7 ms·
I disagree. Technology is the perfect solution for problems like these. So many societal issues today arise because systems developed centuries ago cannot keep
by paxys 4y ago
I disagree. Technology is the perfect solution for problems like these. So many societal issues today arise because systems developed centuries ago cannot keep up with a population that has grown exponentially since then. Tech's core feature is being able to scale. There will be more and more systemic reliance on automation and AI as time goes on, since that's the only sensible way out.
- krsdcbl 4y agoI think that's utopian, all i see in this story is a future where some people can afford expert defendants (who'll be assisted by AI but much more effective than AI alone), while poor people are stuck with representing themselves with an app - and the government deems the problem solved, further eroding laws that guarantee legal support.
- Aerroon 4y agoBut the problem with law isn't the number of people, it's with the number of laws/binding contracts. If the US government can't even count the number of possible ways you can commit a crime then how is any of it supposed to work?
- torstenvl 4y ago> can't even count the number of possible ways you can commit a crime This strikes me as a bizarre thing to say and I'm curious what meaning you ascribe to this statement. What would be the value of counting such a thing? Why would you want your tax dollars spent on such a task?
- Aerroon 4y agoIt's a way to show that the legal system is too complex. In the 80s the Justice Department tried to count the total number of criminal laws and they failed.[0] If the government can't even keep track of the number of them, then how is it reasonable to expect regular people to follow all of them? [0] https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2013/03/frequent-reference-question-how-many-federal-laws-are-there/ https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2013/03/frequent-reference-questio...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- aww_dang 4y agoThis is a feature, not a bug for the classes which benefit from the ever expanding legal corpus. Coincidentally, politicians and lobbyists are often lawyers themselves.
- torstenvl 4y agoThat's the opposite of true. And I think you know that. It's absolutely insane that HN of all places is arguing against the concept of locality-of-reference. Given the Option A (letting DoJ prosecutors only have to carry around Title 18) versus Option B (letting lay people looking up a topic by subject matter see what crimes and penalties pertain to that subject matter in the title for that subject matter), which one is friendlier to lawyers? Which one is friendlier to lay people? Yeah, a DoJ official in 1982 probably found it inconvenient that 17 U.S.C. § 506 and 18 U.S.C. § 2319 aren't in the same deadtree volume for them to lug around. But if I'm a lay person, I'm glad that the criminal penalties for copyright infringement aren't invisible from within the chapter on copyright infringement in the title on copyright. If I were to perform a code review for a junior engineer, and they had structured their source files so that all the constructors and destructors for all of their classes were in one independent file, rather than co-located with the classes to which they pertain, they would not pass code review. The argument that it's difficult to even know how many constructors and destructors they have, and therefore memory management is too complex, would be distinctly unpersuasive. It baffles and frustrates me that HN seems to come to the exact opposite conclusion with regard to the law.
- ShamelessC 4y agoThe notion that monolithic tech actually scales is not a given. The strategy typically used to disrupt an industry is to provide a convenience for free that actually costs the company something. These costs (and liabilities) are familiar to the incumbent. That institutional knowledge disappears upon a successful disruption. The startup will now be faced with learning these things over again, “breaking things” in the process. Once enough growth has happened, monetizing via ads or increased pricing occurs. After this, you may have to squint your eyes a bit to tell if the situation before was all that much worse- or merely consisted of a different set of trade-offs. Uber comes to mind. Facebook as well.
- somenameforme 4y agoTech often misses obvious downsides, especially human, in pursuit of unrealistic idealism. A good lawyer is not just knowledgeable of law, but of people. He needs to get 12 people in front of him to agree with him. And he may even be actively misleading them when he's defending a someone whom he knows to be guilty. This comes down to reading people, reading reactions, and understanding what each of those 12 people needs to hear to have them act like he wants. Not coincidentally, the most common background of politicians: lawyers. I'd argue that the most likely scenario here is not closing the divide but widening it. Instead of public defenders, poor people will just get the bot, while those of means will get lawyers. It's akin to tech support today. In the not so distant past, it was easy to get a human on the line. Now in many cases unless you're a "special" client, or get your issue on the front page of some big social media site, you get the bot. And it sucks.
- in3d 4y agoIf poor people can only get the bot, that means the Constitution was changed. I don’t see how that could be the tech’s fault. It’s more likely that the AI would free up public defenders from things like having to answer their clients’ questions, as they could just ask the AI, allowing them to be more effective.
- logifail 4y ago> It’s more likely that the AI would free up public defendants from things like having to answer their clients’ questions, as they could just ask the AI, allowing them to be more effective Public defenders would be more effective if they didn't have to talk to their clients?
- Buraksr 4y agoI read it more as, clients have a mix of questions. Clients don’t go through the system everyday and likely have some general worries and procedural questions as a result. Clients also have a case and need to coordinate with their lawyer. AI could enable more of the latter to happen within the limited time the lawyer has for each client.
- raverbashing 4y agoPlease let me tell how technology has scaled technical support/customer support in favour of the customer in companies like Google or Facebook?
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoP.G. Moneybags here - you know when I have a support issue at either of those companies regarding the billion dollar advertising campaign I am running I never have any problems getting support. The solution seems clear - poor people just need to run billion dollar advertising campaigns to improve their support.
- fasthands9 4y agoWhile I agree that technology is the solution I disagree AI has anything to do with this. This "AI Lawyer" is about a traffic ticket. If we want to make things more fair while also enforcing the laws on the book it seems like the more straightforward tech solution is to improve traffic cameras/monitors such that tickets are given out more appropriately. Or, if it still goes to court, why not just have a system where someone can represent themselves with a form or checklist which points out the reasons they were given a ticket by mistake? Perhaps this is a good business model in the current system but its definitely not the best for society as a whole. Why do we need lawyer of any type to handle something as banal as speeding tickets?
- meowkit 4y agoNormative statements. You should be asking what are the incentives. > like the more straightforward tech solution is to improve traffic cameras/monitors such that tickets are given out more appropriately This is not straightforward from a bureaucratic sense. There is no strong incentive (that I can identify - humanitarian ideals do not count) to improve the functionality here to make traffic tickets and their resolutions more sensible. However, an AI that can resolve traffic tickets and citations might incentive a city to start gathering data more effectively - to win cases and get revenue - and that is a great incentive to improve the general tech. > Why do we need lawyer of any type to handle something as banal as speeding tickets? I also want to mention that this is a great point. The fact that my job provides legal insurance, the end result being I can get out of my traffic tickets by hiring a lawyer for free to show up and ask for a dismissal, is pretty dumb.
- Kinrany 4y agoThe threat of getting fired for incompetence is a perfectly good incentive.
- netheril96 4y agoThe people with the power to fire them don't care. So your threat is empty.
- creatonez 4y agoNo, this is not an overpopulation problem. Surprised this needs to be said.
- midoridensha 4y agoYeah, that's just a dumb claim. A bigger population means more people who can become lawyers. The problem isn't population, and never was, at least for this problem: it's always been the case that justice is arbitrary and money buys better lawyers.
- lm28469 4y ago> because systems developed centuries ago cannot keep up with a population This is _caused_ by technology, you usually don't solve a problem by adding more of its cause
- iso1631 4y ago> So many societal issues today arise because systems developed centuries ago cannot keep up with a population that has grown exponentially since then. If you had 1 lawyer per 100 people in 1800 and you had 1 lawyer per 100 people today, I don't see a scaling problem with population. Indeed in the UK in 2012 there were 120,000 solicitors for 64 million Today it's 160,000 for 68 million That's a 30% increase in lawyers with a 6% increase in population. Why do we need more lawyers per person today than 10 years ago?
- naasking 4y ago> If you had 1 lawyer per 100 people in 1800 and you had 1 lawyer per 100 people today, I don't see a scaling problem with population. [...] Why do we need more lawyers per person today than 10 years ago? How many more laws are there? Being a lawyer is like 90% reading and collating documents to filter out relevant information. We have a lot more law and a lot more documentation to sift through these days.
- Tangurena2 4y agoWe have remedies when a lawyer is incompetent. What sort of remedies do we have when the AI is incompetent? Was there some EULA? Did someone click it? Should that even be allowed? It is my position that the companies that produce AI lawyers (and "expert systems" of any type) should bear full liability for everything and anything that their product does wrong.
- notch656c 4y agoThe defendant is pro se and can choose whether to include info from the AI. If you fuck up your own pro se case because your uncle or a dumb robot told you something stupid that's on you.