3 ms·
>The human brain is, after all, a computer operating on input in the form of experience and biology "In his book In Our Own Image (2015), the artificial intell
by coldtea 4y ago
>The human brain is, after all, a computer operating on input in the form of experience and biology
"In his book In Our Own Image (2015), the artificial intelligence expert George Zarkadakis describes six different metaphors people have employed over the past 2,000 years to try to explain human intelligence.
In the earliest one, eventually preserved in the Bible, humans were formed from clay or dirt, which an intelligent god then infused with its spirit. That spirit ‘explained’ our intelligence – grammatically, at least.
The invention of hydraulic engineering in the 3rd century BCE led to the popularity of a hydraulic model of human intelligence, the idea that the flow of different fluids in the body – the ‘humours’ – accounted for both our physical and mental functioning. The hydraulic metaphor persisted for more than 1,600 years, handicapping medical practice all the while.
By the 1500s, automata powered by springs and gears had been devised, eventually inspiring leading thinkers such as René Descartes to assert that humans are complex machines. In the 1600s, the British philosopher Thomas Hobbes suggested that thinking arose from small mechanical motions in the brain. By the 1700s, discoveries about electricity and chemistry led to new theories of human intelligence – again, largely metaphorical in nature. In the mid-1800s, inspired by recent advances in communications, the German physicist Hermann von Helmholtz compared the brain to a telegraph."
- macguillicuddy 4y agoI don't mean that the brain is materially a computer in the sense we're used to computers in our day-to-day. That would be demonstrably false. Just as we can show humans are not formed from clay we can show humans are not formed of transistors. Instead I mean that humans are logically computers. Physical entities operating on inputs and producing outputs. They share this property with any other physical system. Now there may be some supernatural layer that exists beyond the physics and chemistry operating within the skull that would lead to that position being undermined, but in the absense of that my point is purely that the human brain is just computer in the sense that it's a physcical system producing output.
- coldtea 4y ago>I don't mean that the brain is materially a computer in the sense we're used to computers in our day-to-day. That would be demonstrably false. Just as we can show humans are not formed from clay we can show humans are not formed of transistors. I don't think those using the gear metaphor, or the telegraph metaphor, and so on, believed the brain actually contains gears or has a real telegraph in the day to day sense either. The problem was the metaphor, not that they took it literaly.
- macguillicuddy 4y agoPerhaps we should avoid trying to understand the world around us in simple terms since we know we've got it wrong in the past? Or maybe it's better for us to discuss the arguments and metaphors themselves? Perhaps you could give a reason why you think the human brain is not physical system? Don't get me wrong, I do believe there's a place for the philosophy of science. But to give a list of instances where metaphors have been wong in the past as some form of argument against a given metaphor does not seem robust to me.
- coldtea 4y ago>Perhaps we should avoid trying to understand the world around us in simple terms since we know we've got it wrong in the past? You're saying it as some counter-argument, but I actually agree with it: Yes. We should learn our lesson, and try to understand complex things for what they are, and map their complexity - not think that we "get them" when we only have a simplistic reductionistic version of them... >Perhaps you could give a reason why you think the human brain is not physical system? First, where does the question come from? Who said that I think "the human brain is not physical system"? It not being "a computer" doesn't mean that it's not a physical system anymore than it not being "a gear mechanism" means it's not a physical system. Second, a rock is a physical system too, but a computer can't be a rock. A rock simulation isn't a rock either: it lacks several very important attributes of rockiness. So, the question is less about whether a brain is a physical system, than about whether modelling some physical interactions its all it takes (as opposed to the actual interactions and their "qualia"). Or even worse, whether loading a big enough statistical model is all it takes... -- as if we have already discovered the interplays and mechanisms involved in the brain, neurons, chemical pathways, and such, and modelled them, and we're just short of enough scale with GPT.
- melagonster 4y agoyes, same argument used to support AI should get copyright. they really trust human just another version of their AI.