4 ms·
The MBE is a knowledge test. It tests how well you can memorize a bunch of state law that you’ll never use after the bar exam. Constrained by the multiple choic
by rayiner 4y ago
The MBE is a knowledge test. It tests how well you can memorize a bunch of state law that you’ll never use after the bar exam. Constrained by the multiple choice format, I’d suspect an AI could actually do quite well on the MBE portion. But nobody really cares about the bar exam.
The exam the industry is actually built around is the LSAT, which decides the rank of law school you get into, which in turn decides what career pathways are available. That’s a logical reasoning test with no knowledge component. It would be interesting to apply GPT to that.
- worldsavior 4y ago> It tests how well you can memorize a bunch of state law that you’ll never use after the bar exam. What makes you a good lawyer is if you remember all those laws, and you know how to find them in your mind. Those laws are mostly necessary.
- tptacek 4y agoLawyers specialize, just like software developers do, and they also look stuff up, just like software developers do.
- lostlogin 4y agoI wonder if lawyers find their subtly different questions marked as duplicates?
- worldsavior 4y agoThat doesn't conflict.
- oneoff786 4y agoIt does though. You’re not a good programmer for memorizing a bunch of functions. You’re not a good lawyer for memorizing a bunch of laws. Even if they’re the ones you need.
- worldsavior 4y agoHe said exactly the same thing. A lawyer needs to remember those laws, and knowing how to find them. A software developer needs to have knowledge in security or whatever, and know how to code (which uses this knowledge).
- oneoff786 4y agoNo, he said you need to know how to find them IN YOUR MIND which is simply another way of saying memorizing them. It’s wrong. > What makes you a good lawyer is if you remember all those laws, and you know how to find them in your mind.
- worldsavior 4y agoNo one remembers sentences word by word. Knowing how to find them means finding words which will lead you for the final sentence. Anyway, comparing with a software developer is an unvalid comparison. They are not the same.
- singleshot_ 4y agoThe Multistate Bar Exam, of course, does not test state law. After all, how would they decide which state’s law to test? Accordingly, the NCBE, in their unending wisdom, quizzes applicants on the common law of 18th century England. I’d also argue that quite a few people care about the bar exam (e.g., the people who study for it for months, or who fail it and cannot practice) while there are loads of lawyers who care very little about the LSAT (e.g., I never took it).
- rayiner 4y agoThe MBE tests a generic version of state law that reflects the majority rule in the states or model codes such as the Model Penal Code or UCC. (It also tests the federal rules of civil procedure and evidence.) The law of all states except Louisiana is based on English common law, and so the MBE reflects that. But it is not a test of 18th century English common law. For example the criminal law questions reflect the model penal code which was developed in the 1960s.
- singleshot_ 4y agoI guess I’ll renew my question, then: which state law does the MBE test? The answer “a generic mishmash of least common denominator state uniform law” ain’t no state I ever heard of, anticipating your answer. If you are barred in this state I guess I could take your word for it. Also I’m not even sure what to say about the idea that “larceny by trick” is statutory criminal law under the MPC but more power to you if it is, I guess.