3 ms·
Harms claimed: This type of erasure undermines the abilities of Native and non-Native people to work together Romanticizing Indigenous culture [...] is ha
by meltyness 4y ago
Harms claimed:
This type of erasure undermines the abilities of Native and non-Native people to work together
Romanticizing Indigenous culture [...] is harmful. It categorizes Indigenous people within the bounds of the stereotype [...]
Obviously diversity is important and stereotyping is bad, but Apache is just a nation. It's like demonizing using "pangea" or "constantinople" for a street name. Obviously it wouldn't offend me if Apache took action to remediate, but I think the importance of the complaints in this article are overstated.
At the risk of being guilty of cultural erasure, maybe it would be in the author's interest to be constructive about amplifying culture rather than destructive. This isn't about pedagogy amplifying some narrow view, it's barely even an homage, it's a positive view of history written hundreds of years ago. If you want to discredit that history, you'll have to be more specific.
- nerdponx 4y agoIt's really easy to argue that other people shouldn't be offended by this, but that's because indigenous American cultures have been so aggressively erased that we can barely empathize with them anymore as fellow human beings. As I wrote in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34329605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34329605, imagine if instead this were the "Irish Software Foundation". It would be so blatantly stupid that it would never come to exist in the first place.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]