, unless you believe in magic, he had a comorbidity that is yet to be understood or known - either in general or in his specific case (do you have his blood tests or know if he's one of the people that produce low amounts of interferon?) We do not live in the world of Harry Potter. Or, you know, you could just look at the literature:
> The marathon running population does not constitute solely persons with excellent cardiovascular health. Marathon runners, especially those with a family history of heart disease and other coronary risk factors, should not consider themselves immune to either sudden death or to coronary heart disease
> Why do you reject this social responsibility
Because it only exists in your head.
> that has the upside of making a possible covid infection for you dramatically less likely to hospitalize you
The effect of exercise was greater than any of the vaccines on all health events related to COVID-19. Read the paper Associations of Physical Inactivity and COVID-19 Outcomes Among Subgroups I shared above.
> let alone prevent long covid as well as simply make an infection less uncomfortable?
If you're talking about preventing COVID-19 then you should look up what sterilizing immunity[3] is, and note that none of the COVID-19 vaccines provide it.
As to comfort, when I had COVID-10 I found that painkillers helped a lot.
So, I asked a specific question that you ignored so I will make it more specific and explicit - please, tell us all why we should get the Yellow Fever vaccine even though most of us are not at risk of catching it and hence, the benefits cannot outweigh the risks. It'll be interesting watching you argue against medical orthodoxy.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/03/health/covid-herd-immunity-vaccine.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/03/health/covid-herd-immunit...
[2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3298928/#article-details https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3298928/#article-details
[3] https://thehill.com/changing-america/well-being/prevention-cures/501677-what-is-sterilizing-immunity-and-do-we-need-it/#content https://thehill.com/changing-america/well-being/prevention-c...
- komali2 4y ago> - please, tell us all why we should get the Yellow Fever vaccine even though most of us are not at risk of catching it That's pointless, let's just go to the heart of the issue here. You, for some reason, are special, and smarter than all of us idiots that listened to our doctor when they said "get the covid vaccine." So, when I answer your question as to why we don't get the Yellow Fever vaccine, "because doctors don't recommend it, but doctors do recommend getting the COVID vaccine," tell us why you are right, and why they are wrong to say we should get the COVID vaccine. I can only think of two possibilities: the vast majority of doctors across the entire planet are stupider than you, or, they're all lying for... some reason. So, which is it? In short, you're doing what you've accused me of doing: not really answering the question, *why NOT get the COVID vaccine?* Given that basically every health professional across the world recommends near everyone to get a COVID vaccine, including young and healthy people, what's your *good reason* not to? Because something vaguely about "opioid epidemic?" Not good enough, that's a unique-to-America problem, we don't have the same issue here with our health advice re: medication and vaccination. Doctors recommend that young, healthy people get a COVID vaccine because the possibility of a side effect are extremely small, compared to the possibilities for the same person having a really bad COVID infection with long term effects. The possibilities of COVID vaccination side effects are also low enough to justify the social benefits of a vaccinated population. Though true herd immunity won't happen, every step each of takes to reduce the chance of infection, helps in the overall reduction of fatal or severe infections. It'd be great if it was black and white, but part of why covid is such a virulent pandemic is because that's not possible with this disease. It was the same with wearing masks: nope, wearing a mask doesn't completely eliminate the spread of covid, but the studies bear out that it reduces infection rate: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2119266119 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2119266119 (among others) You said you don't think you'd get a severe covid infection, then claim I don't know my friend well enough to say why they would. You guessed at comorbidity, that could be detected through a blood panel, despite the greater medical field not being fully certain on exactly what comorbidity could cause a bad covid infection among a young health person, and whether said comorbidity could be detected in a blood panel. You don't actually know for sure whether or not you're susceptible to a bad COVID infection, unless, again, you know something the rest of the world doesn't, which, you don't. So, the statistics indicate that you, like most people, should just get a COVID vaccine. If the term "social responsibility" makes you hear the soviet national anthem in your head, I'm very curious how you feel about littering, playing loud music in public, and opting to hold in a pee until you get to a public bathroom. And if you think everyone that uses words like "lol" is a teenager, I'm really curious how you are at parties lmao