4 ms·
Which of these hypotheticals is least bad: an AI which won't write political invective against anyone, or one which will be used by your enemies to stir up hatr
by ben_w 4y ago
Which of these hypotheticals is least bad: an AI which won't write political invective against anyone, or one which will be used by your enemies to stir up hatred against your entire team, and your team's only available response is to do the same back at the entire other side?
- nullish_signal 4y ago"Will be used by your enemies" and "only response is fight Fire with Fire" are both a bit hyperbolic
- LightG 4y ago* Set reminder for this comment - 10th Jan, 2028 * /Edit * Reset reminder - 5th Nov, 2024 *
- ben_w 4y agoThe first is 100% guaranteed unless someone makes a synthetic virus that turns our entire species into peace-and-love hippies. I recon that would probably be a good thing, probably. Enough people will respond with the second that, although it can be avoided with skill and courage and charismatic leadership, it has a decent risk. Even just politics, it’s not just two parties: When I say there is a literal Communist Party of the United States of America, it’s not a sarcastic reference to the Democrats, nor even to the Greens. Even within parties, you see political divisions. And political enemies aren’t limited to domestic politics.
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoHow about looking at political conversation as less of a fight and more of a dialogue? In which case I wouldn't mind any intelligent input from chatGPT even if it's against my viewpoint, and nobody really needs artificial stupidity as there's already plenty of human stupidity to go around. Get your out of your tribalistic mindset. And get your tribalistic mindset out of the way of real progress (as opposed to so called "social justice" ""progress"")
- ben_w 4y ago> Get your out of your tribalistic mindset. And get your tribalistic mindset out of the way of real progress (as opposed to so called "social justice" ""progress"") Most humans can’t help but be tribalist, which is why I don’t blame you for taking a swipe at social justice even though I very carefully didn’t say which tribe I’m in. Now, given you appear to hate social justice enough to put it in scare quotes, I ask you to imagine some amoral but intellectually perfect AI tasked with the goal of creating propaganda that calls for the destruction of anyone who hates social justice. (If you’d said the same thing but put “conservatives” in scare quotes, I’d make the same point but with the phrase “anyone who hates conservatism”). Telling me not to be tribal isn’t going to stop someone sending that prompt to that AI. Telling the AI not to be, is going to stop them getting infinite free propaganda. This isn’t the only reason to do this (the massive PR risk from an unfettered AI is another), but it is a sufficient reason to do this, and OpenAI have repeatedly demonstrated that they err on the side of assuming their AI is better than it really is just in case.
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoI'll take it to the extreme and say I don't care if it even produces anti semitic content, and I'm saying that as a Jew. Propaganda is spread by the media, by journalists, by people with viewers with genuine trust, not by random trolls in the internet. It's spread by professors in the academia, by teachers. If it is a random anonymous person on the internet you don't trust what he says.
- int_19h 4y agoIn practice, it ends up being an AI that won't do the former for your average person but can still be prompt-engineered to do the latter by a sufficiently determined attacker.
- ben_w 4y agoProbably. But AI alignment research is currently extremely primitive (I think they describe themselves as “pre-paradigmatic”), so giving them some time to find a better way is at least worth trying.