2 ms·
> You would see it justified to cash in on someone else's work after she "sold some copies"? In fact the answer to the example of Harry Potter should be that i
by bambax 15y ago
> You would see it justified to cash in on someone else's work after she "sold some copies"?
In fact the answer to the example of Harry Potter should be that if copyright didn't exist, then it would be hard to sell any copy. Maybe some people would be able to sell printed copies, or better copies, or from a manufacturer approved by the author, etc. -- but most (electronic) copies would be available for free.
The question is: would it be bad? You seem to think that it would be morally bad; I'm not sure what morals have to do with it. It would be legal.
Would it be economically bad? I'm not sure either. In general, contrary to what people seem to believe, the economy benefits from cheaper goods.
But the larger point is that works of the mind belong to the public. They used to be in the public domain by default. Copyright is something that is cut from the property of the general public, and given to someone as an incentive to produce more original work.
The public should make sure they're getting their money's worth when granting copyright extensions. And, as it is obvious this is not the case, we should be demanding copyright reduction.
When you want ten bucks, ask for a million. When you want a shorter copyright length, ask for zero.